This day in search marketing history: February 8

Google Chrome to mark non-HTTPS sites as ‘not secure’

In 2018, Google announced it would identify all sites that had not migrated to HTTPS as “not secure” in the Chrome browser.

Google had already been pushing webmasters to make the change to non-secure websites for years – including hinting at a small ranking boost to further incentivize the shift.

According to Google, in 2018:

  • Over 68% of Chrome traffic on both Android and Windows was protected
  • Over 78% of Chrome traffic on both Chrome OS and Mac was protected
  • 81 of the top 100 sites on the web were using HTTPS by default

Read all about it in Effective July 2018, Google’s Chrome browser will mark non-HTTPS sites as ‘not secure’.


Also on this day


Google launches revamped Search Ads 360

2022: It supported Performance Max and Discovery campaigns, included a refreshed UI and greater support for other search engines.


Google adds Journeys to Chrome: search your history by topic

2022: The feature made it easier for users to revisit topics they searched for days or weeks ago.


Bing News PubHub moves to Bing Webmaster Tools

2022: This made it easier for for publishers who had already verified their sites with Bing Webmaster Tools to access the Bing News PubHub features.


Google publishes new manual actions aimed at Google News and Discover penalties

2021: Google published a whole new set of manual actions around Google News and Google Discover policies and guidelines.


Yelp introduces Keyword Boosting, rolls out Custom Location Targeting to all advertisers

2021: The feature let business owners optimize their ads for specific keywords


Effective July 2018, Google’s Chrome browser will mark non-HTTPS sites as ‘not secure’

2018: After years of pushing for ‘secure by default’ websites, Google would identify insecure sites in the Chrome browser beginning mid-Summer.


Google Search Console request indexing limit removed from interface

2018: Google wouldn’t comment on why quota details in the fetch tool were no longer displaying.


GoDaddy site builder now integrated with Google My Business

2018: Much of the content creation and verification process was automated.


India’s competition regulator fines Google $21.1 million for ‘search bias’ in travel results

2018: India’s Competition Commission said Google disadvantaged “verticals trying to gain market access.”


Google Data Studio now connects to Search Console

2017: Marketers could build reports that included only Search Console data or combine it with other sources to compare paid versus organic traffic trends, for example.


Bing Ads rolling out list exclusions for retargeting ads

2017: Audience exclusions would be available in all markets.


Google: 82% Of Super Bowl Ad Searches Happened On Mobile, Up From 70%

2016: Ads drove more than 7.5 million incremental searches for Super Bowl advertisers.


Yahoo To Close BOSS (Build Your Own Search Service) Next Month

2016: Launched on July 10, 2008, the service would close officially on March 31, 2016.


French Privacy Agency’s Site Crashes, After Demanding Link From Google France Home Page

2015: The traffic seemed to have slowed and sometimes crashed the CNiL website.


Yahoo Turns To Yelp To Beef Up Local Search

2015: Yahoo would reportedly start incorporating local content and listings from Yelp into its main search results.


Confirmed: Google Removes “Not Selected” From Webmaster Tools

2013: Because it “was causing more confusion than actually helping webmasters with their sites.”


Search In Pics: Googlers Must Wash Hands Before Coding, Facebook & Google Accident & Dan Russell & Duane Forrester

2013: The latest images showing what people eat at the search engine companies, how they play, who they meet, where they speak, what toys they have, and more.


Interesting Quotes From Google’s Search Lead, Amit Singhal

2012: Some insights into Singhal’s role at Google, how Google tested new algorithms, and the future for Google search.


Survey: People Largely Negative About Google’s Personalized Search Results

2012: The majority of respondents expressed ambivalence or outright dissatisfaction about Google’s more personalized search results.


Google Screenwise: New Program Pays You To Give Up Privacy & Surf The Web With Chrome

2012: Google was quietly taking requests from web users who wanted to get paid to surf the web using the Chrome browser while sharing data with Google. 


Why Does Microsoft’s Bing Search Engine Hate Rick Santorum?

2012: Santorum’s Bing problem, as with his Google problem, wasn’t stopping many Republican voters from selecting him over other candidates.


Bing Testing New Search Results Design

2012: The new design seemed a lot cleaner, fresher and more organized compared to the older design.


Apple’s Siri Drives 25 Percent Of Wolfram|Alpha Queries

2012: However, the company received no branding on those results.


Demand Media & Being “The Best Click” On Google

2011: Demand’s chief revenue officer brought screenshots and examples to prove they were generating great content to show up on Google. Additional coverage of FM’s Signal LA event:


Bing Search Volume Up 29% In 2010, Google Up 13%, comScore Says

2011: Meanwhile, Experian Hitwise said Bing-Powered Engines Grew 6.5% in January


Android Closing On BlackBerry As Verizon iPhone Launch Approaches

2011: 63.2 million people owned smartphones in the U.S., a penetration level of 27%.


Google Translate iPhone app: A Small Glimpse at the Future Of Search

2011: “It’s your very own Babel Fish replacing frantic searches through a beat up translation dictionary when you’re in a small town in Estonia and need to find a bathroom.”


Yahoo BOSS Moves From Yahoo’s Index to Microsoft’s, Adds Pay Structure

2011: The fee structure would be based on query volume.


Google Building Instant Translator Companion

2010: You would speak to it in any language, Google would then convert that and spit it back in the language of choice.


Report: Google To Announce A More Social Gmail

2010: Google was about to announce a new social feature inside Gmail that allowed users to see (and add to) a stream of status updates from friends and connections. What could go wrong?


Cambodia Calls Google Maps “Misleading” Over Thailand Border Dispute

2010: Cambodia was the latest country upset with Google over how they drew a border on Google Maps.


Google Warns Chinese Knockoff To Stop Using Google Logo

2010:  Google sent a warning to the Chinese Google knockoff, Goojje to stop using their logo.


Ask.com Puts Its NASCAR Sponsorship Back In Garage

2010: Ask spent about $15 million on its one year of NASCAR-related sponsorships.


Microhoo At One Week 1: Decision Nears? Yahoo Brand To Survive?

2008: There were rumors that Yahoo was nearing a decision, while Microsoft’s Steve Ballmer seemed to want to encourage his potential new employees that a Yahoo brand would survive.


Yahoo Live Launches – Online Video, Um, Live

2008: Yahoo Live let you broadcast live video.


Live Search: There For Skiers And Snowboarders Everywhere

2008: Live Search added Instant Answers for snow conditions at ski resorts.


Rumor: Google To Acquire Plaxo

2008: Spoiler alert: It never happened. 


Why The SEO Folks Were Mad At You, Jason

2007: And follow-up: Diggers Can’t Handle The Truth (About SEO)


Will Google Remain ‘The Start Page For The Internet’?

2007: Thoughts on a “post-search” future.


YouTube Founders & Investors Cash In Big Time

2007: Sequoia Capital, the company that funded YouTube, received 941,027 shares that were worth about $442 million.


Google Maps Sticker Spotted In London

2007: The “find us on Google Maps” sticker was a UK-only campaign.


Roundup Of Feedback On Yahoo’s Panama Release

2007: A collection of blog posts, forum posts and opinion on Yahoo’s new quality score factor.


Yahoo Pipes: Letting Non-Programmers Make Mashups & More

2007: It was an “interactive feed aggregator and manipulator.”


The State of Search Engine Marketing 2006

2007: It was thriving. North American advertisers spent $9.4 billion on in 2006, a 62% increase over 2005.


Past contributions from Search Engine Land’s Subject Matter Experts (SMEs)

These columns are a snapshot in time and have not been updated since publishing, unless noted. Opinions expressed in these articles are those of the author and not necessarily Search Engine Land.


< February 7 | Search Marketing History | February 9 >


Related stories

New on Search Engine Land

@media screen and (min-width: 800px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:770px; min-height:260px; } } @media screen and (min-width: 1279px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:800px!important; min-height:440px!important; } }

About the author

Danny Goodwin

Danny Goodwin is Managing Editor of Search Engine Land & SMX. In addition to writing daily about SEO, PPC, and more for Search Engine Land, Goodwin also manages Search Engine Land’s roster of subject-matter experts. He also helps program our conference series, SMX – Search Marketing Expo. Prior to joining Search Engine Land, Goodwin was Executive Editor at Search Engine Journal, where he led editorial initiatives for the brand. He also was an editor at Search Engine Watch. He has spoken at many major search conferences and virtual events, and has been sourced for his expertise by a wide range of publications and podcasts.

https://searchengineland.com/search-marketing-history-february-8-392857




Will the new Bing create more opportunities for advertisers? Maybe

Today, Barry Schwartz and I had the great honor of being there live at the Microsoft Executive Briefing Center, or Building 33, for those in the know, for the announcement of their new Bing and Edge AI-powered search results experience.

By leveraging the power of OpenAI, Microsoft will allow users to chat with, ask questions, or even use it to create content.

But how will this affect advertisers?

Ask and you shall receive. But not really. I asked that very questions during the Q&A portion of the presentation. I was told that ads were already incorporated and they were visible in one of the screenshots in the presentation.

IMG 5012 Copy 800x450

In a brief statement, Microsoft said

“And as usage expands, we expect to see greater volume leading to more opportunities for advertisers to reach their desired customers.”

Rob Wilk, CORPORATE VICE PRESIDENT, MICROSOFT ADVERTISING 

But come to find out, this is not the result they were referring to. In fact, when you receive an answer to a query such as “who are the best dentists in Seattle?” You get a list of dentists with descriptions of their office, address, and (sometimes) Yelp ratings. But you’ll need to hover over the results to see relevant ads, as well as any ad for that specific result.

I don’t have proof of this, as I had to approach a staff member after the keynote to ask about new ad opportunities. But once the new Bing search experience is released to the public, I’ll update this article.

What’s new. As of right now, it looks like relevant ads will remain on the left side of the page, while the AI answers are on the right. In some cases, you can see relevant ads directly within the AI result when you hover over the answers.

Why we care. With all of the chatter (pun intended) around AI, there’s a lot up in the air right now. As usage expands, ChatGPT’s natural language processing capabilities will get better matching queries with advertisements in a more intuitive way, leading to increased ad visibility and improved targeting. This can result in a better return on investment for advertisers who utilize the Bing platform.

Alternatively, informational results could hurt advertisers if users aren’t incentivized to click an ad for the information they seek.


Related stories

New on Search Engine Land

@media screen and (min-width: 800px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:770px; min-height:260px; } } @media screen and (min-width: 1279px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:800px!important; min-height:440px!important; } }

About the author

Nicole Farley

Nicole Farley is an editor for Search Engine Land covering all things PPC. In addition to being a Marine Corps veteran, she has an extensive background in digital marketing, an MBA and a penchant for true crime, podcasts, travel, and snacks.

https://searchengineland.com/will-the-new-bing-create-more-opportunities-for-advertisers-maybe-392822




Microsoft Ads in 2023: Key areas to leverage, test and optimize

Google’s hard push into machine learning and automated bidding – and away from more manually controllable optimizations – builds a sense of exasperation for experienced PPC marketers.

The January revision to the “remove redundant keywords” recommendations, where they announced the removal of redundant exact and phrase match keywords in favor of broad match, was an aggressive example of that trend. 

And it’s made some of us wonder if it’s time to reconsider a long-time little sibling of the paid search world, Microsoft Advertising.

In late 2022, Microsoft announced its ambitious goals for capturing a greater share of brand advertising budgets.

With such a promising prospect, let’s look at Microsoft Ads (or Bing Ads, as most PPC marketers still fondly call it) in relation to Google – including advantages, disadvantages, and opportunities for the platform to make some gains in market share. 

What advantages does Microsoft search offer over Google for PPC experts right now?

There are a couple of major advantages Microsoft (and its search engine, Microsoft Bing) offers over Google as I’m writing this. 

The first is an EQ advantage: I’ve found their reps to be reliable, helpful, and far less likely to push an agenda than Google’s reps. 

This might be expected of a challenger brand that needs to work extra hard for market share, but it’s still a plus to work with folks who look for ways to achieve your goals and do what’s right for your clients.

Strictly from a growth marketing perspective, Microsoft has the unique ability to pull in LinkedIn targeting, which could enable an account-based marketing (ABM) strategy for marketers looking for ways to leverage tighter budgets. 

Microsoft offers targeting by job function, industry, and specific companies. They don’t have full LinkedIn targeting capability yet (more on that in a bit), but you can leverage job-function exclusions and company targeting to construct ABM targeting for brands in your ICP.

Microsoft’s Search Partners network also includes DuckDuckGo, which gets some buzz even though – or maybe because – it’s a privacy-first platform and not an ad network. 

If you’re interested in testing DuckDuckGo, you can exclude other placements in Search Partners to try and concentrate spend there, but you can’t actually isolate it for a clean test.

On the features front, Microsoft recently beat Google to the punch by rolling out video extensions, which complement action extensions and review extensions as nicely built-out ad features.

Extensions

Get the daily newsletter search marketers rely on.


What disadvantages persist for Microsoft Advertising?

The first and most obvious is scale. Although Bing has closed the gap with Google in search engine volume over the past three years, Google’s volume is nearly 10x that of Bing’s.

And Bing is a little sibling in other ways. It tends to mimic Google with a few months of lead time. (For instance, the deadline for switching to Bing RSAs is approaching, and they’re pushing Performance Max-like functions for ecommerce brands). 

In other words, most functionality released by Google eventually comes out on Bing whether advertisers like it or not. 

On the quality front, Bing has traditionally struggled to match the consistency of Google’s algorithm, which has been an issue for advertisers fighting to maintain control of their top keywords. 

Recently, their exact match query results look nearly as good as Google’s and they share almost all search term data on all keyword types (~99%, compared to Google’s <80%). 

If this is still a disadvantage, it’s minimal – and could actually become an advantage if Bing continues to focus on consistency.

When (and why) should advertisers consider investing and testing more on Microsoft Advertising?

In my clients’ accounts, lower levels of competition for keywords on Bing generally result in lower CPCs than Google’s. 

While this doesn’t always result in higher conversion rates (in fact, those tend to be higher on Google), it can result in more efficient CPLs. 

That said, the scale is much lower that the competitive CPLs alone don’t justify big resource shifts. 

But Bing is a smart play in a couple of scenarios. 

  • We always recommend keeping an eye on your brand terms to protect your turf. This might seem obvious, but there are lots of brands that forget that step.
  • Lower CPCs can help you get enough volume to understand what your spend is delivering. 
  • I still recommend fully funding Google, but if you’re seeing a relatively soft month or opportunities to save budget from scrubbing lower-performing keywords on Google, it might be worth testing Bing. 

Overall, if you’re putting in a consistent investment into Google and struggling to improve or maintain returns, look at where return has dropped and consider scaling that back and re-investing into Bing tests.

Where should Microsoft focus on improving to compete with Google?

Microsoft appears to be going all in on AI, given its recent $10B investment in OpenAI and its red-hot ChatGPT functionality. 

If it incorporates ChatGPT into Bing search, as is rumored, it could instantly make waves for Bing as a trendy, user-friendly alternative to Google, helping it wrest away some market share. 

On the advertising budget front, one thing I’d strongly recommend Microsoft work on providing advertisers is the ability to create audiences from LinkedIn targeting. 

In-market audiences for B2B represent a major soft spot for Google that Microsoft should exploit as soon as possible. This could be a great grassroots ABM option for companies that can’t pay for expensive ABM tools.

There’s also room to add plenty of nuance to the existing LinkedIn-like targeting. The ability to target by job title and, more importantly, the ability to drill down by using the “and” piece of and/or targeting, would give B2B advertisers a nice level of precision that Google doesn’t have.

Along with targeting and chatbot innovation, I’d recommend Bing focus on buttoning up its offline conversion tracking. 

It’s come a long way with the combination of the Microsoft click ID and the auto-tag for use with CRMs, but it’s not as robust as Google’s offline tracking, which is a big deal for B2B optimization.

Don’t overlook Microsoft Ads 

At this point, other than in a few specific use cases, I don’t have a compelling argument for shuttling resources away from Google and over to Bing. That said, Microsoft is steadily building momentum with room to create more. 

If Google’s engagement costs continue to climb, and Microsoft focuses on releases that allow advertisers to reach the right people more efficiently, the picture could change.

For now, keep an eye on product releases and announcements. Stay ahead of the curve on adoptions from a platform determined to become more relevant in the coming months.


Opinions expressed in this article are those of the guest author and not necessarily Search Engine Land. Staff authors are listed here.


Related stories

New on Search Engine Land

@media screen and (min-width: 800px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:770px; min-height:260px; } } @media screen and (min-width: 1279px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:800px!important; min-height:440px!important; } }

About the author

Laura Schiele

Laura Schiele, Head of Paid Acquisition at Jordan Digital Marketing, has nearly a decade of experience in paid media strategy and execution in both agency and in-house accounts and uses advanced analytics skills to scale growth within efficiency goals across Google, LinkedIn, Facebook, and more. Laura manages a large team of paid media experts remotely from her home in Burlington, VT.

https://searchengineland.com/microsoft-ads-in-2023-key-areas-to-leverage-test-and-optimize-392650




This day in search marketing history: February 7

Noogler: SEO is spam, ads help you rank

In 2012, a Googler made headlines when he said “SEO isn’t good for users or the Internet at large,” and “It’s a bug that you could rank highly in Google without buying ads, and Google is trying to fix the bug.”

Was it Matt Cutts, John Mueller, or another prominent Googler who said this? No. It was actually a Noogler (or new Googler).

So did this this new employee slip up and reveal what Google really thinks? No. Far more likely, he simply didn’t know what he was talking about.

Google didn’t view SEO as spam. As for ads, Google said: “As always, Google search rankings are completely unrelated to Google’s paid advertising services and other partnerships, and there is absolutely no way for a webmaster to pay money to increase search rankings.”

Read all about it in Google Clarifies: No, Ads Shouldn’t Help Rankings & No, SEO Isn’t Bad.

And yet, more than a decade later, these SEO myths persist.


Also on this day


Google says Shopify sites are in a good crawling state after reports of stalled crawling

2022: Google’s John Mueller said the issue was related to a “temporary drop in how we calculate how much we can crawl,” implying there was no issue with the Shopify sites.


Google tests Buying Guides in mobile search results

2022: It presented users with various drop-down menu options to learn more about the product they were searching for.


Google Search Console performance reports data issue may impact analytics

2022: It impacted Google Search, Google Discover, and Google News data.


Google Posts being rejected because of non-compliance with image guidelines

2020: It seemed like maybe Google didn’t want users to use stock photos.


Google adds Siri Shortcuts to its iOS apps

2020: Users could take actions within the corresponding Google app through Siri by saying trigger phrases, such as “search with Google.”


Clicks plummet when images, article info stripped from news results in SERP

2019: Google sought to show potential ‘unintended consequences’ of new copyright rules that require fees when content is shown in search results.


Google Search Console goes live with new consolidated view

2019: Google made a preview of the consolidated data view live early.


Bing to publishers: Start using new Bing URL submission process for indexing now

2019: Bing wanted to reduce the effort and resources put into crawling the web.


Google begins enforcing certification process for event ticket resellers on AdWords

2018: Ticket resellers were now included among the list of restricted advertisers on AdWords and had to be certified by Google before they could advertise.


Google now wants larger images for AMP articles

2018: The new minimum requirement was 1,200 pixels wide and 800,000 pixels in total.


AdWords Express launches notifications for calls from search ads

2018: Advertisers could rate calls and be notified of missed calls.


Google adds new features & improves navigation for mobile hotel & flight searches

2018: Google rolled out tabs that let users switch between hotel, flight and trip details.


Bing rejected 130M ads in 2016, including 17M tech support scam ads

2017: Advertisers attempting Phishing attacks and pushing counterfeit goods continued to try to evade detection.


Suspected Paid-Link Penalty Hasn’t Hit Expedia Bottom Line — Yet

2014: Said Expedia: “Our traffic from Google, both on a paid and an organic basis, continues to increase on a year-on-year basis.”


Google Now Adds Google Now “Launcher,” Video On Demand Providers, Airbnb Reservations & More

2014: Google rolled out several enhancements to Google search app for Android, bolstering Google Now features on the Nexus 5 and some other devices.


YP Wants To Compete Directly With Google And Yelp In Local

2014: New CMO planned to focus on personalization, more content depth and multi-platform experiences.


Google Now Ranks No. 2 Behind Apple As The 2nd Most Valuable Company In America

2014: As the world’s largest online advertiser, Google’s rise was a reflection of the technology industry taking a larger role globally.


Bing Teams Up With The Hollywood Reporter In Anticipation Of The Oscars

2014: To create the “ultimate Oscars resource guide.”


Search In Pics: Golden Tate With Glass At Super Bowl, Google Indoor Clouds & Android Socks

2014: The latest images showing what people eat at the search engine companies, how they play, who they meet, where they speak, what toys they have, and more.


Google’s Enhanced Campaigns Inspire Love, Hate And Hope For The Next Version

2013: Thoughts from marketers about what they liked, what they didn’t like, what needed to be done, and what they wanted to see in future releases.


Sudden Change In The Number Of Links Reporting In Google Webmaster? Don’t Panic.

2013: It was a bug. Google said it was working on it.


Twitter Search Lets You Once Again Find Old Tweets

2013: Twitter said that some older tweets were going to be available.


Google Still #1 Traffic Source For Most Of Top 30 Websites — Report

2012: Google ranked as the number one source of traffic for 23 of the top 30 websites. 


Did Super Bowl Advertisers Take Advantage of Search Interest?

2012: Brands did a much better job of keeping things simple and driving viewers to interesting, relevant pages that engaged them.


Google: 41 Percent Of Super Bowl Ad Searches Were Mobile

2012: Super Bowl ad-related searches in the US rose 200% on desktop, 970% on tablets and 2,700% on smartphones.


New: Google Sitelinks With Small Arrows

2012: Google confirmed rolling out a new look for their one-line sitelinks.


Wolfram|Alpha Goes Pro With Powerful Data Analysis & Presentation Tools

2012: It included the ability to analyze your own datasets.


Google Webmaster Tools and Google Analytics: The Beginning Of A Useful Integration?

2011: The verification page of Google Webmaster Tools included a link to Google Analytics option for all verified sites.


Google Instant Now On Product Search

2011: Google added Google Instant to Google Shopping Search view within the web results.


Google To EU: We’re Always Open To Algorithm Suggestions

2011: Google CEO Eric Schmidt said that “Google could be willing to change some of its algorithm methodology in search,” to avoid potential fines or other penalties.


Scoring the 2011 Super Bowl Commercials For Search Visibility and Visitor Engagement

2011: 100% of brands had at least some search visibility. But many brands didn’t include mention the Super Bowl ads at all on their home pages.


Instant Replay: Where To Find The Super Bowl Ads

2011: Four good sites that made it easy to find and watch them.


PSAs To Be Phased Out Of AdSense

2011: Publishers running AdSense would see fewer public service announcement banners on their sites.


Google I/O Conference 2011 Sells Out In 59 Minutes

2011: It took 90 days and 50 days in 2009 and 2010, respectively, for the event to sellout.


Google’s Egypt Executive, Wael Ghonim, Should Be Released From Egyptian Custody Now

2011: He had been detained by the Egyptian government during protests.


Blekko: Actually We Have A Million Slashtags

2011: If Facebook-generated “/likes” were included the “slashtag count” rose to over a million.


Twitter Study: Mainstream News Are Carbs, Blogs Are Protein For Your Marketing

2011: Bloggers had more influence than mainstream publications in areas such as technology and entertainment.


Google Airs TV Ad During Super Bowl – But Why?

2010: The “Parisian Love” commercial had 1.2 million views on YouTube before it ran during the Super Bowl. 


Searching for the Superbowl Start Time: How Are The Engines, the NFL, and CBS Doing?

2010: The NFL, CBS, and the search engines didn’t do a great job at connecting with searchers who wanted to know what time the game started.


Google News’ New Local Angle

2008: New capabilities allowed users to “create a local section for any city, state or country in the world.”


Microsoft Live Search Core Relevance Program Management Director Eytan Seidman Moves On

2008: The core relevance team that Eytan managed included crawling, indexing, and ranking for Live Search.


Microsoft Acquires 3-D Modeling Software Company Caligari

2008: The group would be a part of the Virtual Earth team, but the software equally used for gaming and game development.


If You Like Digg, You’ll Love Ask’s Big News

2008: Ask embraced the social media tenet that you need others to tell you how important a news story is, with its new “BigFactor” ratings.


January 2008: Search Engine Land’s Most Popular Stories

2008: Search Engine Land’s 10 most popular stories from January 2008.


Rand Fishkin’s Belated SuperBowl Proposal Gets A Yes

2007: Instead of a Super Bowl ad, he popped the question during a “Veronica Mars” commercial.


Google Maps Australia Turns 30 Second Walk Into 18 Minutes Drive

2007: Searching for directions from Shelbourne Hotel to Google’s own Sydney office across the street took you over a toll bridge and back.


Gmail Now Public Beta, Open To All

2007: You no longer needed an invite or SMS code to gain access to your own Gmail account.


Google To Roll Out Fee-Based Google Apps?

2007: Once it was free for companies to adopt Google’s office applications.


Google Sends Mr. Schmidt To Washington

2007: Schmidt lobbied for many things in his talk, including a bill to remove taxes on internet access and e-commerce, net neutrality and government initiatives to help small businesses with technology. 


Live Search SOAP API Out Of Beta

2007: They also added some new features including more languages, increased search results, enhanced search tags, more local options, improved phone results and more coding samples.


Yahoo Adds Featured Search Builder Sites Box

2007: Yahoo added a box to the home page in order to promote user-generated search sites. 


Kudos To National Pork Board For Apologies & Fundraising Efforts

2007: A search marketer and breastfeeding activist received two letters of apology, plus the National Pork Board backed a fundraising campaign for the Mother’s Milk Bank Of Ohio.


Searching For “The Next Google”

2007: A look at search-related demonstrations from the DEMO conference.


Searchforvideo Upgrades Design, Capabilities

2007: Viewers were presented with brand name content channels and hundreds of video partners were added to its search index.


SideStep Raises $15 Million

2007: SideStep had its eye on more acquisitions.


From Search Marketing Expo (SMX)


Past contributions from Search Engine Land’s Subject Matter Experts (SMEs)

These columns are a snapshot in time and have not been updated since publishing, unless noted. Opinions expressed in these articles are those of the author and not necessarily Search Engine Land.


< February 6 | Search Marketing History | February 8 >


Related stories

New on Search Engine Land

@media screen and (min-width: 800px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:770px; min-height:260px; } } @media screen and (min-width: 1279px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:800px!important; min-height:440px!important; } }

About the author

Danny Goodwin

Danny Goodwin is Managing Editor of Search Engine Land & SMX. In addition to writing daily about SEO, PPC, and more for Search Engine Land, Goodwin also manages Search Engine Land’s roster of subject-matter experts. He also helps program our conference series, SMX – Search Marketing Expo. Prior to joining Search Engine Land, Goodwin was Executive Editor at Search Engine Journal, where he led editorial initiatives for the brand. He also was an editor at Search Engine Watch. He has spoken at many major search conferences and virtual events, and has been sourced for his expertise by a wide range of publications and podcasts.

https://searchengineland.com/search-marketing-history-february-7-392777




This day in search marketing history: February 6

Google AdWords announces Enhanced Campaigns

In 2013, Google AdWords announced Enhanced Campaigns. This major update was designed to simplify campaign management across multiple devices and increase adoption rates of mobile advertising among small and medium-sized businesses.

Among the notable changes:

  • Tablets and desktops would be grouped together, rather than treated as separate devices.
  • Advertisers would set a baseline bid that applied to both desktop and tablet, and then set the mobile bid as a multiplier of the desktop/tablet bid. 
  • Targeting at the operating system level would no longer be available.

Google planned to upgrade all campaigns in June 2013 (though the full rollout would actually begin July 22 and would take several weeks to complete).

Read all about it in The Big AdWords Update: Enhanced Campaigns Puts The Focus On Mobile.


Also on this day


Happy 15th birthday to Google Maps, the company’s second most important product

2020: Google introduced a refreshed version of its app for Android and iOS with some new features.


Now, get your Google Shopping ads on Gmail, Discover, YouTube

2020: Google kept finding more places to show Shopping ads as merchants prioritized them over text ads.


Google Search Console to consolidate Search Performance reports to canonical URL

2019: Starting at the end of March 2019, Google would change how the Google Search Console Performance reports counted metrics.


Google My Business supports hotel check-in and check-out times

2019: Google would display that information to searchers looking for more information about those times.


Google officially announces the new Google Search Console is available for everyone

2018: The beta version had reached nearly everyone as of a couple of weeks ago.


Google removes tappable shortcuts from search app

2018: Less than a year after it launched, Google removed the shortcuts offering quick answers on weather, sports and entertainment info.


Bing explains how AI-powered intelligent answers can show users two points of view for the same query

2018: Bing believed there were many questions where getting just one point of view was not sufficient, convenient or comprehensive


Quora adds more contextual & behavioral ad-targeting options

2018: Quora offered more options for behavioral and contextual targeting to either narrow or widen audience targets.


Google makes it easier to see and share publishers’ real URLs from AMP pages

2017: The AMP header area would display a link or chain icon, what it called the “anchor” button. Clicking on this would make the publisher’s direct URL appear.


84 Lumber and Avocados From Mexico among Super Bowl advertisers that stood out in paid search

2017: Both advertisers opted to drive users to their own sites instead of YouTube.


Google Maps updates Android app with real-time traffic info, nearby places & bus schedules

2017: Swiping up from the bottom of the Google Maps app home screen on Android displayed a Places tab, Driving tab and Transit tab.


Google Confirms Making “Tweaks” To The Search Results But Says No “Update” To Announce

2015: Google said he latest update the SEO community noticed was not related to the Penguin or Panda algorithms.


Google Removes “How Can I Join ISIS” Autosuggestion

2015: Google censored out the Google autocomplete results to show ISIS for the search term [how can I join].


Bing Ads Rolling Out Updates To Quality Score Reporting

2015: Changes were designed to make quality score easier to use as a guide to where to focus your optimization efforts.


Yahoo Gemini Gaining Mobile Search Share, But Not At Google’s Expense, Yet

2015: The spike in Gemini traffic appeared to come almost entirely at the expense of mobile ads served by Bing.


Google Penalized A Germany Agency & Their Clients For Link Schemes, Says Matt Cutts

2014: He added that Google would be going after more Germany link schemes in the near future.


Google Requiring Some Business To Reverify Their Listings Or Be Removed From Google Maps

2014: Some business owners received emails from Google requiring them to reverify their listings within three weeks or their listings would be deleted from Google Maps and Google+ Local.


Two New Link Analysis Tools Available: OpenLinkProfiler.org & WebMeUp.com

2014: Two new link tools were available for those looking to analyze their own links or competitor links.


Google’s “Olympic Charter” Logo Stands Up To Russia’s Anti-Gay Legislation

2014: The logo included a quote stressing that the official Olympic Charter was against discrimination and using the colors of the rainbow gay pride flag.


Update: “When Do The Olympics Opening Ceremonies Start?” Now You CAN Ask Yahoo

2014: Yahoo inserted a Search Shortcut that displayed not only the live start time but the TV broadcast time at the top of the search results.


Google On Will They Ever Remove PageRank From The Google Toolbar?

2013: Matt Cutts said the “writing is on the wall” for this feature. Google would remove Toolbar PageRank just over three years later, in March 2016.


Australia’s Highest Court Relieves Google Of Liability For “Deceptive” Search Ads

2013: The Australian Competition & Consumer Commission sued Google six years earlier, claiming that certain travel-related ads appearing in search results were misleading.


Has Google Overtaken Naver In South Korea?

2013: Despite reports that Naver controlled somewhere between 70-80% of the search market in South Korea, StatCounter was showing Google soundly defeating Naver since February 2012.


Google Buys Channel Intelligence For $125 Million

2013: Channel Intelligence offered a range of services built around data management and product feed optimization.


Super Bowl Commercials 2013 Edition: For Search Visibility, Most Brands Bought AdWords Too

2013: Eighty percent of brands bought AdWords for branded searches and 50% bought AdWords for commercial taglines.


Google Maps Adds Ski Resort Trail Maps For Android & iPhone

2013: The new feature overlayed lifts and trail maps for 38 major ski areas in the U.S.


Find Content Quicker On The Go With Twitter’s New Mobile Search & Discover Upgrades

2013: The Search, Discover and Connect tabs were all updated.


Google Instant: Only On When Your Computer Can Handle It

2012: If you went to the search preferences it would say Google Instant was only enabled when “my computer is fast enough” and then showed whether Google thought your computer was fast enough.


Report: National Marketers Love Local, Fail At Basic Tactics

2012: Insufficient funding, a lack of education or just plain ignorance were the factors behind the flawed national-local approaches.


Bing Webmaster Tools Adds Markup Validator

2012: The tool scanned for HTML Microdata, Microformats, RDFa, Schema.org and Open Graph.


Yahoo Launches Mobile-App Search (For PCs) In The UK

2012: As an app search tool, it was quite nice. Neither Google nor Bing offered anything comparable in their main search engines.


Under Threat Of Being Blocked Google, Facebook Comply With India’s New Internet Censorship Rules

2012: The law made online publishers potentially liable for the acts of individual users and third parties.


A Google Super Bowl Ad? Eric Schmidt Hints At It

2010: His tweet suggested that Google would run its first major broadcast television commercial during the Super Bowl.


Another Survey (Incorrectly) Predicts Google Could Lose Search Crown

2009: Forrester Research had concluded that Google, for lack of user loyalty, was vulnerable to being dethroned and that another “Google killer” was lurking just around the corner.


Privacy Critics Don’t Give Google Enough ‘Latitude’

2009: An example of overreaching in an effort to gain (media) attention.


Google Offers A Peek Into Its Internal Eye-Tracking Studies

2009: An interesting look into how Google tested its search results pages and how searchers interacted with them.


Search In Pictures: Google Doodle Wall, Ask.com On Labonte’s Helmet & A Google Boat?

2009: The latest images showing what people eat at the search engine companies, how they play, who they meet, where they speak, what toys they have, and more.


The Latest From Jerry: Stay Focused, Yahoos!

2008: No real news other than Yang telling employees no decision had been made, proposals were being evaluated, and people loved Yahoo.


Berkowitz Had Hoped To Turn Around Microsoft, But May Find Himself In “Turnaound”

2008: Several internal groups were slated for leadership changes.


Google To Fight Baidu In China With Legal Music Downloads?

2008: 7% of Baidu’s traffic was to access free music, but Baidu had been a target of copyright actions because of this.


Ask Launches BigNews

2008: It was similar to Google News, with a side of Digg.


Searching For Southern Tornado Maps

2008: There wasn’t much map content about the tornadoes that tragically tore through the Southern U.S.


SphinnCon Israel 2008 Recap

2008: Coverage of first SphinnCon event in Jerusalem, Israel.


Google Hiring In Africa

2008: The company was hiring in its Nairobi, Kenya headquarters and opening new offices in several Africa countries.


What Yahoo’s Panama Update Means For Searchers

2007: With the new ad ranking system in place, Yahoo hoped people would start looking at the results more as a whole.


Keyword Research And Consumer Demand

2007: How marketers were using search volumes to help conduct research and development, launch new products and predict potential product success based on perceived consumer demand.


Google’s Pen Flatlines For Ask, Parody Of Recent Capacity Problems

2007: They described the flatlining of the Google pen to cause “considerable inconvenience and loss of data.”


IAC Earnings Drop But Ask.com Grows

2007: IAC’s profits dropped 98 percent in the fourth-quarter.


Search Engine Land: January 2007 Statistics Review

2007: How Search Engine Land was growing.


Past contributions from Search Engine Land’s Subject Matter Experts (SMEs)

These columns are a snapshot in time and have not been updated since publishing, unless noted. Opinions expressed in these articles are those of the author and not necessarily Search Engine Land.


< February 5 | Search Marketing History | February 7 >


Related stories

New on Search Engine Land

@media screen and (min-width: 800px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:770px; min-height:260px; } } @media screen and (min-width: 1279px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:800px!important; min-height:440px!important; } }

About the author

Danny Goodwin

Danny Goodwin is Managing Editor of Search Engine Land & SMX. In addition to writing daily about SEO, PPC, and more for Search Engine Land, Goodwin also manages Search Engine Land’s roster of subject-matter experts. He also helps program our conference series, SMX – Search Marketing Expo. Prior to joining Search Engine Land, Goodwin was Executive Editor at Search Engine Journal, where he led editorial initiatives for the brand. He also was an editor at Search Engine Watch. He has spoken at many major search conferences and virtual events, and has been sourced for his expertise by a wide range of publications and podcasts.

https://searchengineland.com/search-marketing-history-february-6-392679




This day in search marketing history: February 5

Moz upgrades its Domain Authority metric

In 2019, SEO tool Moz announced an update to how they measured Domain Authority (DA).

Basically, DA is a score, from 0-100, that “predicts how likely a website is to rank in search engine result pages.”

Curious about what changed? Read all about it in Moz upgrades controversial ‘domain authority’ metric.

To be clear, Google does not use Domain Authority to determine ranking. “We don’t use domain authority at all in our algorithms,” according to a tweet. by Google’s John Mueller.

I bolded that part above because the DA metric has caused confusion within the SEO industry, as many have basically assigned it value as a meaningful SEO metric, akin to the old visible Google PageRank scores. And you will often see it in spammy SEO and link building emails.

Even Rand Fishkin, who created the metric, essentially disowned Domain Authority as something he didn’t care much about anymore (“I know. I created it, but still”) during Milestone’s Engage conference in August 2022.


Also on this day


Justice Department homing in on Google Ad Manager in antitrust probe

2020: The feds were interviewing publishers and ad-tech rivals about whether Google has too much control “over the monetization of digital content.”


Tripadvisor’s new ‘Review Hub’ lets restaurateurs manage reviews from multiple sources in one place

2020: The subscription-based product could also be used to identify review trends across sites.


Video: Jim Boykin on how link building has evolved over two decades

2020:  In this installment of Barry Schwartz’s vlog series, he also chatted with Boykin about Google penalties, algorithm updates and the importance of featured snippets and people also ask for SEO.


5 takeaways from Google’s Q4 2018 earnings for search marketers

2019: Google executives discussed search experience, campaign, device and performance updates.


Google adds new SEO Audit category to Chrome’s Lighthouse extension

2018: The popular auditing tool used by developers and search marketers enabled users to run basic SEO checks against site pages.


Google dedicates engineering team to accelerate development of WordPress ecosystem

2018: Google’s partnership with WordPress aimed to jump-start the platform’s support of the latest web technologies, particularly those involving performance and mobile experience.


Google Search Console AMP report error now corrected

2018: “Major content mismatch” were due to a processing error on Google’s side. 


Google Has Penalized A Link Network In Japan

2016: After being quiet for over a year on link network penalties, Google said it had penalized a large, Japanese-based link network.


AdWords App For Android Now Supports Universal App Campaigns

2016: New conversion columns were also available in the latest update.


Sorry, No Emoji Allowed In Google PLAs (Frown Face)

2016: Google updated its store name guidelines in the Merchant Store policy center to specifically cite emoticons and emoji among its don’ts.


Search In Pics: GoogleBot Costume, Google Maps Peghog & Fancy Google Coffee Maker

2016: The latest images showing what people eat at the search engine companies, how they play, who they meet, where they speak, what toys they have and more.


Official: Twitter To Give Google Access To “Firehose” Of Tweets

2015: Twitter confirmed that it had a deal again to supply Google with access to its full stream of tweets.


As Apple-Google Deal Expires, Who Will Win The Safari Default Search Business?

2015: Would it be Bing, Yahoo or Apple itself that supplied Safari’s search engine?


Marketers Spent $4 Billion On Click-to-Call Advertising In 2014 — Report

2015: Lack of keyword attribution created a “blind spot” for search marketers.


Google App Indexing Statistics & Errors Being Emailed To Webmasters

2015: Google Webmaster Tools email notifications drove app deep linking awareness in terms of errors and impression and click statistics.


It’s Done: Google Settles Search Antitrust Case In Europe

2014:  Google escaped any significant fines or penalties. More coverage: Wow! See How Much Screen Real Estate Google Is Giving Rivals In Its EU Antitrust Settlement


Google’s Latest Manual Action Penalty: Spammy Structured Markup

2014: How to get it: marking up content that was invisible to users, marking up irrelevant or misleading content, and/or other manipulative behavior that violated Google’s Rich Snippet Quality guidelines.


Official: Google’s Sridhar Ramaswamy Takes Over Ads & Commerce As Wojcicki Heads To YouTube

2014: Ramaswamy and Wojcicki shared the title of SVP, Ads & Commerce, and had been jointly running the ads division for the prior year.


SEMPO Search Survey: Nearly 70% Of Agencies Say Client SEO Budgets To Increase In 2014

2014: Only 47% of respondents from within a company said there would be a significant or, at least, some increase to their SEO budget.


Yelp Reports $233 Million In Revenue For 2013, Up 69% From 2012

2014: Active local business accounts on Yelp grew to 67,000 in 2013, up 69% year-over-year.


Microsoft’s $15 Million Check-in: Will Redmond Buy Foursquare?

2014: Microsoft had reportedly signed a multi-year agreement to license Foursquare data for both mobile and Bing on the PC.


Bing Launches New Winter Olympics Search Features & Counter To Track Gold Medals

2014: When Bing users searched on specific sports and athletes the search engine would include Olympic-related schedules and content in its search results.


“When Do The Olympics Opening Ceremonies Start?” Search Engines Compete To Answer

2014: How Google, Bing and Yahoo stacked up in this Olympic effort.


Telenav Thinks Scout Can Take On Google Maps

2014: Apparently because Scout had higher user ratings than Google Maps in the Google Play store at the time.


Will A Google Crackdown On Shady Search Toolbars Hurt AVG & IAC?

2013: Either they needed to change their ways — and become much more transparent and easy to use — or they would apparently need to look elsewhere for ads. More coverage: IAC: We Comply With Google’s Toolbar Standards


Survey: Half Of Small Businesses Never Update Their Listings Online

2013: 70% of SMBs said they didn’t have the time to manage listings on all of the sites that consumers use.


Study: Are Public Record Ads Placed On Google Racially Biased?

2013: The study found that ads associated with black identifying names were more likely to have ads with the word “arrest” in them than ads that were associated with white identifying names. 


Dilbert: SEOs Control Content On The Web

2013: A Dilbert cartoon once again took a jab at SEOs and what they do or can do.


When Is the Super Bowl Start Time? The NFL Finally Gets It Right

2012: In past years, organizations like the NFL, the playing teams, and the failed to show up in search results because none of their sites answered the question.


Turning The Tables On The Google Toolbar & Disclosure Claims

2012: Google didn’t seem to occupy any higher ground than Microsoft when it came to using data gathered from browser add-ons to improve its own services, including its search engine.


What Time Does the 2011 Super Bowl Start? A (Continuing) Lesson in Search Visibility

2012: The NFL and FOX were still nowhere to be found.


Google Recommends The Competition On Your Business Place Page

2010: The content block, called “Nearby places you might like,” appeared below reviews on the place page and show up to 10 recommended businesses.


Microsoft Extends Bing Search Deal With Facebook

2010: Deal included a more robust Bing search experience on Facebook. Also, Bing would power Facebook search outside of the U.S., to all Facebook users, worldwide.


Siri: Not A “Search Engine” But You Might Use It Like One

2010: The highly-anticipated iPhone app was intended to enable you to do more with your voice and your phone in fewer clicks or moves.


Super Bowl 2010 Winners: Google, Yahoo & Bing Are Ready

2010: All three had Super Bowl shortcuts/oneboxes in place.


2002 In Review: Google Powers AOL; AdWords Go Cost-Per-Click

2010: Major events from the year 2002 in consumer search.


Google Earth Adds World War II Imagery

2010: Y could compare, side by side, the earth as it is today versus how it was during World War II.


Search In Pictures: Bing Hat, Yahoo Balls & Yahoo Karate

2010: The latest images showing what people eat at the search engine companies, how they play, who they meet, where they speak, what toys they have, and more.


Google Continues AdWords Product PlusBox

2009: It was still a limited beta to test the effectiveness of engaging potential customers for advertisers.


Google Books Search Goes Mobile

2009: If you viewed the book on a mobile device, they would try to extract the text using OCR and show you plain text, not scanned text.


A Bad Month For SEO’s Reputation

2008: Although the bad reputation issue had been out there for years, demand for SEO services was as strong as ever.


MicroHoo: Boon Or Bust For Yahoo?

2008: There seemed to be mounting cynicism and detachment among Yahoos.


2008 elections


Google Releases New Link Reporting Tools

2007: You could view and even download thousands of links to your site via Google Webmaster Central.


Google’s Click Fraud Team Writes On Commonly Raised Concerns

2007: They analyzed IP address, duplicate clicks, and various other clicking patterns to detect click fraud.


Searching For Super Bowl XLI

2007: Although there were improvements over 2006, this year was still lacking in terms of integrating their offline and online ad efforts.


YouTube Pulls Videos That May Not Violate DMCA Law

2007: Google didn’t know whether a video was infringing. It simply knew it was reported as an infringement.


Krillion Launches ‘Actionable Local Search’

2007: Krillion helped consumers find where they could buy products in their markets after conducting online research.


Major UK Mobile Companies Look To Start Mobile Search Engine

2007: The companies included Vodafone, France Telecom, Telefonica, Deutsche Telekom, Hutchison Whampoa, Telecom Italia and Cingular.


FAST Introduces Private-Label Contextual Ad System

2007: It let publishers manage and serve their own advertisements, bypassing Google, Yahoo and other third-party contextual advertising services.


Will Tagging Replace The Dewey Decimal System?

2007: 28% of internet users had tagged or categorized content online such as photos, news stories or blog posts.


Past contributions from Search Engine Land’s Subject Matter Experts (SMEs)

These columns are a snapshot in time and have not been updated since publishing, unless noted. Opinions expressed in these articles are those of the author and not necessarily Search Engine Land.


< February 4 | Search Marketing History | February 6 >


Related stories

New on Search Engine Land

@media screen and (min-width: 800px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:770px; min-height:260px; } } @media screen and (min-width: 1279px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:800px!important; min-height:440px!important; } }

About the author

Danny Goodwin

Danny Goodwin is Managing Editor of Search Engine Land & SMX. In addition to writing daily about SEO, PPC, and more for Search Engine Land, Goodwin also manages Search Engine Land’s roster of subject-matter experts. He also helps program our conference series, SMX – Search Marketing Expo. Prior to joining Search Engine Land, Goodwin was Executive Editor at Search Engine Journal, where he led editorial initiatives for the brand. He also was an editor at Search Engine Watch. He has spoken at many major search conferences and virtual events, and has been sourced for his expertise by a wide range of publications and podcasts.

https://searchengineland.com/search-marketing-history-february-5-392678




This day in search marketing history: February 4

Microsoft’s bid to buy Yahoo, Day 4

In 2008, there were some big developments following the news of Microsoft’s bid to purchase Yahoo. 

Google wasn’t happy about the news. The company objected, suggesting that the move would hurt what it called the underlying principles of the internet: “openness and innovation.”

There was some ironic back and forth, as Google had spent the past year arguing that it should be able to acquire DoubleClick, which Microsoft argued against because it would make Google too dominant in online advertising.

Meanwhile, was Yahoo considering an alliance with Google? And why did Google CEO Eric Schmidt call Yahoo CEO Jerry Yang to offer Yahoo help?

And what about post-acquisition “integration” issues? Local, maps, and mobile were areas where both companies had made significant investments but also had significant duplication and redundancy.

Microsoft sounded pretty confident the deal would happen. As Kevin Johnson put it:

  • “It doesn’t make sense to have thousands of engineers at Yahoo working on a search index, thousands of engineers at Microsoft working on the same search index. By combining, we can have one team of people across the two companies working on the search index, and then have others continue to focus on areas where we’ve defined differentiation in search. New search verticals and expanded user experience for search. We’ve got so many ideas, more engineers applied to those ideas will drive breakthroughs in search.”

Dig deeper:


Also on this day


Enhanced conversions: Google tests global site tags with automatic collection

2022: The global site tag could now automatically collect the information (e.g., email, telephone number) that a user submitted on the website.


Microsoft Bing adds automobile and car search features

2022: There were links to the MSN Autos marketplace in the knowledge panels for these car-related searches under “learn more” and “shop used cars” right above the car specifications.


Google expands phrase match to include broad match modifier traffic

2021: Phrase match would expand to include additional broad match modifier traffic and support for broad match modifier would end.


5 takeaways for marketers from Google’s Q4 2019 earnings

2020: For the first time, the company disclosed YouTube advertising revenues.


Hitwise halts some reporting services in wake of Jumpshot’s closing

2020: Hitwise informed its customers that daily, weekly and monthly metric updates were on pause until further notice.


Filter, sort, bulk manage product groups in Microsoft Shopping soon

2020: Scripts were also coming to Shopping campaigns in Microsoft Advertising.


Bing doesn’t show ads for queries around Super Bowl commercials, while Google does

2019: The company’s primary goal was not to drive revenue and chose not to monetize search results.


Survey: Local SEO an ‘artisanal’ discipline dominated by small agencies

2019: Roughly 53% of firms doing local SEO had 10 or fewer clients.


Google Adds JSON-LD Support For Structured Data Markup

2016: Google started supporting JSON-LD for structured data markup for reviews and products rich snippets.


Google Revamps Mobile Travel Search Results, Almost Making Web Results Irrelevant

2016: Once you clicked on the “more destinations” button, Google led you into a travel search experience that made it harder to view organic search results.


Bing Updates Android & iOS Apps To Enable More Finding With Less Searching

2016: The idea, according to Microsoft, was to help users “find” and “do” faster.


Google Expands Webmaster Documentation Around Reconsideration Requests

2015: Google clarified and expanded on their reconsideration request documentation for those who had been hit by a Google manual action.


Report: Google Will Get Access To Twitter’s Firehose Again

2015: The agreement came 3+ years after a similar arrangement ended. It would make tweets easier to find via search.


Google Answers Now Showing Blue Icons Linking To Publisher Sites Or More Google Answers

2015: This had been done previously for easter eggs and Google’s own content, but now it worked for third-party publishers.


Bing Ads Discusses 3 New Initiatives: Native Ads On MSN.com, Mobile Ad Formats, Remarketing

2015: The company’s foray into native advertising would harness intent signals from Bing Ads.


With Nadella’s Appointment, The “Search CEOs” Now Run Google, Yahoo & Microsoft

2014: For the first time in ages, the three major search companies in the US were all run by CEOs who either came out of a search background or had a solid understanding of it.


Google AdWords To Roll Out Flexible Conversion Counting, Says Goodbye To 1 Per-Click, Many-Per-Click

2014: Converted clicks = Conversions (1 per-click) and Conversions = Conversions (many-per-click).


Google’s DoubleClick Search Ramps Focus On PLAs And Ecommerce With New Commerce Suite

2014: The suite was comprised of two new capabilities: Dynamic Product Listing Ads creation and Product Listing Ads optimization.


Google Showing Large Video Embeds In Some Search Results

2014: Searching Google for video-related content would return a large, playable, video directly at the top of the search results.


Google Maps App Now Continually Searching For Faster Route

2014: The app would notify you if a faster route was available while you were in transit.


Beyonce, Blackout, Ravens And M&Ms — What We Searched For During Super Bowl 2013

2013: Viewers turned to their devices to ask [why did the lights go out], [superdome power outage] and [what caused power outage].


Bing: Why Google’s Wrong In Its Accusations

2011: Bing said it has search signal, not Google signal.


Yelp: 35 Percent Of Searches Mobile Now

2011: The mobile audience on Yelp was more active and engaged than its PC audience.


Search In Pics: Google Sweden License Plate, Yahoo Beach Sandals & Google Privacy Cup

2011: The latest images culled from the web, showing what people eat at the search engine companies, how they play, who they meet, where they speak, what toys they have, and more.


Google Maps To Add “Google Store Views”

2010: Google Store Views would allow people to virtually walk into the store, off of Google Street Views.


Yahoo Sells “Non-Core” Asset HotJobs For $225 Million

2010: Yahoo would continue to have a career site, but it would be powered and populated by Monster.


2001 In Review: Search Engine Marketing Gets Respect, As Does Search Generally

2010: Major events from the year 2001 in consumer search. 


Google Latitude: Share Your Location On Google Maps

2009: More coverage: Google Latitude Turns Maps (For Mobile) Into Social Tool


Google Android Phone Finds Its Voice (Search That Is)

2009: Google was rolling out voice search on the Android platform via the new software update.


FriendFeed Improves Search Features

2009: You could use the advanced search features and then subscribe to that search via RSS.


Internet Explorer 8 Search Now Showing Instant Answers From Live Search

2009: Instant answers were shown for searches related to financial information, weather conditions, movie show times, calculations, equations, conversions, and definitions.


Yahoo Starting To Roll Out “Search Pad” Feature

2009: The application automatically collected sites and content as users conducted online research.


Google’s Influence In The Oval Office

2009: Google was the “fourth-largest corporate source of campaign cash” for President Obama’s presidential race.


Virtual Earth’s First 2009 Imagery Update

2009: The major updates included the new Digital Globe satellite imagery they recently licensed and “bird’s eye” photos of Paris, France. 


IAC Troubles, Ask.com, And Post-Yahoo Search Share

2008: IAC claimed the legal battle for control of IAC’s board was impeding the company’s ability to effectively operate.


Microsoft’s Prize: Big Yahoo CPMs, Largest Display Share

2008: Yahoo ranked as the top site with just under 19% of US online display advertising.


Google Releases New Urchin Beta

2008: For those who required server-based analytics.


EU Prepares “Objections” To Google-DoubleClick Acquisition

2008: The European Union’s antitrust regulator was likely to impose conditions or ask Google for concessions in order to bless the acquisition.


Google Files Screenshots Of Compensation Tool With SEC

2008: The tool modeled the potential value of Google equity awards, including transferable stock options.


From Search Marketing Expo (SMX)


Past contributions from Search Engine Land’s Subject Matter Experts (SMEs)

These columns are a snapshot in time and have not been updated since publishing, unless noted. Opinions expressed in these articles are those of the author and not necessarily Search Engine Land.


< February 3 | Search Marketing History | February 5 >


Related stories

New on Search Engine Land

@media screen and (min-width: 800px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:770px; min-height:260px; } } @media screen and (min-width: 1279px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:800px!important; min-height:440px!important; } }

About the author

Danny Goodwin

Danny Goodwin is Managing Editor of Search Engine Land & SMX. In addition to writing daily about SEO, PPC, and more for Search Engine Land, Goodwin also manages Search Engine Land’s roster of subject-matter experts. He also helps program our conference series, SMX – Search Marketing Expo. Prior to joining Search Engine Land, Goodwin was Executive Editor at Search Engine Journal, where he led editorial initiatives for the brand. He also was an editor at Search Engine Watch. He has spoken at many major search conferences and virtual events, and has been sourced for his expertise by a wide range of publications and podcasts.

https://searchengineland.com/search-marketing-history-february-4-392677




Google search, network, and YouTube revenue all fell in Q4 2022

Search, ad network, and YouTube revenues all fell in the fourth quarter of 2022, Google reported yesterday. Overall, Google ad revenue fell 3% to $59 billion. 

Search advertising revenue was the most resilient, falling 1.6% in Q4 2022 compared to Q4 2021. Google Network and YouTube revenue declined 8.6% and 7.0%, respectively. 

Google Q4 2022 ad revenue by segment
Q4 2022 Q4 2021 Change
Search & other $42.6 billion $43.3 billion – 1.6%
Google Network $8.5 billion $9.3 billion -8.6%
YouTube $8.0 billion $8.6 billion -7.0%

A poor economic climate. Google CFO Ruth Porat told CNBC the YouTube slowdown was the result of both planned and direct response advertising in a challenging economic climate. She said Google is slowing the pace of hiring in an effort to deliver long-term profitable growth. Last month, Google said it would lay off around 6% of its workforce or roughly 12,000 jobs. The company has about 187,000 employees. 

ICYMI, Meta also blamed a poor economic climate on their own weak ad demand.

Trouble for YouTube. YouTube’s ad revenue fell below analyst predictions to reach $7.96 billion, a decrease of 8% from the previous year’s $8.63 billion. On Thursday, Google CEO Sundar Pichai said in addition to the overall pullback in ad spending, YouTube is also facing heightened competition from TikTok in short-form videos. Meta also said competition from TikTok was limiting growth. 

The financial outlook at YouTube could get even bleaker as it begins paying for rights to professional football games. In December, the National Football League announced that YouTube will pay approximately $2 billion annually for the rights to broadcast “Sunday Ticket” to homes, in a seven-year deal. That’s expected to be a loss-leader that enables YouTube to acquire more paying subscribers. 

Dig deeper. You can review the earnings here.

Why we care. A decline in ad revenue could affect the platform’s ability to reach its target audience and in turn, the success of its advertising campaigns. Lower ad revenue could also result in less investment in platform improvements and innovations, leading to a less favorable advertising environment.

Additionally, a continual decrease in ad revenue may cause a shift in pricing, competition for ad placements, and changes to the platform’s advertising policies. If Google shifts its attention toward AI, advertisers could lose more control over their campaigns. 

On the other hand, a decline in revenue could result in a decline in demand, which could lower ad costs for advertisers.


Related stories

New on Search Engine Land

@media screen and (min-width: 800px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:770px; min-height:260px; } } @media screen and (min-width: 1279px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:800px!important; min-height:440px!important; } }

About the author

Nicole Farley

Nicole Farley is an editor for Search Engine Land covering all things PPC. In addition to being a Marine Corps veteran, she has an extensive background in digital marketing, an MBA and a penchant for true crime, podcasts, travel, and snacks.

https://searchengineland.com/google-search-network-and-youtube-revenue-all-fell-in-q4-2022-392611




This day in search marketing history: February 3

How Google uses AI in search

In 2022, we learned more about how Google was using AI in search – for understanding language for query, content and ranking purposes.

The overview covered in what ways AI and machine learning helped Google Search perform its daily tasks. Specifically with:

  • RankBrain
  • Neural matching
  • BERT
  • MUM

In short, RankBrain, neural matching and BERT were all used in Google’s ranking system across many, if not most, queries and look at understanding the language of both the query and content it was ranking. However, MUM was not used for ranking purposes.

Read all about it in How Google uses artificial intelligence In Google Search.


Also on this day


Google will suspend merchant sites that show higher prices at checkout

2021: Starting on April 6, Google would begin enforcing price accuracy between Merchant Center feeds and checkout.


Google Search Console fixed a bug with Google Tag Manager verification

2020: Reverification may have been necessary.


Amazon’s booming ad business grew by 40% in 2019

2020: Amazon’s quarterly ad revenues surpassed $4 billion for the first time in Q4.


Video: Jennifer Van Iderstyne on agency types & multimedia SEO

2020: In this installment of Barry Schwartz’s vlog series, he also chatted with Van Iderstyne about content creation in SEO, capitalizing on misalignments in SEO and more.


YouTube sees 90% lift in searches for football highlight videos during the last year

2018: In addition to the rise in search activity, watch-time of sports highlight videos skyrocketed 80% between 2016 and 2017.


Unconfirmed Google algorithm update may be better at discounting links and spam

2017: It appeared to impact those using more aggressive link building.


Google adds a new carousel to let you expand the search results

2017: Google began letting searchers filter down their search results and/or expand their search results using a carousel-style slider at the top of the desktop and mobile search results.


Report: Releasing Super Bowl ads early jump-starts lifts in brand search

2017: Snickers and Budweiser saw by far the biggest jumps in brand search volume. 


Search in Pics: Google & Sergey Brin protests, an Asian conical hat room & Google Somalia store

2017: The latest images showing what people eat at the search engine companies, how they play, who they meet, where they speak, what toys they have and more. 


Amit Singhal, The Head Of Google Search, To Leave The Company For Philanthropic Purposes

2016: He had worked at the company for 15 years and was instrumental in shaping Google Search across desktop, mobile and other search appliances.


Google’s Shopping Campaign Expansion To Search Partners Is Gaining Traction

2016: Traffic from product listing ads on YouTube and third-party retailers and in image search began surging in Q4, Merkle data showed.


To Fight Radicalism In The UK, Google’s Giving Away Free Search Ads

2016: NGOs that promoted anti-radicalization would be able to use $10,000 worth of AdWords credits each month.


Google Issues Its 2014 “Bad Ads” Report: Disabled More Than Half A Billion Ads

2015: More than 43 million ads were disabled for using “Trick to Click” ploys.


Google’s Mortgage Calculator Quick Answer Now Live

2015: Google launched their dynamic mortgage calculator quick direct answer in the search results for variations of queries around [mortgage calculator].


Google’s Senior VP Of Knowledge, Alan Eustace, To Retire

2015: He joined Google in 2002 as the Senior Vice President of Engineering and then moved into Knowledge when Google began working on its Knowledge Graph.


Google Warns German Webmasters That Paid Links Violate Google’s Guidelines

2014: Google head of search spam Matt Cutts posted another stern warning to German webmasters about a link penalty looming for them.


Google Brings Search Funnels Attribution Modeling Tool To AdWords

2014: Advertisers could look at five different attribution models and compare up to three attribution models simultaneously to analyze keywords, ad groups and campaigns.


Google Places International Adds Over 1,000 New Categories For Business Listings

2014: The categories were available in the new Places dashboard globally and translated to every language Google supported.


Super Bowl 2014: How We Searched

2014: Recipes, start time, people. and Skittles.


Searching for The Super Bowl Start Time: 2013 Edition

2013: Google provided the answer right at the top of the page.


Google’s January Search Update: Panda In The Pipelines, Fresher Results, Date Detection & More

2012: Google’s monthly update of search tweaks from the prior month.


Chrome’s Market Share Drops In January; Was It Due To Google’s Penalty?

2012: After 17 straight months of gains in market share, Google’s Chrome web browser dropped 0.17%.


Google’s New Privacy Policy May Violate HIPAA, Congresswoman Says

2012: But was Google actually compelled to follow the HIPAA requirements?


Czech Republic Gives Google Green Light To Resume Street View

2012: Google agreed to several conditions put forth by the Czech Office for Personal Data Protection.


Search In Pics: Obama’s Google Hangout, SEO Cake & Zuckerberg’s Desk

2012: The latest images showing what people eat at the search engine companies, how they play, who they meet, where they speak, what toys they have, and more.


Google Webmaster Tools Search Queries Report Now Less Accurate

2011: Google started rounding the impressions and clicks to one or two significant digits (e.g., 246,000 impressions now showed as 250,000 impressions).


Did A Google Employee Just Register Hiybbprqag.com To Help Recruit New Employees?

2011: Google’s Jobs page, which was at https://www.google.com/intl/en/jobs/index.html, could also be reached by going to hiybbprqag.com, via a 302 redirect.


Colbert: “Hiybbprqag Is A Word Meaning You Got Served”

2011: Despite being sponsored by Bing, Colbert came down in Google’s favor on “The Colbert Report” – at least jokingly.


Top AdWords Get Longer, Leaner Look

2011: Many AdWords placements at the top of the page would be getting extended headlines.


Answers.com Acquired For $127 Million

2011: But shareholders promised to prevent the deal from happening.


Yahoo Completes Outsourcing Its Real Estate Search To Zillow

2011: The two companies said this deal created “the largest real estate network on the web,” and involved several elements.


He Calls Google A Vampire, But Mark Cuban’s Mahalo Is Doing The Sucking

2010: Cuban was an investor in Mahalo, which touted to advertisers how it taps into Google to generate page views.


Report: Digital Marketing Budgets To Increase In 2010

2010: 64% planned to increase budgets for search engine optimization, and 51% planned to increase budgets for paid search marketing.


Do Search Engines (Google) “Harm Minority Owned Businesses”?

2010: More concerns about reports that Google was “heavily biased towards established brands” (i.e., wealth rather than merit). 


Google’s Recent Bugs: SMS Spam, Safe Filter Stuck, News Fonts & Google Docs Spam

2009: Many users complained that they were unable to change the safe search filter.


Google AJAX Search Results = Death To Search Term Tracking?

2009: If Google rolled out AJAX-based search results on a wide scale, there were concerns about the ramifications for SEO rank checking software and other tools.


Judgment Day For Four Google Execs In Italian Court

2009: The case was over a video uploaded to YouTube where a disabled child was being taunted.


Another French Court Rules Against Google On Trademark Claim

2009: Google was ordered to pay a total of €350,000 ($454,000) for violating two companies’ trademarks by allowing other companies to bid on the terms in AdWords.


Ask.com & Symantec Partner To Detect Malicious Sites

2009: When a search was run from the Norton toolbar, results were safety-rated by Symantec using a color-coded icon, to flag sites or sections of sites that could have been malicious or harmful.


Yahoo Communications Head Jill Nash To Depart

2009: Nash was “spent” after the transition from Terry Semel to Jerry Yang and the MicroHoo rollercoaster.


National Pork Board Says Sorry About The Breastfeeding Thing

2007: They apologized over the legal threat about her using “The Other White Milk” as a slogan on shirts supporting breastfeeding.


From Search Marketing Expo (SMX)


Past contributions from Search Engine Land’s Subject Matter Experts (SMEs)

These columns are a snapshot in time and have not been updated since publishing, unless noted. Opinions expressed in these articles are those of the author and not necessarily Search Engine Land.


< February 2 | Search Marketing History | February 4 >


Related stories

New on Search Engine Land

@media screen and (min-width: 800px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:770px; min-height:260px; } } @media screen and (min-width: 1279px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:800px!important; min-height:440px!important; } }

About the author

Danny Goodwin

Danny Goodwin is Managing Editor of Search Engine Land & SMX. In addition to writing daily about SEO, PPC, and more for Search Engine Land, Goodwin also manages Search Engine Land’s roster of subject-matter experts. He also helps program our conference series, SMX – Search Marketing Expo. Prior to joining Search Engine Land, Goodwin was Executive Editor at Search Engine Journal, where he led editorial initiatives for the brand. He also was an editor at Search Engine Watch. He has spoken at many major search conferences and virtual events, and has been sourced for his expertise by a wide range of publications and podcasts.

https://searchengineland.com/search-marketing-history-february-3-392610




Meta blames weak advertising demand, rivals for Q4 2022 revenue decline

Weak advertising demand and competition from TikTok and other rivals yielded lower fourth quarter revenue and profit for Meta, Facebook’s parent company. 

Ad revenue was down 4% to $31.3 billion at Meta’s advertising-supported properties, including   Facebook, Instagram, Messenger, and WhatsApp. Advertising revenue was 97% of Meta’s total revenue in the quarter. 

Ad revenue in North America was flat, declined 16% in Europe and 3% in the Asia-Pacific. Revenue increased by 5% elsewhere (“Rest of World” in the table below). 

Screen Shot 2023 02 01 At 4.48.03 PM 800x455

The decline was attributed to “weak advertising demand, which we believe continues to be impacted by the uncertain and volatile macroeconomic landscape,” by Meta CFO Susan Li. 

Strategy shift for Facebook and Instagram content. “Facebook and Instagram are shifting from being organized solely around people and accounts you follow to increasingly showing more relevant content recommended by our AI systems,” Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg said on the company’s earnings call. 

Reels growth. Zuckerberg also said that Reels plays across Facebook and Instagram have more than doubled over the last year, and the social component of people resharing Reels has more than doubled on both in just the last 6 months. 

The challenge for Reels is “improving monetization efficiency, or the revenue that’s generated per minute of Reels watched,” according to Zuckerberg.

The future for Meta ads. Meta will continue to monetize WhatsApp as well as messaging ads by utilizing an in-app feature allowing consumers to interact directly with businesses.

  • Plans to continue monetizing messaging with click-to-message ads, which currently generate revenue of $10 billion
  • Onboarding more businesses to the WhatsApp Business Platform, where businesses can answer customer questions, send updates and sell directly in chat

Apple’s App Tracking Transparency measures still reducing revenue. “I think what I would say is there is still certainly an absolute headwind to our revenue number,” Li said when asked whether Apple’s ATT (app tracking transparency) measures were reducing revenue. 

“Having said that, we are lapping its rollout and adoption, and we’re making progress in mitigating the impact due to a lot of the work that … I just talked about, including the different advertiser tools, including ad formats that bring conversions on site and including the longer-term AI investments in privacy-enhancing technologies.”

Dig deeper. You can review the earnings transcript on Meta’s Investor Relations site. 


Related stories

New on Search Engine Land

@media screen and (min-width: 800px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:770px; min-height:260px; } } @media screen and (min-width: 1279px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:800px!important; min-height:440px!important; } }

About the author

Nicole Farley

Nicole Farley is an editor for Search Engine Land covering all things PPC. In addition to being a Marine Corps veteran, she has an extensive background in digital marketing, an MBA and a penchant for true crime, podcasts, travel, and snacks.

https://searchengineland.com/meta-blames-weak-advertising-demand-rivals-for-q4-2022-revenue-decline-392607