Amateur sleuths help solve 160-year mystery by decoding Charles Dickens letter

Section of the so-called "Tavistock letter," written by Charles Dickens in his idiosyncratic shorthand. The crowd-sourced transcription, now 70 percent complete, reveals a dispute between Dickens and The Times of London.
Enlarge / Section of the so-called “Tavistock letter,” written by Charles Dickens in his idiosyncratic shorthand. The crowd-sourced transcription, now 70 percent complete, reveals a dispute between Dickens and The Times of London.

Last October, a collaboration called The Dickens Code project made a public appeal to amateur puzzle fans and codebreakers for assistance in decoding a letter written by Victorian novelist Charles Dickens in a tortuously idiosyncratic style of shorthand. The crowd-sourced effort helped scholars piece together about three-quarters of the transcript. Shane Baggs, a computer technical support specialist from San Jose, California, won the overall contest, while a college student at the University of Virginia named Ken Cox was declared the runner-up.

Dickens himself hardly needs an introduction, deemed by many to be the greatest novelist of the Victorian era. Great Expectations, Oliver Twist, A Tale of Two Cities, and of course, his timeless 1843 novella A Christmas Carol, are just a few of the works contributing to that well-deserved reputation. A lesser-known aspect of Dickens’ life is that he taught himself a particularly difficult form of shorthand as a teenager, relying on an 18th-century manual called Brachygraphy by shorthand writer Thomas Gurney. Dickens mentions this in passing in his semi-autobiographical novel David Copperfield:

I bought an approved scheme of the noble art and mystery of stenography (which cost me ten and sixpence); and plunged into a sea of perplexity that brought me, in a few weeks, to the confines of distraction. The changes that were rung upon dots, which in such a position meant such a thing, and in such another position something else, entirely different; the wonderful vagaries that were played by circles; the unaccountable consequences that resulted from marks like flies’ legs; the tremendous effects of a curve in a wrong place; not only troubled my waking hours, but reappeared before me in my sleep.

It took Dickens about a year to master Gurney’s Brachygraphy, and he spent three years using the shorthand as a court reporter. He also began adding his own unique symbols to write personal memos to himself, maintain teaching notebooks, write letters, and so forth. Alas, very few examples survive. There are only about 10 currently known manuscripts of Dickens’ shorthand, dating from the 1830s to the late 1860s. Several of these remain undeciphered, including a letter from the 1850s and a set of shorthand booklets collected by Dickens’ shorthand pupil, Arthur Stone (the son of his friend and neighbor).

British novelist Charles Dickens in his study in Gads Hill near Rochester, Kent, circa 1860.
Enlarge / British novelist Charles Dickens in his study in Gads Hill near Rochester, Kent, circa 1860.
Epics/Getty Images

The Dickens Code project is the brainchild of two Dickensian scholars: Claire Wood of the University of Leicester, and Hugo Bowles of the University of Foggia. “Dickens’s shorthand has proved extremely difficult to decode,” they wrote on the project’s website. For those seeking to crack the code, it helps to identify the original source material, although “in most cases, experts have been unable to locate the source texts used for the exercises,” they wrote. “They could be published or unpublished passages written by Dickens, or by another author.”

One of the samples of Dickens’ shorthand is a dictation exercise headed “Sydney Smith,” likely arising from the shorthand lessons he gave to Arthur Stone. Dickens was a great admirer of a reverend philosopher of that name, often carrying around a copy of Smith’s Elementary Sketches of Moral Philosophy. Dickens admired Smith so much, in fact, that he named his seventh son Sydney Smith Haldimand Dickens.

So which Sydney Smith did the dictation exercise refer to—the son or the philosopher? According to Wood and Bowles, this one was fairly easy to decipher thanks to a known symbol meaning “world.” They just had to search for occurrences of “world” in the philosopher’s works, which yielded about 10 candidates. But only one of those used “world” in the first line of a paragraph: a lecture entitled “On the Conduct of the Understanding.” Wood and Bowles think it makes sense that Dickens would have dictated something by his favorite philosopher to Stone as part of the latter’s shorthand lessons. Once they had identified the text, it was relatively simple to complete the rest of the transcription.

https://arstechnica.com/?p=1832843




“Gay propaganda” law keeps Sims 4 wedding expansion out of Russia

Artist's rendition of EA saying goodbye to Russia for this expansion pack.
Enlarge / Artist’s rendition of EA saying goodbye to Russia for this expansion pack.

The “My Wedding Stories” expansion pack for The Sims 4 won’t be released in Russia, publisher Electronic Arts said. That’s due to a “gay-propaganda” law in the country that would have meant the pack’s “storytelling would be subject to changes because of federal laws.”

The pack, set to launch elsewhere on February 17, features a storyline taking players through a romantic relationship between Dominique and Camille, “a couple whose love knows no boundaries,” as EA puts it (and as can be seen in the official trailer for the pack). In an announcement posted Wednesday, The Sims development team writes that “as we moved through our development and brand storytelling process, we became aware that the way we wanted to tell Cam and Dom’s story would not be something we could freely share around the world.”

That’s an oblique reference to Russia’s Article 6.13.1 law, which was passed in 2013 to prohibit “propaganda or homosexualism among minors.” The law has previously been used in attempts to quiet youth protesters in the country and even to target Russians using the “same-sex kiss” emoji.

Back in 2016, Russian members of parliament also accused EA’s popular soccer sim FIFA 17 of violating the law. That’s because the game included references to FIFA’s real-world rainbow laces campaign in support of LGTBQ+ inclusion.

“The core of what we do”

Rather than change the content in “My Wedding Stories” or create a new version that conforms with the Russian law, the developers left the game as is, which “regrettably… means that members of The Sims community in Russia will not be able to purchase this game pack,” EA said.

“The ability to tell stories—any story—is at the core of what we do at The Sims,” the developer wrote in its announcement. “Holding back Cam and Dom’s story meant compromising the values we live by. We are committed to the freedom to be who you are, to love who you love, and tell the stories you want to tell.”

[embedded content]

Same-sex relationships have been possible to varying degrees in The Sims franchise going back to its creation in 2000. The game’s first demo at 1999’s Electronic Entertainment Expo even famously included an unplanned same-sex kiss that helped draw attention to the title.

Those in-game relationships were not always identical to heterosexual partnerships, though; The Sims 2 included “joined unions” for same-sex couples, for instance, a distinction that modders quickly worked to change. The Sims 3 eventually allowed players to call a same-sex partner “husband” or “wife” in 2009, six years before the US Supreme Court made such marriages legal across the country.

EA’s decision on this matter comes as the company also works to introduce customizable pronouns into The Sims 4, a first for the series. That effort, first announced last May, is being made partly in response to an online petition that drew over 22,000 signatories agreeing that the addition “would be impactful for those of us who are still unable to truly feel represented in the game by having our sims selves misgendered.”

While The Sims team hasn’t offered any details regarding when that update may be released, a January livestream included a detailed update on the internal development already in progress. EA has said its pronoun update is focusing on English to start, with similar changes for the game’s other 17 official languages to be “added and supported as we continue to update and improve over time.”

https://arstechnica.com/?p=1833150




Microsoft: Activision on PlayStation will last past “existing agreement”

Despite the prominent "Xbox" in this image, Microsoft suggests some of these popular Activision titles could persist on PlayStation "into the future."
Enlarge / Despite the prominent “Xbox” in this image, Microsoft suggests some of these popular Activision titles could persist on PlayStation “into the future.”

Microsoft now says that it has “committed to Sony” that “Call of Duty and other popular Activision titles” will be “available on PlayStation beyond the existing agreement and into the future so that Sony fans can continue to enjoy the games they love.” The Xbox maker also says it is “interested in taking similar steps to support Nintendo’s successful platform” following its planned $68.7 billion purchase of the mega-publisher.

The announcement comes as part of a blog post outlining a number of “Open App Store principles” Microsoft says are explicitly designed “to address Microsoft’s growing role and responsibility as we start the process of seeking regulatory approval in capitals around the world for our acquisition of Activision Blizzard.”

The bit about distributing Activision titles to non-Xbox consoles “beyond the existing agreement” is especially relevant here. In the days after Microsoft announced its plans to purchase Activision, statements regarding console exclusivity plans from Activision, Sony, and Microsoft focused on language like “honor[ing] all existing commitments” and “abid[ing] by contractual agreements” and “honor[ing] all existing agreements,” respectively. Late last month, Bloomberg reported that those existing agreements only covered the next three Call of Duty games planned for release through 2024.

The new statement is much clearer that Microsoft plans to allow Activision titles on multiple console platforms even once those previous agreements run out. Yet there is still some wiggle room surrounding which specific “popular Activision titles” (and even which Call of Duty titles) will be allowed on competing consoles. Bloomberg also reported that Microsoft “plans to keep making some of Activision’s games for PlayStation consoles but will also keep some content exclusive to Xbox” with little clarity on how big each group of games would be.

<a href="https://rassegna.lbit-solution.it/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/microsoft-activision-on-playstation-will-last-past-existing-agreement-3.png" class="enlarge" data-height="445" data-width="800" alt="The idea of Crash Bandicoot as an Xbox exclusive always felt a little weird…”><img alt="The idea of Crash Bandicoot as an Xbox exclusive always felt a little weird…” src=”https://rassegna.lbit-solution.it/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/microsoft-activision-on-playstation-will-last-past-existing-agreement-1.png” width=”640″ height=”356″ srcset=”https://rassegna.lbit-solution.it/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/microsoft-activision-on-playstation-will-last-past-existing-agreement-3.png 2x”>
Enlarge / The idea of Crash Bandicoot as an Xbox exclusive always felt a little weird…

It’s also important to remember that Microsoft is making these statements as regulators around the world examine the antitrust implications of Microsoft’s massive purchase, which won’t be finalized for months. Previously, Microsoft and Bethesda hinted at non-exclusive Bethesda titles before that purchase was finalized last March, only to confirm Xbox console exclusivity for the studio’s major games shortly afterward.

On the other hand, Microsoft might not want to similarly limit the reach of Activision’s biggest franchises to its own walled garden. Call of Duty: Warzone alone reportedly brings in millions of dollars a day thanks to a base of over 100 million players, many of whom play on PlayStation. That value could be worth more to the company than the added value that exclusivity would bring to Xbox and Game Pass.

Keeping the console closed

Aside from specific questions regarding Activision, Microsoft also announced a new set of “Open App Store principles” it says will “encourage more innovation and investment in content creation and fewer constraints on distribution.” These include a reiteration of policies announced last summer letting developers on its Windows App Store choose outside payment processors for in-app payments. That’s a pretty apparent jab at Apple’s continuing legal issues surrounding similar third-party payments on the iOS App Store.

But Microsoft’s blog post also makes it clear that these “open” principles regarding payments won’t apply to the Xbox console store, which it differentiates from those on “PCs, mobile phones and other general purpose computing devices.” Legislation seeking to regulate and open up digital App Stores “is not being written for specialized computing devices, like gaming consoles, for good reasons,” Microsoft writes. “Gaming consoles, specifically, are sold to gamers at a loss to establish a robust and viable ecosystem for game developers. The costs are recovered later through revenue earned in the dedicated console store.”

Unlike PC and mobile App stores, Microsoft says consoles need to be in their own walled gardens.
Enlarge / Unlike PC and mobile App stores, Microsoft says consoles need to be in their own walled gardens.
Aurich Lawson / Getty Images

That language echoes similar arguments Epic Games made in explaining why it was fine with the 30 percent fees charged by console platforms, even as it took legal action against similar fees charged on Apple’s iOS.

“There’s a rationale for [the 30-percent fee] on console where there’s enormous investment in hardware, often sold below cost, and marketing campaigns in broad partnership with publishers,” Epic CEO Tim Sweeney told GamesIndustry.biz in 2018. “But on open platforms, 30 percent is disproportionate to the cost of the services these stores perform, such as payment processing, download bandwidth, and customer service.”

While Microsoft says it is “committed to closing the gap” on these principles for the Xbox store “over time,” there’s little by way of specifics for how that might happen. For now, it seems, Microsoft will continue to argue that being fully “open” is fine when it comes to computers and phones but totally unworkable when it comes to game consoles.

https://arstechnica.com/?p=1832856




Namco Bandai promises Elden Ring is secure following Dark Souls exploit

Promotional screenshot for upcoming video game.
Enlarge / In Elden Ring, you get a horse.
Bandai Namco


Last month, publisher Namco Bandai took down its online player-versus-player servers for all PC Dark Souls games after players found a serious vulnerability that allowed for remote execution of malicious code on an opponent’s computer. While a Reddit user who publicly identified that issue said the exploit would also work on Namco Bandai’s upcoming Elden Ring, the publisher is now assuring players that the highly anticipated title will be protected.

“We have extended the investigation to Elden Ring… and have made sure the necessary security measures are in place for this title on all target platforms,” Namco Bandai wrote in a tweet Wednesday morning.

The wording of that statement suggests that Elden Ring‘s online services will launch as expected when the game is released on February 25. That’s important for players looking forward to online co-op gameplay, competitive multiplayer battles/invasions, and even basic message support between player worlds, as seen in Dark Souls.

Namco Bandai now says that it has “identified the cause” of the Dark Souls exploit, which didn’t require any specific interaction on the player’s part to make them vulnerable to malware from a PvP opponent. But because of the “time required to set up proper testing environments” (and perhaps because of the focus on Elden Ring security), Namco Bandai writes that online services for Dark Souls will continue to be offline until after Elden Ring‘s launch.

“We will continue to do everything we can to bring back these services as soon as possible,” the company writes.

The Dark Souls vulnerability surfaced just weeks after Minecraft players were exposed to Log4j, which went on to affect hundreds of thousands of machines worldwide. https://arstechnica.com/?p=1832796




Amanda Seyfried makes a winsome Elizabeth Holmes in The Dropout trailer

[embedded content]
Amanda Seyfried stars as Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes in Hulu’s new original series, The Dropout.

Regular Ars readers have no doubt been following our ongoing coverage of the Elizabeth Holmes fraud trial. The disgraced Theranos founder’s meteoric rise and equally rapid fall has already been the subject of a 2018 nonfiction book and the HBO documentary feature, The Inventor: Out for Blood in Silicon Valley. Now Hulu has released the official trailer for The Dropout, the streaming platform’s new original limited series starring Amanda Seyfried as Holmes. (Kate McKinnon was originally slated to star but left the production early on for undisclosed reasons.)

It’s certainly one hell of a story. Holmes famously dropped out of Stanford (hence the series title) to found Theranos in 2003. The company claimed its technology was going to revolutionize medical diagnostic testing by reducing the amount of blood required for analysis down to a single finger prick. Based on that potential promise, Theranos raised over $900 million from investors, most of whom had no experience in biomedical startups. Forbes magazine named Holmes the youngest and wealthiest self-made female billionaire in the US in 2015, valuing Theranos at $9 billion.

Amanda Seyfried stars as Elizabeth Holmes.
Enlarge / Amanda Seyfried stars as Elizabeth Holmes.
YouTube/Hulu

As Ars’ Tim De Chant reported last month, Theranos could never deliver on its signature promise that it could perform more than 1,000 tests with a drop of blood. In reality, it could do 12. The company’s proprietary devices—first the Edison, then the MiniLab—were unreliable and had to be rigged with “null protocols” during investor demos to avoid raising red flags.

Wall Street Journal reporter John Carreyrou (played by Ebon Moss-Bachrach in the series) spent months investigating Theranos and published an explosive series of reports. Forbes revised its valuation of the company to zero in 2016. Holmes and Theranos COO Ramesh “Sunny” Balwani (played in the series by Naveen Andrews of Lost fame) were ultimately charged with perpetrating a multimillion-dollar scheme to defraud investors and patients. Both pleaded not guilty.

During the trial, the jury heard how Holmes personally approved investor presentations, including those fraudulent demos. The court also heard how Holmes had doctored Theranos-authored reports with the logos of various pharmaceutical companies, making it look like the companies approved of the contents. In fact, some contracts that Theranos had with those companies expressly forbade the startup from using their logos. In her defense, Holmes said she was merely “trying to convey” the partnership between the two companies.

Science! Theranos claimed its technology could revolutionize medical diagnostic testing by reducing the amount of blood required to a single finger prick.
Enlarge / Science! Theranos claimed its technology could revolutionize medical diagnostic testing by reducing the amount of blood required to a single finger prick.

Adding to the spicy drama was the fact that Holmes and Balwani had a romantic history for more than 10 years, which they hid from investors and Theranos employees. During the trial, Holmes alleged that she had been abused and controlled by Balwani, who was COO at Theranos for much of its existence. Holmes claimed that she was raped by Balwani and that he sought to control every facet of her life. The relationship ended in 2016.

On January 3, Holmes was found guilty of defrauding Lakeshore Capital Management (the family office of the DeVoses) of $100 million, PFM Healthcare (a hedge fund) of $38 million, and an LLC connected to Daniel Mosley (Henry Kissinger’s former estate attorney) of $6 million. She was also convicted of conspiracy to commit wire fraud against Theranos investors more generally.

On three charges, all alleging wire fraud against investors, the jury returned no verdict. Holmes was acquitted of all other charges, including those that involved defrauding patients. Holmes faces up to 20 years in prison and is currently awaiting sentencing, set for this fall—after Balwani’s trial has concluded.

Theranos was founded in 2003 and formally dissolved in 2018 amid allegations of fraud.
Enlarge / Theranos was founded in 2003 and formally dissolved in 2018 amid allegations of fraud.
YouTube/Hulu

Hulu’s series is based on the 2019 Emmy-nominated podcast of the same name by Rebecca Jarvis, who is an executive producer on the series. Per the official premise:

Money. Romance. Tragedy. Deception. Hulu’s limited series The Dropout, the story of Elizabeth Holmes (Amanda Seyfried) and Theranos, is an unbelievable tale of ambition and fame gone terribly wrong. How did the world’s youngest self-made female billionaire lose it all in the blink of an eye?

Seyfried makes an alluring Holmes in the trailer. You believe this young woman could charm seasoned investors with her tremendous optimism, energy, and personal charm. Heck, even the jurors in the trial found her likable, despite finding her testimony not credible.

The star-studded cast also includes Laurie Metcalf as Phyllis Gardner, a Stanford professor who was among the first to voice skepticism about Holmes and Theranos; William H. Macy as Richard Fuisz, the physician who connected Carreyrou with the former medical director of Theranos; Stephen Fry as former Theranos chief scientist Ian Gibbons; and Camryn Mi-Young Kim as former Theranos employee and whistleblower Erika Cheung.

The first three episodes of The Dropout will premier on Hulu on March 3, 2022. After that, new episodes will air on a weekly basis.

Listing image by YouTube/Hulu

https://arstechnica.com/?p=1832348




Sega’s Shenmue returns as an Adult Swim anime—and so far, it’s promising

<img src="https://rassegna.lbit-solution.it/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/segas-shenmue-returns-as-an-adult-swim-anime-and-so-far-its-promising.png" alt="Shenmue protagonist Ryo Hazuki bids his father farewell in an iconic game series moment. The new animated TV version expands upon this scene in interesting ways, and it’s a great start for the series’ first season.”>
Enlarge / Shenmue protagonist Ryo Hazuki bids his father farewell in an iconic game series moment. The new animated TV version expands upon this scene in interesting ways, and it’s a great start for the series’ first season.
Adult Swim / Crunchyroll

For its 23 years of existence, the Sega game series Shenmue has been embroiled in drama beyond the events of the games themselves. The series began life with a record-breaking budget and industry-changing aspirations, only to flounder as a casualty of its original target platform, the short-lived Dreamcast. While the series returned as a surprising, Sony-promoted Kickstarter in 2015, the resulting Shenmue III underwhelmed (and left some backers livid thanks to an EGS-related switcheroo).

Yet the series’ first two games, in spite of their dated mechanics, remain beloved for players who reveled in Shenmue‘s mix of substantial martial arts combat, open-city exploration, and fully voiced dialogue. (The 1999 original’s best ideas are better realized in the likes of Grand Theft Auto and Sega’s own Yakuza.) Furthermore, Shenmue games always came with an intriguing, detective-like story of family, friendship, and revenge. Forget the game industry drama. Ryo’s suspenseful search for his father’s killer, Lan Di, was the good stuff, and dedicated fans continue to hope its story might even see a logical conclusion.

I kept all of that in mind while tuning in to this week’s Shenmue: The Animation, a new TV series co-produced by Adult Swim and Crunchyroll, in hopes that its season premiere might benefit from leaving its video game roots behind. And now I’m a bit upset—enough to beg Sega: please don’t get fans’ hopes up with an animated series premiere this good, only to yank Shenmue away from us again.

Tearing down an arrogant demeanor

<a href="https://cdn.arstechnica.net/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/vlcsnap-2022-02-06-22h10m37s806.png" class="enlarge" data-height="1080" data-width="1920" alt="An iconic showdown for the Shenmue series.”><img alt="An iconic showdown for the Shenmue series.” src=”https://rassegna.lbit-solution.it/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/segas-shenmue-returns-as-an-adult-swim-anime-and-so-far-its-promising-1.png” width=”980″ height=”551″>
Enlarge / An iconic showdown for the Shenmue series.
Adult Swim / Crunchyroll

As fans previously suggested in 2020, Shenmue: The Animation is poised to retell the game series’ events with additional color and context, whether to add side stories that were scrapped from the original games or to take the games’ known stories in darker or more violent directions. The first episode makes this intent clear by focusing on Shenmue I‘s dramatic opening sequence, which introduces series hero Ryo Hazuki—and immediately makes him a witness to his father’s murder.

Compared to other games of its era, Shenmue I‘s opening cut scene remains memorable for how polished and cinematic it was for the time, complete with masterful martial arts motion capture and emotive facial animations. The teams responsible for this week’s TV interpretation are careful to respect that legacy, and series villain Lan Di issues the same brutal blows to both Ryo and his father before walking away with an all-important “Dragon Mirror.”

Don't mess with Ryo's friends.
Enlarge / Don’t mess with Ryo’s friends.
Adult Swim / Crunchyroll

Yet, this week’s new series introduces an entirely new wrinkle for Ryo’s character development, and it’s surprisingly for the better. Shortly before his life is torn apart by tragedy, we see him as a happy-go-lucky high schooler… who happens to be a skilled and suave martial arts student. To prove this point, Ryo takes down two varieties of jerk: an arrogant bully at a rival school who boasts before an official tournament; and a pair of bullies who harass one of Ryo’s old friends in the streets of Yokosuka.

S:TA, then, begins with a calm and arrogant Ryo, but after he joins his father in a fatal showdown with a mysterious rival, he is changed. Again, that fight plays out just like in the original game—which means Ryo interrupts the fight, then nearly gets killed until his father sacrifices himself so that Ryo might live. This time, however, fans get to see a version of Ryo who truly believed he could even the battling odds. His failure to do so in this extended, animated version leaves him visibly frustrated and grief-stricken.

https://arstechnica.com/?p=1832147




Great balls of fire: A monk named Gervase saw ball lightning way back in 1195

Great balls of fire: A monk named Gervase saw ball lightning way back in 1195
Aurich Lawson | Getty Images | Trinity College

On October 21, 1638, people were congregating at a church at Widecombe-in-the-Moor, in Devon, England, when a severe thunderstorm broke out. Witnesses described an 8-foot ball of fire hurtling through the church, tossing large stones from the walls to the ground, smashing pews and windows, and filling the church with smoke and the pungent odor of sulfur. Four people died and many more were injured in what has been widely recognized as the earliest known account of ball lightning in England—until now.

A British historian and a retired physicist have found an even earlier credible account of ball lightning in the writings of a 12th-century Benedictine monk, Gervase of Christ Church Cathedral Priory in Canterbury. According to a recent paper published in the journal Weather, Gervase of Canterbury recorded in his Chronicle a “marvelous sign” that “descended near London” on June 7, 1195. The sign was a “fiery globe” emerging from below a dark and dense cloud, and it predates the Widecombe-in-the-Moor account by nearly 450 years.

“Ball lightning is a rare weather event that is still not understood today,” said co-author Brian Tanner of Durham University (emeritus). “Gervase’s description of a white substance coming out of the dark cloud, falling as a spinning fiery sphere and then having some horizontal motion is very similar to historic and contemporary descriptions of ball lightning. If Gervase is describing ball lightning, as we believe, then this would be the earliest account of this happening in England that has so far been discovered.”

<a href="https://rassegna.lbit-solution.it/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/great-balls-of-fire-a-monk-named-gervase-saw-ball-lightning-way-back-in-1195-3.jpg" class="enlarge" data-height="1729" data-width="1200" alt="Extract from the Chronicle of Gervase of Canterbury where the medieval monk describes ball lightning—the earliest known description of ball lightning in England. Cambridge, Trinity College, MS R.4.11, p.324.”><img alt="Extract from the Chronicle of Gervase of Canterbury where the medieval monk describes ball lightning—the earliest known description of ball lightning in England. Cambridge, Trinity College, MS R.4.11, p.324.” src=”https://rassegna.lbit-solution.it/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/great-balls-of-fire-a-monk-named-gervase-saw-ball-lightning-way-back-in-1195-1.jpg” width=”640″ height=”922″ srcset=”https://rassegna.lbit-solution.it/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/great-balls-of-fire-a-monk-named-gervase-saw-ball-lightning-way-back-in-1195-3.jpg 2x”>
Enlarge / Extract from the Chronicle of Gervase of Canterbury where the medieval monk describes ball lightning—the earliest known description of ball lightning in England. Cambridge, Trinity College, MS R.4.11, p.324.
The Master and Fellows of Trinity College, Cambridge

As we’ve previously reported, ordinary lightning occurs due to the ionization and dissociation of molecules in the air (a process with the awesome name “dielectric breakdown”), which occurs during a static electric discharge between clouds and the ground. Ball lightning is much rarer, to the point where some have even postulated that it’s actually a hallucination rather than a real weather phenomenon. As the name suggests, ball lightning appears as a spherical or spheroidal ball of light, between one centimeter and one meter in size and variously colored as purple, green, white, or orange. Just like normal lightning, ball lightning seems to occur primarily during thunderstorms. Ball lightning can persist for a few seconds, and the spheres travel horizontally close to ground level.

Tanner and Gasper were scouring medieval archives for reports of celestial phenomena when they came across Gervase of Canterbury’s Chronicle. Much of the monk’s writing concerned the priory’s day-to-day operations—including a detailed account of rebuilding the cathedral’s choir after a fire in 1174—as well as disputes with neighboring houses and an Archbishop of Canterbury. But Gervase was also fascinated by natural phenomena like eclipses, floods, famines, earthquakes—and ball lightning.

Here is the full account, translated from the Latin:

On the 7th of the ides of June [1195], around the sixth hour, a marvellous sign descended near London. For the densest and darkest cloud appeared in the air growing strongly with the sun shining brightly all around. In the middle of this, growing from an uncovered opening, like the opening of a mill, I know not what [was the] white colour [that] ran out. That, growing into a spherical shape under the black cloud, remained suspended between the Thames and the lodgings of the bishop of Norwich. From there a sort of fiery globe threw itself down into the river; with a spinning motion it dropped time and again below the walls of the previously mentioned bishop’s household.

Cumulonimbus clouds over Chandler, Arizona, USA, in 2018, showing the inverted pyramid with the dark cloud beneath.
Enlarge / Cumulonimbus clouds over Chandler, Arizona, USA, in 2018, showing the inverted pyramid with the dark cloud beneath.
Mircea Goia

But just how credible was the monk’s account, given that it was clearly based on a second-hand report? The evidence points to a sober, careful, and reliable chronicler.

“He reported dates and times of solar eclipses remarkably accurately and comprehensively,” the authors wrote. The same was true with lunar eclipses. “These are all the more impressive when considering that observation of partial eclipses was visually challenging in medieval times. In a detailed account of the partial eclipse of 13 September 1178, Gervase accurately describes the turning of the horns of the partly obscured solar disc to point downwards, as well as the changing colours close to maximum eclipse.”

https://arstechnica.com/?p=1830197




Star Citizen devs scale back roadmap to avoid timeline “distractions”

Screenshot from the video game Star Citizen.

Star Citizen developers Cloud Imperium Games’ new public development roadmap will no longer include target dates for coming features more than one calendar quarter away. The change, the company writes, is largely to avoid “distraction” and “continued noise every time we shift deliverables” from “a very loud contingent of Roadmap watchers who see projections as promises.”

It has now been just over nine years since Chris Roberts first raised $6.3 million in Kickstarter funds for Star Citizen, a haul that has grown to over $434 million in funding in the years since. Despite all that time and money, though, the game still only exists as a very rough Alpha version that’s still missing many of the promised features that have slowly crept into the project during that time. The single-player spinoff game Squadron 42, meanwhile, has seen a planned beta delayed multiple times, with CIG COO Carl Jones recently saying it still might be “one or two more years” before the game is playable.

To help provide “more transparency” on the state of both games, RSI promised to overhaul its public roadmap in a way that would “utilize our internal sprint-tracking process to visualize our progress.” When that new roadmap rolled out in late 2020, it came with a focus on a new, less time-sensitive “Progress Tracker” for each development team. That was alongside the traditional “Release View,” which offered a quarter-by-quarter estimate for when new features would be implemented over the next 12 months.

[embedded content]
A trailer for the latest Alpha version of Star Citizen.

At the time, CIG said that the target dates in this Release View would be less reliable as timeline projections got pushed farther into the future. If the Release View showed a feature as being finished in “the quarter in front of us,” CIG said, “you could say at that point that we have a ~90% degree of confidence that this deliverable will make its indicated release quarter.”

More than one quarter ahead, though, CIG said: “That predictability and confidence for delivery will begin to degrade.” Thus, Release View cards for features projected more than a quarter out would be marked as “tentative” and colored in gray. That said, any features appearing anywhere on the Release View would be ones where “we have at least a good level of confidence – around a ~70% confidence level – that we could make that window,” CIG wrote. “If we can’t even clear this hurdle of confidence internally, then we won’t put it on a release card.”

That all broadly lines up with an interview Chief Development Officer Erin Roberts gave in 2019, where he said, “I have very much made sure and asked the team that what we put in [the roadmap] is what we can achieve with what we have right now. … You know last time, we had if we feel we can do this we put it in the roadmap, this time it’s what we are pretty damned sure we can do.”

No no, you didn’t understand

Now, just over a year later, CIG is now saying that maintaining a Release View that showed four quarters’ worth of tentative feature release plans was “a mistake.” The overhauled Release View “put too much attention on features that had a high probability of shifting around,” the company said, adding that “it has become abundantly clear to us that despite our best efforts to communicate the fluidity of development, and how features marked as Tentative should sincerely not be relied upon, the general focus of many of our most passionate players has continued to lead them to interpret anything on the Release View as a promise.”

In explaining the problem, CIG seemed to put some of the blame for this faulty interpretation on the players themselves:

We want to acknowledge that not all of you saw it that way; many took our new focus and our words to heart and understood exactly what we tried to convey. But there still remains a very loud contingent of Roadmap watchers who see projections as promises. And their continued noise every time we shift deliverables has become a distraction both internally at CIG and within our community, as well as to prospective Star Citizen fans watching from the sidelines at our Open Development communications.

<a href="https://cdn.arstechnica.net/wp-content/uploads/2015/02/IMG_3817.jpg" class="enlarge" data-height="2304" data-width="3456" alt="Chris Roberts, CCO of Cloud Imperium Games (Star Citizen).”><img alt="Chris Roberts, CCO of Cloud Imperium Games (Star Citizen).” src=”https://rassegna.lbit-solution.it/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/star-citizen-devs-scale-back-roadmap-to-avoid-timeline-distractions-1.jpg” width=”640″ height=”427″ srcset=”https://rassegna.lbit-solution.it/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/star-citizen-devs-scale-back-roadmap-to-avoid-timeline-distractions-2.jpg 2x”>
Enlarge / Chris Roberts, CCO of Cloud Imperium Games (Star Citizen).

To eliminate “distraction both internally at CIG and within our community” when far-out feature dates get moved, CIG has now simply stopped projecting features in the Release View more than a quarter out. “Even though we always added a caveat that a card could move, we feel now that it’s better to just not put a deliverable on Release View until we can truly commit to it,” the company writes (even though, previously, those deliverables were described as a 70 percent “good level of confidence”).

The change means that RSI is no longer committing to target dates for seemingly fundamental and promised gameplay systems, including an FPS radar, “zero G push and pull,” persistent hangars for managing a squadron of purchased ships, and a “player interaction experience.” Many of these features are now shifting toward development in Squadron 42 first, CIG writes, after which they will be migrated back into the wider “Persistent Universe” afterward, RSI writes.

On one level, we understand how messy game development can be and how hard it can be to get end users to understand the way internal project timelines can shift as priorities and staffing change. But developing a game “in public” like this also means setting expectations reasonably and understanding how the community will interpret your communications, at some level.

More than that, though, some players are getting understandably impatient with CIG as Star Citizen rolls well into its 10th year of development with nothing close to a final release anywhere in sight. No matter how much you update your roadmap or change the way you inform players about what’s going on, at some point people start to expect something approaching an actual product to justify nearly half a billion dollars in funding. https://arstechnica.com/?p=1831926




The Orville: New Horizons jumps 400 years into the future in teaser footage

[embedded content]
The Orville: New Horizons returns, after a nearly three-year hiatus, to its new home on Hulu.

We’re unabashed fans of The Orville here at Ars Technica, and like everyone else, we’ve keenly felt the absence of the series following its explosive S2 finale way back in April 2019. We thought we were getting a third season on Hulu in March, but it looks like we’ll have to wait a few months longer. The streaming platform announced that it is pushing the release of The Orville: New Horizons until June 2. To soften the blow, Hulu released nearly four full minutes of teaser footage, including the new main title.

Series creator Seth MacFarlane addressed the long, frustrating delay when he announced the sneak peek on Twitter:

To all the Orville fans: Thanks for being so patient with us as we’ve navigated the production challenges resulting from the ongoing covid-19 pandemic. As occasionally happens, our show has been repositioned amidst the ever-changing television schedule landscape, which means that the wait will be just a bit longer, and we’re now preparing for a June 2nd launch on Hulu. We’ve always promised you a television experience that will make it worth the wait, and we’re not wavering on that. We understand the frustration you’re feeling over more delays, so we want to give you a little taste of what’s to come. Here’s a sneak peek at the first few minutes of our season opener, and our new main title!

(Spoilers for prior seasons of The Orville below.)

The series is set aboard the USS Orville (ECV-197), an exploratory spaceship in the service of a 25th-century interstellar alliance known as the Planetary Union. Series creator and star Seth MacFarlane (Family Guy), who plays Captain Ed Mercer, was a huge fan of Star Trek growing up, particularly The Next Generation, so it’s not surprising that The Orville has embraced a similar sensibility. As I wrote in my S2 review, “This is a smart series that combines humor and witty dialogue with cutting-edge science, ethical musings, the occasional literary reference, and genuine heart.”

The first season introduced us to the characters and their fictional world while developing the central relationships. The second season put those relationships to the test, with an ambitious and emotionally powerful two-part finale, in which an alternate timeline is created wherein the Kaylons have conquered half the known galaxy (including annihilating Earth). It was the classic trope of how changing a seemingly insignificant detail in the grand scheme of things—Ed and Kelly going on their first date—can have world-altering ramifications. The Orville was destroyed in the process of trying to restore the original timeline, but we had no idea whether that effort was truly successful.

So what can we expect from the show’s third season? Details are being kept tightly under wraps, but it seems the show is taking a page from Star Trek: Discovery and sending the ship and its crew far into the future. Per the official premise, “Set 400 years in the future, The Orville: New Horizons finds the crew of the USS Orville continuing their mission of exploration, as they navigate both the mysteries of the universe and the complexities of their own interpersonal relationships.”

<a href="https://rassegna.lbit-solution.it/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/the-orville-new-horizons-jumps-400-years-into-the-future-in-teaser-footage-2.jpg" class="enlarge" data-height="747" data-width="1200" alt="The intrepid crew of the USS Orville are back and ready for more adventures.”><img alt="The intrepid crew of the USS Orville are back and ready for more adventures.” src=”https://rassegna.lbit-solution.it/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/the-orville-new-horizons-jumps-400-years-into-the-future-in-teaser-footage.jpg” width=”640″ height=”398″ srcset=”https://rassegna.lbit-solution.it/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/the-orville-new-horizons-jumps-400-years-into-the-future-in-teaser-footage-2.jpg 2x”>
Enlarge / The intrepid crew of the USS Orville are back and ready for more adventures.

Filming for S3 was already underway when the COVID pandemic hit and production shut down in March 2020 along with everything else. The move to Hulu brings some distinct storytelling advantages, such as not having to hit a specific run time or factor in commercial breaks. There will be 11 episodes in the third season, two less than for prior seasons, but each episode will be 12 to 15 minutes longer. All the main cast members are returning, with the addition of new cast member Anne Winters, playing ship navigator Ensign Charly Burke. S3 also represents the final role of comedian Norm Macdonald, who voiced the gelatinous engineer Lt. Yaphit and completed his S3 voiceover work before he died of leukemia in September 2021 at age 61.

Based on the new footage, The Orville: New Horizon will open with a major space battle—an impressively ambitious VFX showcase for a series committed to constantly raising the bar in that regard. We also get our first look at the upgraded design of the Orville spacecraft (already pretty distinctive, with three of its “quantum rings” at the rear). The Orville takes quite the beating during the battle, with some significant casualties. There are shots of Claire’s (Penny Johnson Jerald) eldest son, Marcus (BJ Tanner), dashing through the corridors to find his younger brother, Ty (Kai Wener), plus a brief shot of Isaac (Mark Jackson)—the usually friendly Kaylon ally—transforming into a truly terrifying visage.

The Orville: New Horizons will premier on June 2, 2022, on Hulu.

<a href="https://rassegna.lbit-solution.it/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/the-orville-new-horizons-jumps-400-years-into-the-future-in-teaser-footage-3.jpg" class="enlarge" data-height="691" data-width="1200" alt="The Orville has an upgraded design for S3.”><img alt="The Orville has an upgraded design for S3.” src=”https://rassegna.lbit-solution.it/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/the-orville-new-horizons-jumps-400-years-into-the-future-in-teaser-footage-1.jpg” width=”640″ height=”369″ srcset=”https://rassegna.lbit-solution.it/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/the-orville-new-horizons-jumps-400-years-into-the-future-in-teaser-footage-3.jpg 2x”>
Enlarge / The Orville has an upgraded design for S3.
YouTube/Hulu

Listing image by Hulu

https://arstechnica.com/?p=1831893




Controversy erupts over Aussie museum’s identification of HMS Endeavour wreck

<img src="https://rassegna.lbit-solution.it/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/controversy-erupts-over-aussie-museums-identification-of-hms-endeavour-wreck.jpg" alt="Painting by Samuel Atkins of the HMS Endeavour off the coast of New Holland during Cook’s voyage of discovery (1768-1771). “>
Enlarge / Painting by Samuel Atkins of the HMS Endeavour off the coast of New Holland during Cook’s voyage of discovery (1768-1771).

The HMS Endeavour is famous for being sailed by Capt. James Cook to the South Pacific for a scientific expedition in the late 18th century. But the Endeavour (by then renamed the Lord Sandwich) met its demise in the Atlantic, when it was one of 13 ships the British deliberately sank (or “scuttled”) in a Rhode Island harbor during the American Revolution.

Now, the Australian National Maritime Museum has announced that its researchers have confirmed that a shipwreck proposed as a likely candidate in 2018 is indeed the remains of the HMS Endeavour. However, the Rhode Island Marine Archaeology Project (RIMAP)—the museum’s research partner in the project—promptly released a statement calling the announcement premature. RIMAP insists that more evidence is needed and that its own final report is still forthcoming.

The HMS Endeavour holds special relevance for the scientific community because Cook’s first voyage (1768-1771) was, in part, a mission to observe and record the 1769 transit of Venus across the Sun. The observation was part of a combined global effort to determine the distance of the Earth from the Sun. Those observations proved less conclusive than had been hoped, but during the rest of the voyage, Cook was able to map the coastland of New Zealand before sailing west to the southeastern coast of Australia—the first record of Europeans on the continent’s Eastern coastline.

But back to the Atlantic. As Ars’ Kiona Smith reported, archaeologists and divers in 1993 consulted 18th-century maps and logs for information about the locations of the wrecks of the Endeavour (now the Lord Sandwich) and the other ships scuttled with it. Then the researchers took to the water with side-scan sonar to find the remains.

Kiona continued:

It was painstaking work, especially in the early years before GPS technology was available to help with precise mapping. Every possible shipwreck that turned up in the sonar images had to be checked by divers, a process archaeologists call “ground-truthing.” Some of those sites turned out to be modern vessels, lumpy geological formations, piles of abandoned commercial fishing tackle, and even Navy training torpedoes…

By 2016, RIMAP’s volunteers, operating on grants and private donations, had located 10 of the 13 wrecks, almost exactly where historical charts said they should be. And the search had gotten a boost from the 1998 discovery of a 200-year-old paper trail linking the troop transport Lord Sandwich to its former life as HMS Endeavour.

But which of those wrecks was the Endeavour? One candidate was found just 500 meters off the coast of Rhode Island, 14 meters below the surface and buried in nearly 250 years’ worth of sediment and silt. RIMAP’s team concluded in 2018 that this was likely the wreck of the Endeavour, although the researchers emphasized that they needed to accumulate more evidence to support their conclusions.

A digital remodeling of the ship, which was scuttled in 1778.
Enlarge / A digital remodeling of the ship, which was scuttled in 1778.
Australian National Maritime Museum

That’s because only about 15 percent of the ship survives. Any parts of the hull that weren’t quickly buried by silt have long since decomposed in the water. Initially, all that appeared to be left were the piles of ballast (heavy stones placed in the bottom of a ship’s hold to help keep it stable when empty) visible on the harbor bottom. But archaeologists have since found ceramic teapots, glass bottles, lead pieces from pumps, and bits of rope encased in concrete-like substances produced by corroding metal, all buried beneath the harbor’s silt amid the waterlogged timbers.

The Australian National Maritime Museum held a press conference to announce its conclusion. The museum said its researchers matched structural details and the shape of the remains to those on original plans of the Endeavour—including the size of the timbers and the scuttling holes in the keel. The remains are also European-built, the museum said.

“The last pieces of the puzzle had to be confirmed before I felt able to make this call,” Kevin Sumption, director of the museum, said. “Based on archival and archaeological evidence, I’m convinced it’s the Endeavour.”

RIMAP executive director DK Abbass issued the following statement soon afterward:

The Australian National Maritime Museum (ANMM) report that the Endeavour has been identified is premature. The Rhode Island Marine Archaeology Project (RIMAP) is now and always has been the lead organization for the study in Newport harbor. The ANMM announcement today is a breach of the contract between RIMAP and the ANMM for the conduct of this research and how its results are to be shared with the public. What we see on the shipwreck site under study is consistent with what might be expected of the Endeavour, but there has been no indisputable data found to prove the site is that iconic vessel, and there are many unanswered questions that could overturn such an identification. When the study is done, RIMAP will post the legitimate report on its website at: www.rimap.org. Meanwhile, RIMAP recognizes the connection between Australian citizens of British descent and the Endeavour, but RIMAP’s conclusions will be driven by proper scientific process and not Australian emotions or politics.

“We are very open to conversations with Dr. Abbass if she disagrees with our findings, their findings,” Kieran Hosty, the ANMM’s manager of maritime archeology, told the Australian Broadcasting Corporation (ABC). He added that he believed their contract with RIMAP had ended in November, although he could not be sure.

https://arstechnica.com/?p=1831567