Bungie promises to rebalance Destiny 2’s loot boxes, raids
In its first development roadmap update of 2018, Destiny developer Bungie is promising to rebalance Destiny 2‘s microtransaction and raids systems to give players more satisfying rewards that are less dependent on luck.
In the lengthy development update posted Thursday evening, Game Director Christopher Barrett admitted up front that, currently, “the scales are tipped too far towards Tess,” the owner of the game’s much maligned microtransaction-fueled Eververse store. The Eververse was “never intended to be a substitute for end game content and rewards,” Barrett writes.
To that end, Barrett says the game will be shifting the item balance so desirable items like Ghosts, Sparrows, and ships can be earned directly as “activity rewards” for in-game actions rather than as random drops from Bright Engrams. Barrett also promises more “direct purchase options” and adjustments that will “allow players to get the items they want more often” without relying on the luck of the draw. These changes should start rolling out February 13.
Bungie is also promising to rework the rewards for Destiny 2‘s end-game Raids “to make them more unique and interesting.” New Raid-specific perks and guaranteed item drops from major encounters should help ameliorate widespread complaints that the difficult raids simply aren’t worth the effort at the moment.
Barrett says Bungie is “still investigating changes to XP earn rates,” following a debacle in which the discovery of a hidden XP scaling system caused the company to slow down overall leveling rates even further. “Right now, it’s too slow in general and lopsided towards grinding specific activities (which is not a fun grind) and we want to fix that without making those activities low value to players who aren’t grinding them (fairness is cool),” Barrett writes.
Do you remember where you were during the 2010 Boston nuclear meltdown?
Advisor Wright seems kind of nervous about that plane crash.
In the SNES version, this purple beat is replaced by Bowser.
The on-screen cursor and side menus let you do pretty much anything they could do in the PC version.
The NES version has seaports, but no boats.
Calculating all the interrelated variables for a city this complex gets a bit hairy on hardware like that on the NES.
Gamers of a certain age probably remember that Nintendo worked with Maxis to port a version of the seminal SimCity to the brand-new SNES in 1991. What most gamers probably don’t realize is that an NES version of the game was developed at the same time and cancelled just before its planned release.
That version of the game was considered lost for decades until two prototype cartridges surfaced in the collecting community last year. One of those prototypes has now been obtained and preserved by the Video Game History Foundation’s (VGHF’s) Frank Cifaldi, who demonstrated the emulated ROM publicly for the first time at MAGFest last weekend.
From lost to found
As Cifaldi recounted, the story of the NES SimCity began when legendary Nintendo designer Shigeru Miyamoto says he had an idea for a game where you build and maintain an entire city. After hearing of a similar game on PC and trying SimCity for himself, Miyamoto was impressed enough to get Nintendo to purchase the console rights for the game, rather than trying to make a competing title.
While the SNES version of SimCity was released in August 1991, the NES version was summarily canceled and wouldn’t be heard from for over 15 years. That’s when a 2006 issue of Nintendo Power mentioned that Managing Editor Scott Pelland had a “far in development” golden prototype cartridge sitting in his desk.
A very short demonstration of the SimCity NES prototype from when it was first discovered last August.
A short demonstration video posted at the time proved the prototypes were in working order. The demo also highlighted very basic gameplay functionality. Back in Time then showed the cartridges off at a Portland Retro Game Expo booth in October, where the carts were eventually auctioned off to the highest bidder.
Pat “The NES Punk” Contri recalled that auction in a recent podcast and mentioned that, at one point, it looked like the prototype might be effectively lost to history once again.
“There was a chance the game wasn’t going to be dumped—that someone was going to purchase both for an insane amount of money and lock both SimCity carts away,” Contri said. “Which would potentially mean no one would have access to the ROM, which would be awful, obviously.”
Fortunately, game collector Steve Lin was able to make what Contri called “a substantial purchase” to secure one of the prototypes, which was then dumped and preserved as a ROM file by Cifaldi’s Video Game History Foundation. On the NES Punk podcast, collector Ian Ferguson recalls the moment he and Cifaldi loaded up the ROM for the first time. “That was original NES title music we haven’t heard,” he said with awe. “That’s a nice title screen… We were reveling in it for a minute.”
The prototype
[embedded content]
The Video Game History Foundation’s Frank Cifaldi shows the preserved SimCity ROM file publicly for the first time at MAGFest 2018. Video by Kyle Orland.
While Cifaldi is still working on a full analysis and write-up of the prototype, he showed the emulated ROM file at a MAGFest panel on the status of lost NES games last weekend. As you can see in the video above, the game is pretty similar to the SNES release, right down to the green-haired advisor Dr. Wright (a Nintendo creation and homage to SimCity creator Will Wright).
The NES version even includes the same pre-built scenarios that appeared in the SNES version, including a Boston nuclear meltdown in the far-future year of 2010(!). The biggest immediate difference is in the Monster Attack disaster, which uses a generic purple monster instead of the Bowser cameo found in the SNES version.
Cifaldi also mentioned that features like nuclear meltdowns and boats hadn’t been fully coded for the NES prototype. And, at points, Cifaldi points out that “the NES is really struggling with its calculations. You see how nothing has power? That’s because it’s still doing the math behind the scenes to figure out what buildings have power… it’s not an easy calculation for a system like the NES.”
That slowdown could help explain why the NES version was eventually scrapped, or it could be a sign of an early version that would have worked just fine with a bit more polish. Nintendo could very well have canned the NES port to avoid creating more competition for the brand-new SNES, as well.
Whether or not the VGHF or another owner will release the prototype ROM publicly is still unclear. Regardless, the version that’s now being preserved by the Foundation ensures that this gaming history rarity will at least be accessible to historians and researchers well into the future.
Ars community gives more than $36,000 in annual charity drive
Over the last month or so, I’ve been pestering Ars readers to give as much as they could in our 2017 Charity Drive sweepstake. All told, Ars Technica readers donated $36,738.11 to Child’s Play and the EFF through our 2017 charity drive. That’s a bit below the roughly $38,000 pace in the last two years, but the total is still much higher than every other year we’ve run the drive. Good job!
Thanks to everyone who gave whatever they could. We’re still very early in the process of selecting and notifying winners of our swag giveaway, so don’t fret if you haven’t heard if you’re a winner yet. In the meantime, enjoy these quick stats from the 2017 drive.
2017 Fundraising total: $36,012.37 (down $2,848.69 from 2016)
Total given to Child’s Play: $13,876.76 (down $1,162.98)
Total given to the EFF: $22,135.61 (down $1,562.76)
Number of individual donations: 545 (down 120)
Child’s Play donations: 265 (down 85)
EFF donations: 277 (down 38)
Average donation: $66.44 (up $8.19)
Child’s Play average donation: $52.37 (up $9.51)
EFF average donation: $79.91 (up $4.45)
Median donation: $25 (even)
Median Child’s Play donation: $25 (up $0.04)
Median EFF donation: $25 (even)
Top single donation: $1,500 (to EFF)
Donations of $1,000 or more: 4
Donations of $100 or more: 119
$1 donations: 4 (every little bit helps!)
Total charity donations from Ars Technica drives since 2007 (approximate): $282,715.24
2016: $38,738.11
2015: $38,861.06
2014: $25,094.31
2013: $23,570.13
2012: $28,713.52
2011: ~$26,000
2010: ~$24,000
2009: ~$17,000
2008: ~$12,000
2007: ~$10,000
https://arstechnica.com/?p=1242801
YouTube finally hands down punishment to creator for posting dead body video
Valentina Palladino
About one year after the YouTube ad-pocalypse shook up the online video website, the company is handing down a punishment to another YouTube star for posting an obscene video. Logan Paul, a YouTube creator with 15 million subscribers, has been removed from Google’s Preferred ad platform. YouTube also won’t feature Paul in the fourth season of Foursome, a YouTube Red show, and Paul’s other Originals projects have been put on hold. This comes nearly two weeks after Paul posted a video of him visiting Aokigahara in Japan, also known as the “suicide forest,” and prominently featuring a dead human body in the video and in the video’s thumbnail.
YouTube’s punishment comes after the company made this original statement about this incident:
Our hearts go out to the family of the person featured in the video. YouTube prohibits violent or gory content posted in a shocking, sensational or disrespectful manner. If a video is graphic, it can only remain on the site when supported by appropriate educational or documentary information and in some cases it will be age-gated. We partner with safety groups such as the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline to provide educational resources that are incorporated in our YouTube Safety Center.
Amidst outrage from the YouTube community and some celebrities, Logan Paul removed the video from YouTube and issued two apologies before announcing he would take time off from YouTube “to reflect.”
How did a dead body end up on YouTube?
A little more than a week after appearing onTop Chef, Paul uploaded the video in question on December 31, 2017. It showed him and some friends entering Aokigahara and finding the hanging body of a man who presumably had committed suicide. The video’s thumbnail also included an image of the body. The video gleaned millions of views and sat on the YouTube Trending page for a while before community members and celebrities including Aaron Paul and Chrissy Teigen called Paul out for his offensive and disrespectful video. Paul removed the video from his channel shortly thereafter.
YouTube issued its original statement above, and, a few days later, the company said it was looking into “further consequences” for Paul. The newly announced actions appear to be those consequences. The company also issued an open letter to its community on Twitter, acknowledging its “lack of communication” and slow response time.
Google Preferred is the company’s premiere advertising platform, and removing Paul from it means he won’t make as much money from monetizing his YouTube videos as he previously did. Putting his YouTube Red and Originals projects “on hold” shows that YouTube isn’t ready to have him star in any of its huge productions made for its paid video platform.
However, it’s unclear how Paul’s video was allowed to stay up on YouTube as long as it did. YouTube’s guidelines do not allow violent or gory content posted in a manner that’s meant to be shocking, sensationalist, or disrespectful. While it’s likely that YouTube would have eventually flagged the video, its systems and moderators did not do so before the video garnered millions of views and likes.
Reminiscent of past controversies
YouTube has chosen to police its creators more than ever before after last year’s ad-pocalypse, which began as advertisers pulled their ads from YouTube after learning some ran in front of extremist and offensive content. Last year’s Pewdiepie controversy also contributed to the ad-pocalypse—YouTube’s most-subscribed-to creator, whose real name is Felix Kjellberg, was removed from Google Preferred, had his YouTube Red show cancelled, and was dropped by Disney Maker Studios after a compilation of clips of him making anti-Semitic jokes went viral.
In the first half of 2017, YouTube introduced a lot of new rules for creators as well as tools that allow advertisers to better control where their ads appear on the website. The new YouTube guidelines and rules surrounding offensive and distasteful content have been seen as unclear to many, as YouTubers big and small have their content demonetized or flagged (sometimes incorrectly so) by YouTube’s system.
The system is clearly still a work in progress, as shown by YouTube’s slow response to the Logan Paul situation. Community members were some of the loudest voices calling upon YouTube to act, but noticeably absent from the outraged parties were individual advertisers. So far, there have been no reports of advertisers pulling ads from YouTube in response to the Logan Paul situation. It’s possible that, after YouTube’s response to the ad-pocalypse, advertisers feel more comfortable with the effectiveness of YouTube’s new tools and the online video company’s ability to police creators.
While community members and some of the public have called for Paul’s channel to be terminated, it doesn’t appear that’s going to happen any time soon. Paul would have to accrue three account strikes within three months for YouTube to terminate his account (YouTube reportedly hit Paul’s account with one strike for this incident).
Now, there are two ways YouTube could proceed after handing down Paul’s punishment: the company could consider the situation handled and do nothing further, or we could see YouTube instate new community guidelines or rules that pertain to this incident. Considering the fact that this situation hasn’t damaged YouTube monetarily (at least not immediately), we may not see any additional rules from YouTube. The company handled the situation with the rules it had in place, albeit slowly. But the repercussions from the Logan Paul incident will likely be felt by creators, large and small (mostly small), on which YouTube cracks down even harder to prevent content like this from being posted in the future.
https://arstechnica.com/?p=1242679
Dark Souls, Donkey Kong Country lead a wave of Nintendo Switch ports
The 14-minute trailer-packed video is filled with new footage and information, but we’ve condensed the important news down below if you can’t watch right now:
Ports
Dark Souls Remastered: No gameplay details were provided for this one, but given the title, it’ll surely be a graphically touched-up version of From Software’s hard-as-nails, 2011 dungeon crawler. Release date is set for May 25, and PS4, XB1 and PC versions will also be available.
The World Ends with You Final Remix: Square Enix’s Nintendo DS cult classic Japanese action RPG gets an HD remaster that includes a new scenario “that gets to the heart of the story.” Arriving some time this year.
Hyrule Warriors Definitive Edition: This Zelda-themed version of the Dynasty Warriors design combines all the maps and missions from the Wii U and 3DS versions of the game and adds new Breath of the Wild costumes for Link and Zelda. Coming some time this spring.
Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze: The tough-but-fun Wii U platform game comes to Switch with Funky Kong as a new playable character, capable of a double hover jump and “infinite rolls.” Coming May 4.
Ys VIII: Lacrimosa of DANA: A port of the game that recently revived the dormant, long-running Japanese RPG series comes to the Nintendo Switch this summer.
New game announcements
Mario Tennis Aces brings back the fast-paced, over-the-top, super-ability-infused sporting franchise with a new Story Mode that includes specific missions and bosses to face. Coming this spring.
SNK Heroines: Tag Team Frenzy looks like a female-fighter-focused version of the popular King of Fighters franchise, with new Dream Finish moves to round things out a bit. Coming this summer.
DLC
Super Mario Odyssey gets a new “Luigi’s Balloon World” online hide-and-seek mode as part of a free update in February. One player has 30 seconds to hide a balloon somewhere in the level, and another player has to track it down with the help of a guiding arrow. New costumes and photo filters will also be available.
Mario + Rabbids: Kingdom Battle will get Donkey Kong as a playable character alongside themed content in a paid update this spring.
Pokken Tournament DX will see new characters and moves as part of a paid DLC Battle Pack.
Other
Air-dashing 2D platformer Celeste is coming January 25.
3D platformer Fe is coming February 16.
4-player co-op platformer Kirby Star Allies is coming March 16.
Payday 2 is (still) coming to Switch February 27.
A demo for Dragon Quest Builders hits the eShop today.
https://arstechnica.com/?p=1242687
Hyperkin plans to release a new (old) Game Boy in 2018
Enlarge/ Not an actual picture of the Ultra Game Boy.
There has been plenty of nostalgic attention being paid to classic console hardware updates in recent years, from Nintendo’s official plug-and-playClassic Edition consoles to third-party clone consoles. But for all the focus on the TV-based game consoles of yesteryear, we haven’t seen much corporate interest in recreating the portable system of the past.
That now seems set to change, as Gizmodo reports from CES on the Ultra Game Boy, an aluminum-cased portable console that resembles the slimmer Game Boy Pocket more than the bulky 1989 original system. The case’s authenticity extends down to a cartridge slot that supports classic games and those familiar volume and contrast knobs on the edge, along with a new third knob letting players adjust the color of the system’s backlight.
Gizmodo reports a six-hour battery life with USB-C charging for the prototype, which also sports stereo speakers and dual audio outputs targeted at chiptune makers. Hyperkin is reportedly still finalizing the hardware and is aiming for a 2018 release at “under $100,” according to the report.
This isn’t Hyperkin’s first foray into Game Boy nostalgia. The company first introduced its SmartBoy accessory as a joke, then actually released the Android phone sleeve, which provides authentic Game Boy controls and cartridge support for smartphone-based emulators.
The Ultra Game Boy removes the need for a separate Android phone and slims down the form factor quite a bit. But it’s not clear yet if it will provide emulator-style benefits like Super Game Boy color palettes, save states, and the ability to save ROM images of your actual cartridges. It’s also not clear if Game Boy Color games will be supported or whether the Ultra Game Boy is simulating the actual Game Boy hardware or relying on less reliable software emulation for the console.
With Hyperkin laying down the gauntlet, the pressure is on Nintendo to hurry up and announce the Game Boy Classic Edition everyone assumes is being planned. Pack-in games like Tetris and Pokemon Red and Blue and that rerelease would pretty much be a guaranteed best-seller.
https://arstechnica.com/?p=1242259
The rise, fall, and rise of MDickie—or, how to be the best worst game developer
Stay with us; this will make sense I swear.
MDickie.com / TommyWiseau.com
Recently, Mat Dickie boarded a train out of London and came across a kid, face-down in a smartphone game, sitting in Dickie’s ticketed seat. As the furious tapping played out in front of him, Dickie contemplated whether he should hassle this transit gamer or just find an empty spot elsewhere. The solution ultimately revealed itself when the developer got close enough to catch a glimpse of the boy’s screen: Wrestling Revolution 3D.
By now, the sports simulator gaming genre is as tried and true as sports itself. The Football Manager franchise has been delighting international audiences for 25 years-plus, nudging even stateside developers to take notice within the last decade (how else do you explain Madden spin-off, NFL Head Coach, sneaking into a release cycle full of familiar 2K titles?). But Wrestling Revolution 3D holds an unusual position within this landscape—it’s the genre’s most unexpected yet successful mobile title.
In 2017, Wrestling Revolution 3D became the first sports sim to surpass 50 million downloads. Today, the Google Play Store lists it in the “50,000,000 to 100,000,000” download category. Officially licensed games from the UFC and WWE, for comparison, stall at around 10 million downloads. Dickie knows all this because he’s not only a fan—he’s a long-time independent developer better known as MDickie. Wrestling Revolution 3D is his most successful game to date.
“I didn’t know whether to throw him off the train or pat him on the back,” Dickie jokes.
Looking at Wrestling Revolution 3D, you’d never guess its historic level of success or pervasiveness. The graphics are blocky and dated compared to modern sports simulators. It doesn’t enjoy a professional-league licensing deal, so the characters are all weird knock-offs (“Nightshift” and not The Undertaker; “Jimi Sierra” and not John Cena; “Hank Slogan” and… you get it). And the gameplay, well… it may enjoy some level of fandom because of just how objectively bad it is.
For many, MDickie may be to video games what The Room’s Tommy Wiseau is to film. Allow an August 2017 play-through from gaming site Giant Bomb—in which players call the experience “hell on Earth”—to partially explain.
[embedded content]
Search YouTube and you’ll find plenty of MDickie-inspired stream videos like this (for virtually any of his games).
“This game is 39 megs, and I feel like [Dickie] is in on it—I think he knows these games are kind of bad,” host Dan Ryckert says in the introduction.
“I’ve been hearing about the MDickie stuff for years… the thing people always talk about are the customization elements,” co-host Alex Navarro says. (In fairness, the duo soon scrolls through a seemingly endless amount of character selections and match customization options.) “But it’s the part where you play them that people seem a little less hot on.”
Ryckert goes on to call the game “goofy as shit” and “janky and broken, but in a way I find very funny. I may get more enjoyment out of this than I do the 2K games.”
Navarro compares the experience to playing with ’90s action figures. “The kind of way you’d wrestle with them is to make all the moves at 2/3rd speed and you’d have to laboriously flip them to make the wrestlers do the moves,” he says. “That’s what this looks like—it looks like someone playing with action figures that are as stiff as early ’90s action figures. There’s no reason they should have to move at this speed, but they do.”
So to carry the Wiseau analogy through, by some accounts Dickie has singlehandedly made some of the best worst video games in history. But unlike Wiseau—who made one singularly bad film and only later built something resembling a side gig from it—Dickie has enjoyed a nearly 20-year career independently creating a range of surprisingly deep, accomplished, and janky video games by himself.
Wrestling Revolution 3D may represent something of a commercial and statistical breakthrough, but it’s merely the latest chapter in Dickie’s story of perseverance and peculiarity. And throughout it all, the developer has stayed true to himself while the whole industry changed right alongside.
stunt.zip
Born in the early ’80s, Dickie grew up in the height of the console era. Accordingly, he wanted to be a game developer ever since he was a child, sketching out ideas for games with their own internal logic. And this looked like a fairly realistic goal for a young boy at the time. The history of video games before the late 1990s/early 2000s megaboom is characterized by committed amateurs and solitary enthusiasts making games in their bedrooms. Even video games like PONG were, in reality, small productions coded by a single person or a handful of collaborators. Many of the console games in the first 1980s gaming boom were produced by hobbyist gamers who simply managed to sell their work to a distributor.
In 2000, when he was a mere teenager, Dickie publicly released his first game. It was a 450-kilobyte .zip file named stunt.zip; the game itself was called Hardy Boyz Stunt Challenge. It allowed players to take on the role of one of the two Hardy Boyz, professional wrestlers for the then-WWF who had a penchant for jumping off high places, like the tops of ladders or bleachers in sports arenas. Players essentially gained points for the complexity of the stunts they performed.
Starting with Hardy Boyz Stunt Challenge, wrestling would be fertile ground for MDickie.
It took Dickie two weeks to make the game after he walked through his local branch of Woolworths and spotted a package on the software shelves called Div Games Studios. Created by a Spanish company, Div was a programming language kind-of sort-of like C that was born during the days of MS-DOS gaming.
“It promised to make game development easy,” Dickie tells Ars. “I picked it up, took it home, and spent the summer of 2000 teaching myself how to use it from the examples.”
The 17-year-old was studying computing at college at the time. So after just a couple weeks, he managed to build the basic mechanics of the game: jump off as high a point as possible, do some crazy stuff, earn points. He was more-or-less satisfied with his work, so he got in touch with a wrestling website called Tha Warzone that he used to frequent. “I said, ‘I’ve made a game about wrestling; it’s quite topical. Why don’t you throw it up on your website and let people download it?’”
The owner of the site agreed to do so, and around 15,000 people downloaded the game. “The feedback was really positive,” says Dickie. “I was getting fan mail saying, ‘Can we have more of this?’ That gave me the impetus to make more.”
Dickie soon wrote down an affirmation he’d cribbed from his childhood hero, Bruce Lee (words from the martial arts’ legend still greet visitors to Dickie’s website). At an early age, Lee had written down that, in 10 years’ time, he’d be the highest-paid movie star in Hong Kong—and, lo and behold, he ended up doing just that. Dickie’s affirmation was a little different and multifaceted.
“I want to make games for a living. I want to run my own wrestling company,” Dickie recalls. “Be rich. Travel the world.”
Eagle-eyed YouTuber discovers ongoing EA online-matchmaking shenanigans
Enlarge/ Recently discovered EA research aims to keep players “engaged” with its single-player and multiplayer products. The methods explored in published papers are a little subtler than the above illustration.
The practice of incorporating micro transactions and loot boxes into video games has grown from sporadic to omnipresent in recent years. 2017 saw the loot box trend explode and even bleed over from a “cosmetic” model to one that affects gameplay. But in-game items like loot boxes—which commonly appear in multiplayer games—are worthless to publishers if players don’t engage with them.
The discovered papers emphasize ways to keep players “engaged” with different types of games, as opposed to quitting them early, by manipulating their difficulty without necessarily telling players. These papers were published as part of a conference in April 2017, and they indicate that EA’s difficulty- and matchmaking-manipulation efforts may have already been tested in live games, may be tested in future games, and are officially described as a means to fulfill the “objective function” of, among other things, getting players to “spend” money in games.
The EOMM paper, which is co-authored by researchers from EA and UCLA and was funded in part by an NSF grant, applies more directly to EA’s latest online-gaming controversies. This paper outlines a way to adjust games whose difficulty begins and ends not with computer-controlled difficulty issues (enemy strength, puzzle designs, etc.) but with real-life opponents.
“Current matchmaking systems… pair similarly skilled players on the assumption that a fair game is best player experience [sic],” the paper begins. “We will demonstrate, however, that this intuitive assumption sometimes fails and that matchmaking based on fairness is not optimal for engagement.”
Elsewhere in the paper, the EA researchers point out that other researchers seem to assume that “a fun match should have players act in roles with perceivably joyful role distribution. However, it is still a conceptual, heuristic-based method without experiment showing that such matchmaking system indeed improves concrete engagement metrics [sic].”
In other words, the researchers are operating in a data-driven manner, clarifying that they don’t necessarily see concepts like “fun” or “fairness” driving the engagement that embodies their thesis. And, as the paper notes, it’s engagement, not fairness or fun, that’s linked directly to a player’s willingness to continue spending money in the game.
EA’s researchers don’t necessarily see concepts like “fun” or “fairness” contributing to their thesis.
To test this thesis, in early 2016 EA ran a test on 1.68 million unique players engaged in 36.9 million matches of an unnamed 1v1 game whose matches can end in wins, losses, or draws. Though the paper doesn’t offer further specifics, EA Sports series like FIFA and NHL would fit the description given.
During the testing period, players were analyzed based on their skill level (itself based on wins, losses, and draws) and also their likelihood of “churning” away for at least eight hours after the match. The players were then assigned into one of four pools of different matchmaking techniques: skill-based; EOMM-sorted (the new matching algorithm intended to reduce churn); “WorstMM” (the complete opposite of the EOMM algorithm); and completely random matching.
The paper describes “existing matchmaking methods that heuristically pair similarly skilled co-players,” suggesting that live players were unwittingly dropped into EA’s experimental matchmaking pools for this engagement research. But thanks to vague methodology descriptions and repeated discussion of “simulations” on existing player and match data, the paper makes it hard to determine if actual, live matchmaking was affected. (EA has yet to respond to Ars Technica’s request for comment.)
This EOMM paper also isn’t entirely clear about how a player’s perceived attributes—including “skill, play history, and style”—correlate with the same player’s churn likelihood. This means the paper’s thesis can’t be written out as simply as something like “bad players will play more often if they’re paired with even worse players.”
Ultimately, the paper concludes that this EOMM method of matchmaking reduced churn compared to the existing, skill-based matchmaking standard. In four of its five player-count studies, EOMM bested skill-based matchmaking by up to 0.9 percent; the exception was a smaller pool of players, in which skill-based matchmaking reduced churn more than EOMM by a factor of 1.2 percent. In all cases, EOMM bested both the random and “WorstMM” results.
The authors concede that this matchmaking system must evolve to account for factors such as team-battle video games, larger multiplayer scenarios, network connectivity issues, friends lists, and more. They say that “we will explore” all of those scenarios in future tests. The authors also make clear where this modeling could eventually lead: “we can even change the objective function to other core game metrics of interest, such as play time, retention, or spending. EOMM allows one to easily plug in different types of predictive models to achieve the optimization.”
If our guess about EA Sports 1v1 games is correct, then that division’s “Ultimate Team” products, driven by loot boxes and micro transactions, are already prime for the picking.
Missing whale metrics
The Dynamic Difficulty Adjustment [DDA] paper had previously been found and circulated by fans and critics in late 2017, though perhaps it didn’t receive much widespread attention because it didn’t declare much new in the games industry. This research paper is a higher-level version of automatic difficulty adjustment features that have appeared in single-player games for decades. Simpler versions of this mechanic have appeared in the likes of Crash Bandicoot and newer Super Mario games.
This EA research-driven take worked, according to the paper, by analyzing and auto-adjusting games of a mobile, EA-published match-three puzzle game. The paper wanted to see whether automatic adjustments would keep players engaged instead of churning away out of frustration or dissatisfaction. (The unnamed game in question could be a version of Bejeweled, the biggest match-three series made by EA-owned studio PopCap.)
The paper’s opening abstract could have settled on simply saying that its preliminary DDA system netted a nine-percent “improvement in player engagement,” but the researchers chose to attach an economic model to the findings: that the DDA system had a “neutral impact on monetization.” (Certain free-to-play versions of Bejeweled allow players to spend real money to earn a performance-boosting “coins” currency faster.) The researchers go on to speculate that this was because its algorithms retained players that have a high risk of churn but who are also “less likely to spend [money].”
Coincidentally, the paper’s conclusion mentions a desire to expand DDA testing to “more complicated games with non-linear or multiple progressions, such as role-playing games (RPGs).” We’d also like to see further research to show whether games with more robust online communities or social features, such as online score comparisons, might influence higher-spending “whale” players to spend more, or at least attract more likely whales.
Coming soon? Already here?
Separately, the papers analyze retention methods that, as described, have not been disclosed to players—unlike the clearly marked boosts and aids in newer Super Mario games and the “safe mode” added to horror game Soma. It’s unclear whether EA would actively inform players of these kinds of systems, should they be employed in either single-player or multiplayer games, or whether they’ve already arrived unannounced in EA-published games that launched after these early 2016 tests.
Meanwhile, EA has two big games on the horizon that may marry the single-player challenge tweaks of the DDA study and the matchmaking-driven augmentations of the EOMM one. In addition to Bioware’s upcoming Anthem, an apparent space-combat co-op RPG that looks similar to Destiny, EA recently announced sweeping changes to an unnamed Star Wars game. Those changes should add “a broader experience that allows for more variety and player agency,” which suggests a switch from its original single-player-only vision to a shared-multiplayer one. This 2017 research strongly suggests that EA has a keen interest in applying these methodologies to its future games, but how these single-player and multiplayer systems might combine to quietly and simultaneously manipulate a game’s playerbase is not yet clear.
EA did not immediately respond to Ars’ questions about the studies.
https://arstechnica.com/?p=1241989
Star Citizen maker says engine suit “never should have been filed”
Crytek’s lawsuit alleged that CIG broke a CryEngine licensing agreement and infringed on Crytek’s copyrights by switching from CryEngine to Amazon’s Lumberyard platform in late 2016. But CIG contends that Crytek’s complaint selectively and misleadingly quotes from the full Game License Agreement signed by both parties.
While Crytek argued that the license agreement couldn’t be extended for use in CIG’s spin-off game Squadron 42, for instance, the actual license agreement CIG shared with the court says directly up front that it applies to “the game currently entitled ‘Space Citizen’ [sic] and its related space fighter game ‘Squadron 42.'”
CIG also argues that the “exclusive rights” to CryEngine granted in the license agreement do not extend to a requirement to use that engine. “The plain language of the GLA where the grant of rights to CIG appears, plus the well-established concept of an exclusive license, instead establish that the word ‘exclusively’ simply means that CIG’s right to use the Engine in the Game is exclusive to CIG and Crytek may not give that right to anyone else,” the company writes.
“No provision in the GLA stats that CIG ‘shall not’ embed any other engine or third-party software in the Game,” the response continues.
By extension, the requirement to list Crytek’s copyright notices only applies when CryEngine was being used, CIG argues. Furthermore, CIG argues, the original agreement bars either party from seeking damages, as Crytek is attempting with its lawsuit. And Roberts Space Industries, which is named in the original Crytek complaint, didn’t actually sign the agreement in question, CIG contends.
The agreement submitted to the court reveals that CIG agreed to pay €1.85 million (about $2.21 million) for its CryEngine license, to be paid over a period of five years. That’s a drop in the bucket compared to the over $176 million CIG has raised so far, but it’s still a pretty big expense line for a game engine that won’t end up being used directly in the long-delayed final game.https://arstechnica.com/?p=1241037
“The least-worst idea we had”—The creation of the Age of Empires empire
Enlarge/ We’ve enjoyed Age of Empires so much, we’d probably play this version, too.
Not much about Age of Empires isn’t epic.
Over the last 20 years, these epoch-spanning games have starred more than 50 historical civilizations, sales have surpassed more than 20 million units, and a core fanbase of hundreds of thousands has put hours upon hours into playing one series entry or another on a weekly basis. Age of Empires is one of the most influential strategy games of all time. And far from fading into obscurity, as history is wont to do, Empires is now squarely back in the (games-playing) public consciousness.
With a new Age game in development and a “definitive edition” reboot of the original just around the corner—and given our recent foray into the evolution of the entire real-time strategy genre—we thought it’d be interesting to dig into the history of this RTS series. After all, RTS games like Age have introduced millions of impressionable youths to the delights of… well, history.
I spoke to several of the two dozen or so people who worked on the original Age of Empires about how it was made. I asked them to reflect on the series’ triumphs, successes, failures, and legacy. This is a compressed retelling of their many stories, focusing on the early days—the building of the foundations that are so central to both the Age story and each of the Age games—but spanning the full breadth of the series’ life.
Behold, the original Age of Empires.
The series’ isometric perspective was inspired by SimCity.
When the Goodman brothers needed help solidifying a game concept, they called on an old friend: Bruce Shelley, who had worked on Sid Meier’s Civilization and the business simulation Railroad Tycoon.
In many regards, the original Age was an evolution on big RTS predecessors, Red Alert and Warcraft II. But underneath all the advances, the game was full of the same familiar RTS loops of resource gathering, unit micromanagement, and expanding your base.
Dawn of Man
The seed of the idea for what would become Age of Empires lay with Tony Goodman, the co-founder of an IT consulting company called Ensemble Corporation.
Goodman loved games. He and his brother Rick had been avid board gamers since they were kids. One day, in 1994, thinking that Microsoft’s release of WinG, a DirectX predecessor, had presented a great new opportunity, Tony struck on the idea to do a game as a side project. He didn’t know what it would be yet—only that it would be fun to make something and see if it goes anywhere.
“He just came in one day, out of the blue, to my recollection,” Rick Goodman told Ars. Tony addressed the engineering team: “Hey, would any of you rather be programming games than databases?”
“I think there was a strange reaction in the room because people didn’t know quite how to perceive that,” Rick continued. “But it turned out he was serious.”
Tony then set about organizing a small gaming cabal at the company. The cabal started to experiment with building an engine, its isometric perspective inspired by SimCity. Tony and programmer Angelo Laudon put together a simple tech demo with a tank. You could drive it around and shoot palm trees—that was about it. Still, the demo solidified the idea that they could make a game.
Now, the team just needed a good idea.
To help come up with a solid concept, Tony brought in Rick and their friend Bruce Shelley, who lived up in Chicago but periodically travelled down to Dallas for short stays. Shelley was the co-creator of both the hit game Sid Meier’s Civilization and the business simulation Railroad Tycoon. Tony and his cohorts had met Shelley in a board gaming club when they were teenagers still at school and Shelley was in college.
They spent the next few months discussing countless ideas. Tony suggested something set on a desert island that would have been similar to the television show Lost. But the idea that really got them thinking was a suggestion by another programmer, Tim Deen, to riff off Blizzard’s real-time strategy game Warcraft.
They looked at Warcraft and Westwood’s Command & Conquer. When Rick suggested they borrow from these, Shelley brought up his past experience with the games and suggested they do a kind of real-time take on Civilization.
“They nodded their head and agreed that maybe, of all the bad ideas, it was the least-worst idea we had,” recalled Rick.
“I had an idea that the game would start with the map almost covered with ice, like an Ice Age, and you have little settlers,” Shelley said. “And as the ice recedes, resources are uncovered, and you can start building, and then you proceed from there to build the first civilizations on Earth.”
Another nine months would go by before the entrepreneurs would complete the first working prototype of the game. They gave it the working title of Dawn of Man. The game had a tree, some grass, and a town center composed of tent huts on a 2D isometric grid. A lone animated caveman would chop wood and carry it to the town center, incrementing a resource counter. There might have also been some deer running around that you could hunt for food.
“It seems like an incredibly long time for such a small prototype,” Rick said. “But we started with nothing, and we didn’t have any people that really knew how to make a game. So I guess in that sense we were on schedule.”
Once this basic proof of concept was sorted out, attention turned to the game’s design. Rick Goodman took the lead here, with help from Shelley and another childhood friend of theirs by the name of Brian Sullivan.