This day in search marketing history: January 19

Google’s page layout algorithm launches

In 2012, Google announced it would penalize sites with pages that were top-heavy with ads.

The page layout algorithm update took direct aim at any site with pages where content was buried under tons of ads.

According to Google:

If you click on a website and the part of the website you see first either doesn’t have a lot of visible content above-the-fold or dedicates a large fraction of the site’s initial screen real estate to ads, that’s not a very good user experience. Such sites may not rank as highly going forward.

Google’s Matt Cutts, Page layout algorithm improvement

On the same day, a message from Google’s AdSense team went out, encouraging some publishers to add more ads to their sites.

Isn’t it ironic.

Read all about it in: The Top Heavy Update: Pages with too many ads above the fold now penalized by Google’s “Page Layout” algorithm.


Also on this day 


Google explains how it deduplicates Top Stories from main search results

2022: Google said it deduplicates a link from its main web results if that same link appears in the first Top Stories slot, so long as the Top Stories section appears before the main web results.


Google recipe markup now requires specific times, no more time ranges

2022: Google removed all references to using time ranges in the recipe schema markup help documents.


Marketers, Google agree that proposed ‘surveillance advertising’ ban goes too far

2022: The legislation would have been a game-changer for every digital marketer who advertises on Google, Facebook and other advertising platforms. 


Google Ads’ updated Experiments page sheds campaign drafts and adds experiment sync

2022: Advertisers no longer had to create a separate campaign draft and changes made to the original campaign are automatically synced to the experiment as well.


Google heightens adult ad policy enforcement after Reuters finds illicit ads

2022: Ads for sex toys, liquor and high-risk investments were discovered in Google’s search results, which violated the company’s attempts to comply with UK regulations.


Google crawl stats report now showing more crawls

2021: This was just a reporting change and any change seen in crawling was not reflective of any change in search results. 


DuckDuckGo’s focus on privacy-minded users pushes it past 100 million searches in a single day

2021: DuckDuckGo served 102,251,307 search queries for the first time, breaking past the 100 million query milestone.


Video: Phillip Thune on finding good writers and writing good content

2021: In this installment of Barry Schwartz’s vlog series, he also chatted with Thune about how SEOs changed how they approached content development after Panda and Penguin.


Search in Pics: A pig visits Google, big teddy bear & a broken Google sign

2018: The latest images culled from the web, showing what people eat at the search engine companies, how they play, who they meet, where they speak, what toys they have and more.


Matt Cutts officially resigns from Google

2017: Cutts became the new director of engineering at the US Digital Service. He had been on leave with Google since 2014.


Study shows search terms with the very worst (and best) click-through rates

2017: Study examined the top 50 keyword “stems” to find what terms helped spur clicks and, more importantly, what terms didn’t.


DuckDuckGo surpasses 10 billion searches, with 4 billion happening in 2016 alone

2017: The search engine said 4 billion of those searches happened in 2016.


Google Revamps Their Webmasters Portal With Clean New Slick Design & Resources

2016: The resource got a new design, better organization and three new features (webmaster troubleshooter, popular resources, event calendar).


Google Expandable PLA View Test Displays 16 Product Listing Ads

2016: When expanded, PLAs muscled out other ads and organic listings to take over most of the above-the-fold real estate.


You Can Now Install Android Apps Directly From Google’s Search Results

2016: Bypassing the need to visit the Google Play store.


Google Sending Mobile Usability Warnings To Huge Number Of Webmasters

2015: These notifications warned there were critical mobile usability errors on 100% of the pages on the site and thus the pages would be “displayed and ranked appropriately for smartphone users.”


Bing-Yahoo Paid Search Share Rises For Two Consecutive Quarters [IgnitionOne]

2015: Advertisers increased spending by 31% year-over-year on the Yahoo Bing Network (through the Bing Ads platform). Spending on Google AdWords rose by 5%.


Yahoo Search Testing Google’s Search Results Design?

2015: The whole page looked right out of Google’s search results design.


Google’s 2015 Martin Luther King, Jr. Day Logo Designed By Ekua Holmes

2015: The Doodle featured Martin Luther King, Jr. in locked arms with fellow civil rights activists with the American flag in the background.


Google: Paid Clicks Up 34% While Cost Per Click Down 8% YoY

2012: More people were clicking on ads, but those clicks were costing advertisers less money per click.


Nokia Now “Powering” Bing Maps

2012: Nokia branding would soon be showing up on Bing Maps for mobile.


Google Maps Now Highlighting Borders Of Cities, Postal Codes & More

2012: Google Maps added a feature where it would highlight in a pink color the borders of a city, postal code or other borders based on your search.


How To Track U.S. Congress Members’ Tweets

2012: PolitickerUSA let you access the non-stop real-time stream of tweets from Senators, Reps, President Obama, governors, and a few of the Republican presidential candidates.


Study: Google “Favors” Itself Only 19% Of The Time

2011: “Even if Google listed itself first for [email] … is it really anti-competitive when its competitor is prominently listed in second place? Wouldn’t it really be more of a concern if Google didn’t list its competitors at all?”


Google Makes Modest Comeback In China

2011: 23.1% of Chinese search users wanted Google.


Deconstructing “Search Neutrality”

2011: In an academic article, an NYU associate law professor closely examined and deconstructed the arguments behind the idea of search neutrality.


Google Knol Still Alive & Fixed, But Questions Linger About Its Future

2011: Google fixed a bug that made Knol look like a ghost town.


Google Exposes Maps Options With New Widget Display

2011: Google formally launched a new Google Maps display that made the different viewing options much more visible.


SEO Gets Dissed by CBS TV Series “The Good Wife”

2011: Let the court record show, for the education of “The Good Wife” writers, and good citizens everywhere – when “SEO” or search engine optimization is performed according to the best practices and guidelines set forth by major search engines, then SEO is considered to be a useful, effective and legal technique for driving visitors to a website.


Google Opens Up Downloads To Iran But Blocks Iranian Government

2011: After years of not allowing those in Iran to download their software, Google opened up downloads of their Google Earth, Picasa and Chrome applications.


Search & The 2011 Sundance Film Festival

2011: Bing was the official search engine of the 2011 Sundance Film Festival website, and YouTube had two special channels for the event.


Real-Time Search Engine Collecta Hits Pause

2011: The company took “a step back” to retool its approach.


Google’s Fourth Doodle 4 Google Competition Announced

2011: “What I’d like to do someday…”


Google’s Paul Cézanne Logo

2011: The logo was first created as a real oil painting by a Googler and then digitized. 


Google Changes How It Handles Synonyms

2010: Rather than only bolding direct variants of words (like “photos” for “pictures”), Google “extended this to words that our algorithms very confidently think mean the same thing, even if they are spelled nothing like the original term.”


Bing Updates Autosuggest With News & Trending Queries

2010: Bing added “breaking news and hot trending queries” into autosuggest, with updates being pushed out every 15 minutes.


Microsoft Complies With EU Demand, First To Cut Data Retention To Six Months

2010: Microsoft became the first of the major search engines to agree to the European Union’s demand that data retention be cut to six months. 


Yahoo Search Marketing Launches New Network Distribution & Import Campaigns

2010: The new network distribution and import campaigns went live for Yahoo advertisers.


Can Google Tell Us What Men and Women Are REALLY Thinking?

2010: What Google Suggest had to say about what men and women were really thinking.


Google New York Expanding

2010: Google was expanding its already humongous New York office by 57,000 square feet. 


Google Testing “Preferred Sites” Option In Search Preferences

2009: Users who were in this experiment could add a list of sites in their search preferences page as their “preferred sites.”


Report: Search Spending Off 8% In Q4

2009: Advertisers who spent less than $50,000 on search ads cut their spending by 23% year-over-year, while advertisers that spent more than $200,000 on search per month cut spending by 9% during that time.


No Surprise: IAA Survey Shows Concern Over Google Market Dominance

2009: 65% said there was one dominant player in the online ad market and that there were “limited choices and price options for online advertisers.”


Google Quietly Drops iPhone Optimized iGoogle Page

2009: Google said the reason they dropped the iPhone version was because they “want to ensure you’ll all see the same version” of the iGoogle mobile page. 


Live Search News Adds Email Alerts

2009: You could get these alerts via email either once a day, twice a day or weekly and you could subscribe by section or by search phrase.


Some Parallels Between Obama And Yahoo’s Carol Bartz

2009: Both Barack Obama and incoming Yahoo CEO Carol Bartz were taking charge of their respective administrations at times of crisis.


GDrive: It’s Alive! — Or So It Appears

2009: Renewed buzz and speculation.


Google & Others Martin Luther King Jr.’s Logos

2009: How the search engines commemorated Martin Luther King Jr. Day.


Checking Out Allcheckin Travel Search

2007: Some thoughts on a travel search alternative.


Yahoo Introduces Personal Finance Site

2007: This new sub-site offered “free tools and how-to guides for tax planning, budgeting, real estate planning, and saving for college and retirement.”


Google Book Search To Add Chinese Books

2007: The initial launch would be about 1,000 books, with the hope of having 3,000 book titles in Google Book Search by year’s end.


Search Engines’ Test Beds

2007: An overview of the different ways search engines like Google, Yahoo, Microsoft and Ask.com used “spin off” sites to test new features.


Yahoo Tells Belgian Newspapers They Did Nothing Wrong

2007: Yahoo said they did not violate any copyright laws for “publishing snippets and links” to their newspapers.


Google, Microsoft & Yahoo To Develop NGO Conduct Code

2007: This move was to help the companies’ ventures into China and help paint a better picture for the search giants in the public view.


Yahoo Debuts U.S. Schools Search Tool

2007: Results were plotted on a map, and you could sort by school district, distance from a specific location, grade level, or school type (public, private, charter). 


Looksmart’s Furl Gets A Facelift

2007: Looksmart also made it easier to create and find topics to help organize saved web pages, and improved the browser buttons and toolbar used to save pages.


Google Picks North Carolina For Server Farm

2007: Google was expected to spend about $600 million on their new data center and employ 210 people.


From Search Marketing Expo (SMX)


Past contributions from Search Engine Land’s Subject Matter Experts (SMEs)

These columns are a snapshot in time and have not been updated since publishing, unless noted. Opinions expressed in these articles are those of the author and not necessarily Search Engine Land.


< January 18 | Search Marketing History | January 20 >


Related stories

New on Search Engine Land

@media screen and (min-width: 800px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:770px; min-height:260px; } } @media screen and (min-width: 1279px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:800px!important; min-height:440px!important; } }

About the author

Danny Goodwin

Danny Goodwin is Managing Editor of Search Engine Land & SMX. In addition to writing daily about SEO, PPC, and more for Search Engine Land, Goodwin also manages Search Engine Land’s roster of subject-matter experts. He also helps program our conference series, SMX – Search Marketing Expo. Prior to joining Search Engine Land, Goodwin was Executive Editor at Search Engine Journal, where he led editorial initiatives for the brand. He also was an editor at Search Engine Watch. He has spoken at many major search conferences and virtual events, and has been sourced for his expertise by a wide range of publications and podcasts.

https://searchengineland.com/search-marketing-history-january-19-391879




Efficiency vs. volume in PPC: 4 tips to strike a balance in incremental conversions

In search marketing, you are often captive to what you can measure. That means if it’s not directly converting (or even converting with data-driven attribution), it’s wasted spend. 

Another way to frame this is the tradeoffs between efficiency and volume. The terms you are bidding on will eventually convert (unless you are bidding on utterly unrelated terms). But the question is, was that spend efficient and valuable?

In this article, I will share some insights about striking the right balance between efficiency and volume, a productive and healthy debate search marketers can have with businesses.  

1. Determine how the business is operating

We always suggest starting with how the business is operating overall. Each business has some important metrics that drive its decision-making. 

  • Is the business profitable? 
  • What is the available capacity of the team or product line? 
  • Are there specific seasonalities or unique market forces that may alter the normal state of the business (supply chain, holidays)? 

For example, if the product is highly profitable and there is capacity in the business, you would be willing to pay more for additional traffic and sales. 

The opposite is true. If profitability is poor or capacity is limited, it might be desirable to limit the amount of traffic or only find really profitable sales. 

If you are in a seasonally driven business you might have to make hay while the sun is shining. These are just a few factors that might impact your efficiency vs. volume debate. 

2. Forecast at various levels

A great place to start is Google Ads Performance Planner tool which can be found under Tools > Settings in the top menu bar. This tool lets you get a sense of the opportunity for your existing campaigns. 

You can select which of your search or Performance Max campaigns you would like to forecast the opportunity. Input and select some options to help generate some results.

Google will then create an output that looks like the one below. It creates a curve that provides the expected output of conversions for a variety of spend inputs. 

You can create something like this for as few or as many campaigns as possible. Certainly, the input data and output curves will adjust. Often, the more granular you go the more specific and varied the curves will be. 


Get the daily newsletter search marketers rely on.


3. Evaluate the incremental cost per conversion

Now that you have this curve, the next step is to evaluate the incremental cost per conversion at various levels.

As a search marketer, it can be easy to focus on just the total CPA within search. However, there are other potential options that a business could use to invest in. 

What we recommend is to review the impact of various spend levels and what the next level of investment will do to the metrics. A table like the one below is a simple approach to this. 

To get the incremental cost per acquisition, take the forecasted spend and conversions at various levels and subtract the new level from the prior level. 

Often, brands just look at the total CPA in aggregate and ignore incremental cost per acquisition. Looking at it at the incremental level will give you something to compare to other opportunities. 

For example, in the table above, going up from a total CPA of $351 to $405 is only a 15% increase in CPA. However, the incremental CPA is $891 or 120% above the total CPA of $405. 

This should spark the question, what else can I invest in that will drive a lower CPA than $891? This could be anything from product enhancements or advertising spend outside of search (display, social, programmatic). 

If something else can help you beat the $891 incremental CPA, then it is a better investment. Certainly, there are other things to consider, like level of effort and resourcing. 

4. Choose your bid models

Look at Google Ads’ different automated bid models as you decide. You can set target CPA, ROAS, or impression share or maximize event outcomes (conversions, clicks, conversion value). 

These models also play a part in incremental cost decisions. 

  • If you choose to target a CPA, the optimization will prioritize hitting that CPA goal. 
  • If you look to maximize conversions, the CPA target will no longer be in control and volume will be the primary metric. 

Both models have a purpose depending on your business metrics and the priorities of the business at any given time. We see brands shifting between these models depending on their specific business objectives. 

Deciding between efficiency vs. volume in PPC

There is no “right” option to this matter and it certainly isn’t a static decision.

The choice between efficiency and volume should always be discussed and tested. Search is incredible in this regard. You can always adjust your aggressiveness levels on a near real-time basis. 

I once managed paid search campaigns for mortgages for four different banks simultaneously. All four had vastly different CPA targets given their business metrics and goals at the time. 

So take a step back, look at the business overall and understand how incremental spend or savings would impact the business. 

  • What is the incremental opportunity? 
  • How else can you find incremental results? 
  • Should you spend in other areas, improve the conversion flow, and just save the money? 

Once you start using data and understand how your potential actions will impact the broader business, you will be well on your way to balancing efficiency and volume. (Until you need to debate it again, that is. Because trust me, you always will.) 


Opinions expressed in this article are those of the guest author and not necessarily Search Engine Land. Staff authors are listed here.


Related stories

New on Search Engine Land

@media screen and (min-width: 800px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:770px; min-height:260px; } } @media screen and (min-width: 1279px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:800px!important; min-height:440px!important; } }

About the author

Jason Tabeling

Jason Tabeling is the CEO of Airtank and is an accomplished marketing executive and proven leader with over 20 years of experience growing strong and profitable teams, working for and with Fortune 500 companies in a variety of industries.
Prior to AirTank, Jason served as Executive Vice President of Product for BrandMuscle, an enterprise software and services company focused on Fortune 1,000 brands, where he led product innovation and strategy. He earned the company a Leadership Ranking in the Forrester 2020 Through-Channel Marketing Automation Wave. He also spent 16 years working with Rosetta, Razorfish and Progressive Insurance, leading Paid, Earned and Owned media teams across health care, financial services and retail verticals. He was named a “40 under 40” by Direct Marketing News, has been a judge for the AMA Reggie Awards, and has been published in Forbes and many other publications as a subject matter expert.

https://searchengineland.com/ppc-efficiency-vs-volume-tips-incremental-conversions-391826




This day in search marketing history: January 18

Google blackens its logo, configures Googlebot to crawl at a much lower rate

In 2012, when you visited Google, you saw this:

That’s how Google voiced its opposition to two bills being discussed in Congress – the Protect IP Act (PIPA) and the Stop Online Piracy Act (SOPA). At the time, many feared the proposed legislation would censor the web and hurt U.S. businesses.

What about the SEO impact? Google had previously shared some SEO blackout advice.

Also on this day in 2012, Google’s Pierre Far revealed that GoogleBot would “crawl at a much lower rate for today only so that the Google results of websites participating in the blackout are less likely to be affected.”

Read all about it in:


Also on this day 


URL changes are not so simple for Google Search

2022: These changes, if done properly, can take several months for Google to fully process.


Yoast SEO launches on Shopify

2022: Shopify merchants could use the app to optimize their products and posts to show in organic, non-shopping results.


Danny Goodwin joins Search Engine Land

2022: I joined the team as Senior Editor. Now I’m Managing Editor of Search Engine Land & SMX.


Microsoft seeks more Cortana distribution, deeper integration on Android, iOS

2019: Amazon and Microsoft’s interests were aligned in that each wanted access to the other’s audience for distribution.


Leveraging Amazon search ads in a time of rapid change

2019: Amazon’s advertising offerings were getting more sophisticated, presenting marketers with new opportunities and complexities.


Google My Business videos not showing up on your local listing? It’s a Google bug

2018: A bug prevented the video uploads from showing up on the local listings in Google Maps or Google web search.


Study: 80% of Google Home results come from snippets

2018: In the majority of cases, the Google Home result mirrored the snippet/Answer Box. But in a number of cases, when there was a snippet, Home provided no answer or a different answer.


Google adds keyword functionality to the AdWords app

2018: Advertisers could make more on-the-go changes.


Google Android search app will keep trying your searches when your internet connection is poor

2017: The new version of the Google Android search app worked better when you were in a poor internet connection area.


Bing Ads rolls out scheduling for ad extensions

2017: The option to show extensions during store hours or schedule for time-sensitive promotions became available in all markets.


Google testing new look for local inventory ads in place of local pack

2017: Another effort to monetize local queries on mobile.


Google Core Algorithm Updates Continue As SEOs Notice Weekend Google Update

2016: Gary Illyes from Google said the weekend fluctuations were “core algorithm” and “not Penguin.”


Survey: Under 40 Percent Start A Local Search With A Search Engine

2016: Roughly half of searchers (48%) said that when they were seeking information on a “familiar topic,” they would start at a vertical or content-specific site (e.g., TripAdvisor for hotels). 


Google To Shut Several Search APIs In February

2016: Google said it would close the Google Patent Search API, Google News Search API, Google Blog Search API, Google Video Search API, Google Image Search APIs on Feb. 15.


Martin Luther King Jr. Day Google Doodle Celebrates Civil Rights Leader’s Moving Speeches

2016: The Doodle artfully highlighted the civil rights leader’s ability to deliver “poignant truths in beautiful and moving speeches.”


UPDATED: Bug Affecting Optimization by Acquisition In Some AdWords Accounts

2013: Google confirmed a bug that caused conversions from Google Analytics to not be imported into AdWords properly.


Sign of Hope? Banned Advertisers Rises Just 8 Percent in 2012

2013: Google axed 224 million bad ads in 2012. (Google blocked 3.4 billion ads in 2021. So much for that “hope”?)


Google Improves Handwrite Your Search Feature

2013: Google made three improvements: fast alternatives to letters, overlapping letters and Chinese character improvements.


Facebook’s Graph Search & YourTrove’s Social Search: 5 Questions With Jesse Emery

2013: The co-founder and chief identity officer shared his thoughts on Graph Search, how it was different from YourTrove, and how it might impact YourTrove’s plans.


Search In Pics: Google Chefs, Android Rubik’s Cubes & Google Docks View

2013: The latest images culled from the Web, showing what people eat at the search engine companies, how they play, who they meet, where they speak, what toys they have, and more.


AdWords Gets More Granular With New Mobile Targeting Options

2012: The new features allowed advertisers to target to specific versions of operating systems, to ensure the ads were going to the right users.


Google’s 5th “Doodle 4 Google” Contest Opens For K-12 Students

2012: The winning Google logo would appear on a box of Crayola crayons and on the Google home page on May 18. 


Research: Optimism Fueled SEM Growth in Q4, But ROI Lagged

2011: Spending on search engine marketing grew 23% year-over-year in the fourth quarter of 2010.


Google Says “Ciao” To Antitrust Claim In Italy

2011: The investigation was initiated in 2009 after complaints by Italian publishers that they couldn’t remove links from Google News, which they said wasn’t sending them traffic, without also removing them from Google.com search results, which would have hurt their general traffic and ad revenues.


European Google Antitrust Questionnaire Revealed

2011: The four main questions and areas of inquiry against Google.


Bing Terminates Relationship With Publisher Doing Tricky Home Page Switch

2011: Make-My-Baby.com was suggesting that people needed a plug-in to use it – one that would install a toolbar and change their search provider and home page to Bing.


Gazopa Adds Stock Photos To Image Search Engine

2011: The stock photos were all coming from Shutterstock.


Google Gets 75% Of Paid Search Clicks & Dollars: Report

2010: The stats cover Q4 of 2009, and show Google’s share of paid search clicks rising from 71% in Q3 to 74.4% in Q4.


Google Now Collecting Local Reviews From Non-Traditional Sources

2010: Reviews came from news sites, hyperlocal blogs and local portals.


Apple iPhone To Drop Google For Bing?

2010: Some analysts suspected Apple would drop Google as the default iPhone search provider, in favor of Bing.


Study Looks At Personalization’s Impact On Search Results

2010: The test looked at each searcher’s location, browser, most common Google app used, and use of search history features.


German Companies Piling On With Anti-Trust Complaints Against Google

2010: Publishers, a shopping site and a mapping site.


More Haiti Disaster Relief Resources

2010: Google, Yahoo and Bing were offering cash donations and resources to assist with disaster relief in Haiti.


Martin Luther King Day Logos From Google & Others

2010: Search engine logos and themes for the special day.


FeedBurner Numbers Spike — Blame FeedBlitz!

2008: Why FeedBurner stats went wonky.


Conjunction Junction, Google No Longer Displays Stop Words Malfunction

2008: In the past, searches involving for “stop words” — prepositions, pronouns, articles, and other small words like “be” or “to” — would return a warning saying that these words were “a very common word and were not included in your search.”


3rd Annual Yahoo Searchlight Awards

2008: The event was dedicated to the idea that search isn’t a silo and that online (or traditional) ad campaigns that don’t include search are not going to be as effective.


Jupiter: Local Online Advertising Will Be Worth $8.9 Billion In 2012

2008: Local search was $2.5 billion of that total.


Center For The Digital Future: Perceptions Of Search Reliability And Accuracy Declining

2008: 51% of Internet users said that most or all of the information produced by search engines was reliable and accurate, down from 62% in 2006.


Search in Pictures: Sheryl Crow At Yahoo, Google Cupcakes, Goooooooooooogle Amsterdam

2008: The latest images culled from the web, showing what people eat at the search engine companies, how they play, who they meet, where they speak, what toys they have, and more.


Singapore Offers Cash Incentives To Build New Search Engine

2008: Singapore’s Agency for Science, Technology, and Research was managing a contest to build out “a next-generation multi-media online search engine.”


Google Advertising Google Audio Ads

2007: Google was promoting their own Audio Ads product via AdWords.


Will Paid Search Conquer The Mobile Internet?

2007: Regarding text-based advertising: 7% indicated some degree of interest in promotional text messages (2% were “very” or “extremely” interested), while 92% indicated little or no interest (78% were “not at all interested”).


Google’s Carolina Moves: $100 Million Tax Breaks In North, Server Farm Coming To South?

2007: North and South Carolina were offering major tax breaks to Google in order to encourage Google to build a massive data center in their state. 


JP Morgan Report Shows PayPal Dominating Google Checkout

2007: PayPal’s 42% penetration rate in 2006 was 7x that of Google checkout.


Yahoo TagMaps: Photos + Maps + Tags

2007: TagMaps were something like the word “tag clouds” meeting maps and Flickr. 


First Google, Then Microsoft, Now Belgian Newspapers Take On Yahoo

2007: The group didn’t want Yahoo giving web users archived access to newspaper articles that the newspapers would otherwise charge for.


Past contributions from Search Engine Land’s Subject Matter Experts (SMEs)

These columns are a snapshot in time and have not been updated since publishing, unless noted. Opinions expressed in these articles are those of the author and not necessarily Search Engine Land.


< January 17 | Search Marketing History | January 19 >


Related stories

New on Search Engine Land

@media screen and (min-width: 800px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:770px; min-height:260px; } } @media screen and (min-width: 1279px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:800px!important; min-height:440px!important; } }

About the author

Danny Goodwin

Danny Goodwin is Managing Editor of Search Engine Land & SMX. In addition to writing daily about SEO, PPC, and more for Search Engine Land, Goodwin also manages Search Engine Land’s roster of subject-matter experts. He also helps program our conference series, SMX – Search Marketing Expo. Prior to joining Search Engine Land, Goodwin was Executive Editor at Search Engine Journal, where he led editorial initiatives for the brand. He also was an editor at Search Engine Watch. He has spoken at many major search conferences and virtual events, and has been sourced for his expertise by a wide range of publications and podcasts.

https://searchengineland.com/search-marketing-history-january-18-391848




How to avoid 7 mistakes that tank retail Performance Max campaigns

Imagine this: A small business owner, relying on Google Ads to make sales on his Shopify store, has had his livelihood crushed by Performance Max in two months. Sales are practically zero, cost per conversion is up 20x ($6 to $120), yet his Optimization Score is at 100%.

It’s a real and unfortunate situation that contradicts Google’s stance that their automation makes online advertising easier.

In fact, it illustrates how desperately the PPC advertising community needs better education on ad platform automation, especially when it comes to something as prominent as Performance Max.

That business owner did everything Google recommended, nearly destroying his online business in the process, and it’s unlikely he’ll recover without the help of a seasoned Google Ads professional.

This is the future that Google’s automation was supposed to prevent, but instead, we’re still trying to understand the basics of a campaign type that’s largely a black box.

Let’s fix that. Here are seven mistakes I’ve seen people make with Performance Max campaigns that you can avoid repeating.

Mistake 1: Thinking audiences and audience signals work the same way

Audience signals don’t work the way audience segments do in other campaigns, because you can’t target specific audiences in Performance Max. Instead, you provide signals that tell Google who to start showing your ads to, and Google uses the initial data to expand your audience.

Many account managers underestimate the importance of audience signals (I’ve seen some skip it completely). But anything that relies this much on automation won’t work as intended unless you provide the strongest possible inputs.

That’s why my top recommendation is to make sure you start every Performance Max campaign with strong audience signals. These can include:

  • Everyone who converted on your website.
  • Email subscriber lists.
  • Historical customer data.
  • Repeat or high-spending customers.
  • Anyone else who you know is worth money to your business.
Performance Max audience signals
Source: Google.com

When you import those audiences at the start of a campaign, Google will analyze them for the millions of signals it tracks. And your campaign can begin with strong, relevant audience input instead of wasting money on guessing games.

Mistake 2: Neglecting your data feed

Because retail Performance Max and Standard Shopping campaigns rely on data feeds for keyword targeting, an incomplete feed means you’re missing out on potential opportunities. 

A lot of brands advertising on Google don’t pay enough attention to their data feed, and that goes for Standard Shopping campaigns, too. It’s tempting to get started in Google Ads immediately, but take a step back to the Merchant Center and optimize your data feed for the best results.

Some of the things my agency checks for include making sure that:

  • All products are categorized properly.
  • UPC codes are included where applicable.
  • Titles and descriptions are fully fleshed out.
  • Titles and descriptions feature keywords and search terms related to a product.

Provide Google’s systems with high-quality inputs, and stay on top of the data you share to keep it accurate and up-to-date.

Mistake 3: Picking the wrong campaign structure

I’ve seen many Performance Max campaigns with several asset groups targeting different audience signals, but with the same creative or products. In my experience, that goes against the spirit of how Performance Max works.

Instead, we build asset groups around product categories or services. Because our targeting is based on audience signals rather than lists, splitting them this way provides little to no benefit. The lack of reporting at the asset group level for Performance Max means it’s unclear how this is helpful.

Source: Producthero.com

If you use different UTM parameters to send multiple traffic sources to a page, you could view the data in Google Analytics or offline conversions. But different audience signals can still target the same cohort. You can’t target a fixed audience in Performance Max.

It may seem counterintuitive if you’re new to these campaigns, but my experience says that building asset groups around audience signals only confuses the system.


Get the daily newsletter search marketers rely on.


Many of my peers aren’t happy with the lack of control over where Performance Max places your ads, but there’s one way to counter this.

To set up Performance Max to work as Smart Shopping only, you have to do two things:

  • Remove all creative assets from the asset group.
  • Shut off URL expansion at the campaign level.

When you do those two things, the campaign will likely spend the core budget on Shopping with very little spilling over to placements like Search, YouTube, and Display.

On the flip side, if you remove the data feed entirely, your ads typically won’t show up in Search and Shopping as Google focuses more on YouTube, Gmail, Discovery and Display.

Outside of that and a few account-level exclusions, there really isn’t much you can do to control placement by the campaign.

So when we work with ecommerce clients with larger catalogs, we typically recommend running Performance Max and Shopping campaigns together.

That means running one product segment in Shopping – whether by category, sub-brand, or other attributes – and others (like top items) in Performance Max.

If a client is already active in Shopping and it’s working, we move some products that aren’t selling well to Performance Max. We may even do the opposite and move the top-performing products over. All we’re doing is testing what works to find the path to optimal profitability.

If you’re starting out with Performance Max and want to test Standard Shopping alongside it, what we recommend is looking for the subsets of products that are not getting:

  • Impressions
  • Clicks
  • Sales

Exclude those from Performance Max and put them in a Standard Shopping campaign where you have greater control.

Use manual bidding, be more aggressive with search term blocking, and use the added control to push those products to a stronger place.

Mistake 5: Saying ‘yes’ to all Google Ads recommendations

I can’t stress this enough: You should be the one making decisions about how to optimize your accounts and campaigns.

Google’s recommendations often focus on applying more automation and rely on the average of tens of millions of accounts. Only you have the ability to exercise judgment based on the nuances of your business.

Watch: How to turn off Google Ads auto-applied recommendations

During the automatic transition from Smart Shopping to Performance Max (now complete), the system automatically created a handful of non-Shopping assets – one or two images with your logo plus a couple of generic headlines – and began spending more of the budget outside of the data feed.

Smart Shopping may have split your budget 90/10 between Shopping and retargeting, but an “auto-upgraded” Performance Max campaign would spend a higher portion of your budget on prospecting ads using auto-generated assets that don’t convert well.

What helped us was making sure those assets were stripped away, and going back to core assets so the campaign could only target and create ads from your data feed. It might still spend more on prospecting than Smart Shopping, but it would be a much smaller expense with the focus largely on Shopping.

Mistake 6: Not optimizing assets to sculpt traffic

When I analyze a Performance Max campaign, I first look at total campaign spend and performance versus listing groups, data feed spend, and performance.

That gives me a breakdown of total spend on creative assets versus ads created from the feed. It’s not necessarily going to be 100% Shopping, it could be Display ads created using your feed.

When I see the performance of data feed ads versus creative assets, I better understand what direction to push the campaign in.

  • Is the campaign working much better on the data feed side? I’ll lean in and move to a Smart Shopping style campaign.
  • Is it getting better performance from creative assets? I’ll focus on putting out even better ones, like introducing top-performing assets from paid social campaigns.

While you won’t be able to see landing page performance reports in Performance Max, you can still revisit the “all campaigns” level and filter for Performance Max. This will show you which pages on your website Performance Max is driving traffic to. 

From there, exclude pages from being served in the campaign (via campaign settings), or exclude certain products or categories from the data feed so that it stops sending traffic to those pages.

There’s much you can do to sculpt where ad spend goes, but this information isn’t native or accessible to newer advertisers.

Mistake 7: Using the wrong bid strategy at the wrong time

Performance Max is a fully automated bidding zone and manual bidding doesn’t enter this conversation. So across all campaign types, our goal is going to be getting on Smart Bidding with a target ROAS – the closest to profitable campaigns.

For brand new campaigns outside of Performance Max, we usually recommend starting with Manual CPC or Maximize Clicks for the first couple of weeks. It might not convert as well, but the goal is to drive traffic so the system starts to see what people are clicking and converting on.

Then we typically switch to Maximize Conversions, which is where we start Performance Max campaigns because it’s the lowest level in that funnel.

  • Start with Maximize Conversions.
  • Let the system spend its full budget.
  • Win maximum traffic and study the data for patterns.
  • Change to Maximize Conversion Value.
  • Once you’re driving revenue, add a target ROAS.

A target ROAS tells Google you have a sales goal so it can push to meet that benchmark. Starting with it makes it difficult to gather enough data fast enough, which keeps you in the costly learning phase longer than necessary.

Our approach is to first make sure Google is spending the full budget and driving a nice amount of traffic, then to make sure we’re getting as many conversions as possible for that amount of traffic, and finally to push it to a place of profitability.

Google claims that a change in bid strategy puts the campaign back in a learning phase. But a change to your actual target – CPA for Maximize Conversions and ROAS for Maximize Conversion Value – should allow Google to adapt and continue. That said, I recommend changing targets in increments of no more than 10-20%.

The name of the game with Performance Max is “don’t shock the system.” Any drastic change will force it to look for new sources of converting traffic, resetting the learning phase. We’ve seen situations where it took up to six weeks to get campaigns back to a good place.

Getting comfortable with Performance Max

I get why there are mixed feelings around Performance Max.

When I started my search marketing career in 2003, I was resistant to change too. Any time Google introduced a new way to do things, I’d look for reasons it didn’t make sense.

But when you’ve seen as much change as I have in these two decades, you realize that ad platforms will keep moving forward. Google has a vision, they run the show, and it’s our job as search marketers to find ways to make it work for our clients and us.

In some ways, what we do is like a Performance Max campaign. We put in the work upfront to learn something new, hoping we’ll reach a place where things run smoothly without our constant intervention.

The first step is accepting change, even if you don’t agree with it. The longer you fight it, the more you’ll have to catch up with those who already began looking for solutions.

So don’t try to hack the system or look for shortcuts. Accept the new status quo, put in the work to evolve, and claim a place for yourself in the future of search engine marketing.


Opinions expressed in this article are those of the guest author and not necessarily Search Engine Land. Staff authors are listed here.


Related stories

New on Search Engine Land

@media screen and (min-width: 800px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:770px; min-height:260px; } } @media screen and (min-width: 1279px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:800px!important; min-height:440px!important; } }

About the author

Menachem Ani

Menachem Ani, Founder of JXT Group, is a digital advertising expert with over a decade of success developing high-impact marketing strategies for online retailers and lead-generation clients.

https://searchengineland.com/retail-performance-max-campaign-mistakes-391772




This day in search marketing history: January 17

Google Speed Update: New ranking algorithm designed for mobile search

In 2018, Google announced the “Speed Update” – a new ranking algorithm designed for mobile search – would go live later in the year.

The “Speed Update,” as we’re calling it, will only affect pages that deliver the slowest experience to users and will only affect a small percentage of queries. It applies the same standard to all pages, regardless of the technology used to build the page. The intent of the search query is still a very strong signal, so a slow page may still rank highly if it has great, relevant content.

Google’s Zhiheng Wang and Doantam Phan, Using page speed in mobile search ranking

In 2010, Google said page speed was a ranking factor only on desktop searches. Google promised to look at mobile page speed for years before this announcement.

Starting in July 2018, Google said it would be looking at how fast mobile pages are and use that as a ranking factor in mobile search.

Read all about it in: The Google Speed Update: Page speed will become a ranking factor in mobile search.

Google also answered several questions for Search Engine Land, which we published in: FAQs on new Google Speed Update: AMP pages, Search Console notifications & desktop only pages.


Also on this day 


Google Search Console launches desktop page experience report

2022: The report offered metrics, such as the percentage of URLs with good page experience and search impressions over time, to quickly evaluate performance and see what improvements were needed for specific pages.


OneSearch, Verizon Media’s new search engine, sounds awfully familiar

2020: DuckDuckGo, anyone? The new search engine would serve results powered by Bing and run contextual ads rather than behaviorally targeted ads that rely on cookies.


Updated study: Links are still incredibly important for ranking in Google

2019: The aggregate link data, using 27,000 queries, showed a strong correlation between links and ranking.


Bing Ads will serve all Yahoo search ads in new Microsoft-Verizon Media deal

2019: The extended partnership would make all Yahoo search inventory available through the Bing Ads platform. Bing Ads would continue to serve all AOL search inventory.


Google shares tips for success in Google News search results

2019: These 11 tips were largely established best practices – a good refresher, rather than new approaches.


Survey: Smart speaker ownership steals time from smartphones, TV, radio

2018: The study suggested there are about 40 million devices in US homes.


Survey: 60% of voice users want more answers and fewer search results

2017: Making calls, searching, texting and map lookups were the most common use cases for voice.


Google Issues Bad Ads Report: 59 Percent More Ads Pulled, But Fewer Bad Advertisers In 2013

2014: Google said it pulled more than 350 million bad ads from its systems.


AdWords Cross-Device Conversions: How 1-800-FLOWERS Is Using The Data To Be More Customer Centric

2014: 1-800-Flowers saw the overall conversion contribution from AdWords rise 7% when counting orders that started on one device and ended on another. 


Google Alerts Get A Shiny New Redesign

2014: The emails got a similarly clean look-and-feel to the card-style layout that had become prevalent in Google search results, Google Now, on Google’s mobile apps and elsewhere.


Search In Pics: Bing Hawks Towels, YouTube’s Emmy & Android Sugar Cubes

2014: The latest images culled from the web, showing what people eat at the search engine companies, how they play, who they meet, where they speak, what toys they have and more.


Bing Adds 5X More Facebook Content To Social Sidebar

2013: This included Facebook status updates, comments and shared links in addition to the Facebook content already present (Likes, photos, etc.).


Adobe: Paid Search Opportunities Lie In Tablet Targeting And PLAs

2013: Paid search as a whole had a good holiday season, Adobe found, with spend by online retailers up 16% year-over-year.


Ever Wanted To Be Siri? Apple Seeks A Writer

2013: The ideal candidate: someone who combined a love for language, wordplay, and conversation with demonstrated experience in bringing creative content to life within an intense technical environment.


“Who Sent Me Chocolates?” – Company Tries Sweet Twist To Tap Into Google Traffic

2013: They were not the first company to suggest you Google something to click on the first result. But they seemed to be the first to send out personalized messages in this fashion.


AdGroup-Level Impression Share Metrics Coming To AdWords

2012: Previously, impression share metrics were available only at the campaign level, which didn’t help when advertisers were trying to determine which particular ad group should be allocated more budget.


Google To Join Anti-SOPA “Blackout Day” With Home Page Protest

2012: While Google wouldn’t go dark, Google did link to anti-SOPA information on its homepage.


Yahoo’s Co-founder Jerry Yang Resigns

2012: Yang, who co-founded the company in March 1995, officially stepped down from its Board of Directors and all other positions with the company. 


Google Links To Competitors Next To YouTube Videos

2011: Google began showing links to different video sites and search engines in its search results. The links appeared next to YouTube videos, but only on music-related searches. 


Robbing Peter To Pay Paul: Report Says MSN Suffering For Focus On Bing

2011: Microsoft’s use of its popular portal MSN as a traffic driver for Bing was compromising some of MSN’s partner relationships, angering internal sales staff and even costing the company revenue.


Spanish Want Google To Police Libel On The Internet

2011: The Spanish data protection authority demanded that Google remove links to articles online (e.g., newspaper articles) that contain defamatory content.


Seznam.cz Disputes Google’s No. 1 Ranking In Czech Republic

2011: Seznam called the news “misleading” and said they were based on “a rather unobjective interpretation of Toplist statistics.”


Google’s Martin Luther King, Jr. Logo

2011: Google had a special Doodle on Google.com for Martin Luther King Jr. Day.


Yahoo & Microsoft Execs Meet Again

2009: Microsoft CEO Steve Ballmer met with Yahoo chairman Roy Bostock, restarting speculation about the on-again, off-again merger/deal talks.


Google’s Video Sites Gain Market Share

2008: Americans viewed nearly 9.5 billion online videos during the month and Google was the leading destination, with 3 billion videos viewed (31.3% share of all videos viewed), 2.9 billion of which were on YouTube (30.6%).


OpenID Gaining Critical Mass, Yahoo Announces Support

2008: Yahoo’s 248 million registered users became part of the Open ID system.


The Library of Congress Teams Up With Flickr

2008: The Flickr community was asked to tag photos to help users search for those pictures and give the Library of Congress a more complete and comprehensive method of organizing those photos.


Google.org To Announce Five Strategic Initiatives Today

2008: $25 million in new grants and investments to initial partners.


Truveo Creates New Election Videos Site

2008: It collected candidate videos as well as commentary and news footage.  


Q&A With Gabe Rivera, Creator Of Techmeme

2007: Gabe talked about the service, how it had grown, how it operates and future plans.


Linkbait Articles & Is It Linkbait Or Link Bait?

2007: A rundown on a few linkbait articles and the “to linkbait” or “to link bait” decision we had to make.


Google AdSense Updates Program Policies & Competitive Ads Policy

2007: Running anything in an ad unit that resembled the AdSense ad unit appearing anywhere on the same site became against the terms. 


Google Pushing Google Checkout More

2007: New Google Checkout customers got $10 from Google to spend at Google Checkout merchants.


Wired Looks At Yahoo Failures Over The Years

2007: From not buying Google, to Panama and more.


Are Lower Case Titles In Yahoo Coming From Anchor Text

2007: It was a bug. Yahoo fixed the issue about a week later.


Star Your Favorite Questions at Yahoo Answers

2007: Yahoo allowed users to vote for their favorite questions by adding a star next to interesting or high-quality questions.


Industry Moves: Peter Horan Goes To IAC

2007: Peter Horan was the About.com CEO until its acquisition by the New York Times. and then headed up small business portal AllBusiness.com


Mapshark: A Search Engine For Mashups

2007: It was built using Google’s Custom Search Engine to find interesting and useful mashups.


Boxxet Offers “Best Of” Collections On Popular Topics

2007: It combined aspects of computer automation with community and social commentary and ranking systems to create “box sets” of web-based content for specific topics.


Search Engine Land: Top Stories & Stats, Jan. 16, 2007

2007: A look at the top stories, along with tips, takeaways and suggestions.


From Search Marketing Expo (SMX)


Past contributions from Search Engine Land’s Subject Matter Experts (SMEs)

These columns are a snapshot in time and have not been updated since publishing, unless noted. Opinions expressed in these articles are those of the author and not necessarily Search Engine Land.


< January 16 | Search Marketing History | January 18 >


Related stories

New on Search Engine Land

@media screen and (min-width: 800px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:770px; min-height:260px; } } @media screen and (min-width: 1279px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:800px!important; min-height:440px!important; } }

About the author

Danny Goodwin

Danny Goodwin is Managing Editor of Search Engine Land & SMX. In addition to writing daily about SEO, PPC, and more for Search Engine Land, Goodwin also manages Search Engine Land’s roster of subject-matter experts. He also helps program our conference series, SMX – Search Marketing Expo. Prior to joining Search Engine Land, Goodwin was Executive Editor at Search Engine Journal, where he led editorial initiatives for the brand. He also was an editor at Search Engine Watch. He has spoken at many major search conferences and virtual events, and has been sourced for his expertise by a wide range of publications and podcasts.

https://searchengineland.com/search-marketing-history-january-17-391820




This day in search marketing history: January 16

Google explains crawl budget

In 2017, Google’s Gary Illyes explained what crawl budget is, how crawl rate limits work, what crawl demand is and what factors impact a site’s crawl budget.

As Illyes explained, most sites don’t need to worry about crawl budget.

“Prioritizing what to crawl, when, and how much resource the server hosting the site can allocate to crawling is more important for bigger sites, or those that auto-generate pages based on URL parameters,” Illyes said.

More from Illyes:

  • Crawl rate limit is designed to help Google not crawl your pages too much and too fast where it hurts your server.
  • Crawl demand is how much Google wants to crawl your pages. This is based on how popular your pages are and how stale the content is in the Google index.
  • Crawl budget is “taking crawl rate and crawl demand together.” Google defines crawl budget as “the number of URLs Googlebot can and wants to crawl.”

Read all about it in Google explains what “crawl budget” means for webmasters.


Also on this day 


Google Ads bug again for Gmail on desktop Safari browsers

2022: This impacted Google Ads that were served in Gmail for users accessing their email using the Safari desktop browser.


Google January 2020 core update almost done rolling out

2020: Google confirmed: “the update is mostly done…”


Google Search Console unparsable structured data report data issue

2020: Some users may have seen a spike in unparsable structured data errors due to an internal Google misconfiguration.


Google Search Console’s URL inspection tool adds HTTP response, page resources, JS logs and rendered screenshot

2019: The tool added the ability to see a specific URL’s HTTP response code, the page resources, the JavaScript logs and a rendered screenshot.


Bing Ads launches page feeds for easier Dynamic Search Ads management

2019: Page feeds eliminated the need to create targets for specific URLs or groups of URLs in DSA campaigns, making it easier to set up and manage.


Google ordered to submit search index to state sponsorship in Russia

2019: A law passed in 2018 mandated that search engine results be filtered through the federal state information system (FGIS).


Katy Jurado Google doodle marks 94th birthday of film star from the Golden Age of Mexican cinema

2018: Jurado was drawn in a powerful pose against a backdrop inspired by the film “High Noon.”


Google Image Search testing YouTube videos

2017: Google was embedding playable YouTube videos for certain queries.


Martin Luther King Jr. Day Google doodle promotes King’s message of unity

2017: The Doodle, by guest artist Keith Mallett, captured one of the major themes of King’s speeches and writing: “All life is interrelated.”


Google Still Doing At Least 1 Trillion Searches Per Year

2015: Google was sticking with the figure it gave in 2012 but stressed it’s “over” that amount. How much? Google wouldn’t say.


Google’s Knowledge Graph May Show For 25% Of All Search Queries

2015: The figure was important because it meant searchers often didn’t need to leave Google to visit a publisher’s site. 


2015 Oscar Nominations Now Showing In Google Knowledge Graph & Bing Carousel

2015: Searches for [Oscar nominee] and [Oscar nominations] on Google and Bing delivered results for the best picture candidates.


Local SEOs Sound Off On Google+ Local Hijackings

2014: Local SEOs and people familiar with Google+ Local theorized about on how this happened and shared suggestions o how to guard against future hijackings.


Bing: It’s A Myth That Keyword Rich Domain Names Improve Search Rankings

2014: The domain and keywords in that “domain send less and less” ranking signals to the overall Bing ranking algorithm.


RKG Report: PLAs Fuel AdWords Growth, Bing Ads Spend Rises Sharply In Q4

2014: Paid search spend among RKG’s retail-heavy client set rose 23 percent year-over-year. Overall click volume increased 19 percent, and CPCs ticked up just 3 percent.


Covario: Global PPC Click-Through Rates Hit New Highs, Spend Up 17 Percent YoY In Q4

2014: Based on results from their high tech, consumer electronics and retail clients, PPC spending increased 17% year-over-year and 13% over Q3 2013.


Google Now Cards Hit The Desktop For Mac, Windows and Chrome OS Users

2014: The Google Now cards ran through the latest Google Chrome build (Chrome Canary). Users had to be logged into Chrome.


Dian Fossey Commemorated With Google Logo To Mark The Famous Zoologist’s 82nd Birthday

2014: The logo included illustrations of the Silverback gorillas Fossey studied during her time in Rwanda, along with a picture of the Rwanda mountains where Fossey set camp for most of her 18 years with the gorillas.


Report: PLAs Drove 28% Of Google Non-Brand Ad Clicks In Q4

2013: The non-brand ROI for Google was 22% higher than that for Bing.


Play The Frank Zamboni Google Doodle

2013: The interactive Doodle allows searchers to play the Zamboni game by cleaning the ice after it is being used by children, hockey players and ice dancers.


How To Blackout Your Site (For SOPA/PIPA) Without Hurting SEO

2012: Google’s advice was to use a 503 HTTP status code to tell spiders that the website was temporarily unavilable.


Google Honors Martin Luther King Jr. Day With “I Have A Dream” Logo

2012: The Doodle included a couple lines from his famous speech.


Google Plans To Buy Its Way Into Real Estate

2010: Actually … Google’s goal was to acquire one to two companies a month. Not necessarily just small real estate companies.


Why Don’t Google & Yahoo Offer Twitter Search?

2009: if you want to find Twitter’s powerful, compelling material, you went to Twitter. Not to Yahoo. Not to Google, the king of search. 


Microsoft’s Early Mistakes & Missed Opportunities With Paid Search

2009: From bCentral Keywords, to not purchasing Overture, and its failed attempts to buy Yahoo.


Google Names Marchex First ‘Google AdWords Authorized Reseller Technology Platform’

2009: The purpose of this designation was to allow Google to recommend an approved technology partner to AdWords resellers if those partners didn’t have the requisite scalable technology.


Kogan ‘Indefinitely’ Delays Android Phone Launch

2009: Due to technology compatibility issues.


Search In Pictures: Googlers Dancing, Yahoo’s New CEO & Dinner Impossible At Yahoo

2009: The latest images culled from the web, showing what people eat at the search engine companies, how they play, who they meet, where they speak, what toys they have, and more.


December 2008: Search Engine Land’s Most Popular Stories

2009:  Search Engine Land’s 10 most popular stories from December 2008.


Google Writes Google Sitemaps FAQs

2008: Google responded to some of the most asked questions on the Sitemaps protocol and how Google supported it.


Google “Online Marketing Challenge” Has 724 College Teams Signed Up To Be Local SEMs

2008: When Google tried to turn college and business school students into search marketers.


Microsoft And EDGAR Online In Content, Ads Deal

2008: Microsoft became the exclusive third-party provider of display, contextual and video advertising for EDGAR Online and its global audience of more than 2 million unique visitors per month.


Yahoo’s Senior VP Of Entertainment Business Leaves

2008: Media executives at Yahoo were leaving one after another.


Hungry For Yahoo? Feed Yourself From Ya-Hoo! Baking Co.

2008: “not affiliated with Yahoo!, Inc. the search engine company.”


Google No Longer Linking To Yahoo, MapQuest Maps

2007: Previously, a search for an address would have yielded a choice among Google Maps, Yahoo and MapQuest.


comScore: Google Wins Again & IE7 Doesn’t Stop Microsoft’s Slide

2007: When Google had just a 47.3% search market share.


New Google Checkout Promo; New Google Trust Worries

2007: Google added the ability to filter product search results from merchants using Google Checkout – and promoted the new feature within its main search results.


Disclosing When Queries Are Autocorrected

2007: It seemed like Google had moved beyond suggesting spelling corrections to automatically doing them for you. 


MetaGlossary – Two Million Terms, Phrases And Acronyms

2007: It worked in a similar manner to the Google define: function, though it tended to be more comprehensive.


Wikiseek: Leveraging Wikipedia For Web Search, Poorly

2007: A look at the disappointing service along with a revisit to how it was different from Search Wikia.


Vizu Seeking To ‘Democratize’ Market Research

2007: It offered an interesting model, creating financial incentives for publishers to show polls on their sites and a relatively inexpensive way for marketers to get quick user data.


comScore: Email Top Reason For Mobile Internet Access

2007: “33% strongly agree they ‘feel lost’ without their cell phone.”


Past contributions from Search Engine Land’s Subject Matter Experts (SMEs)

These columns are a snapshot in time and have not been updated since publishing, unless noted. Opinions expressed in these articles are those of the author and not necessarily Search Engine Land.


< January 15 | Search Marketing History | January 17 >


Related stories

New on Search Engine Land

@media screen and (min-width: 800px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:770px; min-height:260px; } } @media screen and (min-width: 1279px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:800px!important; min-height:440px!important; } }

About the author

Danny Goodwin

Danny Goodwin is Managing Editor of Search Engine Land & SMX. In addition to writing daily about SEO, PPC, and more for Search Engine Land, Goodwin also manages Search Engine Land’s roster of subject-matter experts. He also helps program our conference series, SMX – Search Marketing Expo. Prior to joining Search Engine Land, Goodwin was Executive Editor at Search Engine Journal, where he led editorial initiatives for the brand. He also was an editor at Search Engine Watch. He has spoken at many major search conferences and virtual events, and has been sourced for his expertise by a wide range of publications and podcasts.

https://searchengineland.com/search-marketing-history-january-16-391814




This day in search marketing history: January 15

Facebook Graph Search arrives

In 2013, Facebook announced a new experience that it called Graph Search.

Facebook Graph Search relied heavily on Likes and other connections to determine what to show as the most relevant search results for each user.

At launch, Facebook Graph Search only included people, photos, places and interests.

Facebook Graph Search wasn’t a traditional web search engine like Google or Bing. It was a new type of search – a social search engine. Although Facebook was already using Bing for web search results at that time.

Dig deeper:

Less than two years later, Facebook quietly dropped Bing’s results and Facebook made Graph Search less visible. Graph Search would be all but dead by around June 7, 2019. According to a Facebook spokesperson:

“The vast majority of people on Facebook search using keywords, a factor which led us to pause some aspects of graph search and focus more on improving keyword search. We are working closely with researchers to make sure they have the tools they need to use our platform.”

– Joseph Cox, VICE, “Facebook Quietly Changes Search Tool Used by Investigators, Abused By Companies“


Also on this day 


LinkedIn launches LinkedIn Marketing Labs on-demand courses for advertisers

2021: The courses cover the basics including an introduction to LinkedIn Ads, how to use LinkedIn ad targeting, and reporting and analytics for LinkedIn ads.


Amazon Sponsored Products ads now support dynamic bidding, bid adjustments

2019: Advertisers could opt into automated bidding and tailor bids for the search ads by page placement.


EU copyright directive nearing final form as Google tests stripped-down news SERPs

2019: The directive sought to “harmonize” copyright law across Europe.


DuckDuckGo map and address searches now powered by Apple Maps

2019: The company had been using OpenStreetMap.


Google to fix reverse image search bug

2018: “Pages that include matching images” section was not showing image thumbnails as it should.


Martin Luther King Jr. Day 2018 Google doodle honors Dr. King & his dream for a better world

2018: The image was designed by guest artist Cannaday Chapman and created in collaboration with the Black Googlers Network.


Google Tests “What’s Hot” & “What’s Nearby” As Android Search Options

2016: In addition to recent searches, Google inserted a “What’s Hot” and “Nearby” option in the pull-down menu.


Search In Pics: Justin Trudeau At New Google Canadian Office, Google Expeditions Subaru & Fallout 4 Statue

2016: The latest images culled from the web, showing what people eat at the search engine companies, how they play, who they meet, where they speak, what toys they have and more. 


Google Knowledge Graph Now Showing Social Profiles For Brands

Google began showing the social profile links for Pixar, Apple, Starbucks, Google and many more brands.


Search Is Number One Content Discovery Tool For Mobile Users

2015: Fifty four percent of respondents said search was the top way they found mobile content/websites


Smartphones Account For 40% Of US Search Ad Spend In Q4 [Marin]

2015: Desktop’s influence, while still dominant, continued to wane


Google Updates Its Structured Data Testing Tool, Documentation & Syntax Support

2015: Google had a new and improved Structured Data Testing tool, updated its documentation and guidelines, while adding more markup support.


Ability To Share Ads Via AdWords Shared Library Is Going Away

2015: The feature would be eliminated on Feb. 11.


Google Wants Webmaster Feedback On Web Search & Webmaster Tools

2015: Google asked: “What would you like to see from Google Websearch & Webmaster Tools in 2015?”


Google Events Knowledge Graph Adds Ticket Links, Delegated Events, Comedian Events & Venue Events

2015: Google made four updates to the events knowledge graph, after launching the markup back in March 2014.


Google Updates Maps App Adding Restaurant Filters & More

2015: Google Maps App added cuisine type filters and more features for iOS and Android users.


Google’s Matt Cutts: We Don’t Have Different Algorithms For Different Web Position Slots

2014: Google’s Matt Cutts answered this question: “Are results in different positions ranked by different algorithms?” Spoiler alert: The answer was no.


Rand Fishkin Steps Down As The CEO Of Moz, Sarah Bird New CEO

2014: The end of an era – this was Fishkin’s final day as CEO of Moz.


Report: Search Engines Responsible For 40% Of Holiday Traffic To Retailer Websites

2014: While still representing the largest share, Experian reported search engines experienced a 13% drop in the amount of upstream traffic sent to retailers when comparing year-over-year traffic data.


Bing Ends 2013 With All-Time High In US Market Share, But Google Also Up [comScore]

2014: Google’s share of search queries was up 0.6 percent in December 2013, to 67.3 percent


EU Wants More Search Concessions, Google Defies French Authority

2014: EU Competition Commissioner Joaquin Almunia said Google needed to deliver additional, revised proposals within weeks to avoid a formal antitrust proceeding.


Is Lowe’s The First Brand To Adopt Jelly?

2014: What we do know: they answered at least one question about how to mount art on a brick wall.


Links From Press Releases Do Have Ranking Benefit Despite What Google Says

2013: That time when Matt Cutts blog started ranking for [sreppleasers] in Google.


Report: Global Paid Search Spending Up 18% In 2012

2013: That growth trend was down just slightly from the 21% annual increase reported for 2011.


77% Of Online Health Seekers Start At Search Engines [Pew Study]

2013: That was significantly more than the 13% who began at health portals like WebMD, general information sites like Wikipedia (only 2%) and social networks (1%).


Google’s 6th “Doodle 4 Google” Contest: “My Best Day Ever…”

2013: The winner would earn a $30,000 college scholarship, a $50,000 technology grant for their school, and have his or her logo displayed on the Google homepage.


Yext “Reinvents The Local Business Listing” With New Rich Content Options

2013: And they called it … PowerListings+.


89% Find Search Engines Do Good Job Finding Information, But “Noise” Is Issue

2011: 13% said they couldn’t find what they were looking for. The answers were there, the “signal” that people want to tune into. They were just surrounded by a lot of noise.


comScore: Bing Share Up – Will It Overtake Yahoo? Plus, Ask.com Sale Speculation Returns

2010: ComScore’s search share figures from December 2009: Yahoo, 17.3%, Bing, 10.7%. (Google? It was at 65.7%.)


Amazon Slaps UK Affiliates Using Search Marketing Techniques

2010: Amazon said it would no longer pay referral fees to Associates who sent users via keyword bidding or other paid search on any other search engine or their extended search networks


OneRiot Launches RiotWise Ad Network For Real-Time Search

2010: The launch followed a pilot phase that the company said allowed developers to monetize mobile apps, desktop clients, social search engines and similar applications.


Carol Bartz’s ‘Gut’ May Stop Yahoo Search Sale To Microsoft

2009: Bartz said her instinct or “gut” was not necessarily to sell, although she would need to immerse herself in the issues and economics to make a better determination.


Microsoft Job Cuts May Come Next Week

2009: The cuts were expected to be “far less than the 15,000 positions” first thought.


Yahoo Shows Wikipedia Some SearchMonkey Love

2009: The Wikipedia SearchMonkey App was turned on by default for all Yahoo search users, which made it the sixth app that all Yahoo searchers would see (with LinkedIn, Yelp, Yahoo Local, Citysearch and Zagat).


TweetNews: Yahoo Programmer Melds News Search & Twitter

2009: TweetNews was a new search engine that used hot Twitter topics to bring more relevance and freshness to news search.


Google Directory Update Showing “Real” PR Scores?

2008: Google Directory scores were much higher than those shown on the Google Toolbar.


Microsoft And MediaCart Bring Ad Targeting To Grocery Store Shopping Carts

2008: Microsoft teamed up with MediaCart to offer in-store behavioral ad targeting and took the concept of “location-based services” to the store aisles using RFID tags.


Google Maps Being Used To Engage Political Volunteers, Activists

2008: How candidates, campaign staffers and other third parties were using Google Maps and the Maps API to showcase their messages and organize political volunteers and activists in upcoming primaries.


Wireless Spectrum Bidders Approved, Auction Begins January 24

2008: Among the bidders: Google, AT&T, Verizon and MetroPCS. 


Study Says Get In Top 5 Not Top 10 & Search Engines May Need To Highlight Official Sites

2007: Among the findings: search marketers needed to be more concerned about getting into the top five rather than the top ten, if they wanted to be seen.


More Spotting Google’s Related Searches At Bottom Of Page

2007: More searchers were seeing a series of eight suggested searches as links, under the heading of “Searches related to:” followed by the original word you searched for.


Looking At Microsoft’s Continued Long Game In Search

2007: “It’s tiring to hear the Microsoft leadership just rip at Google rather than deliver successes that speak for themselves.”


Microsoft Live & Yahoo Push For Firefox Users, Plus Revisiting The IE7 Search Battle

2007: How the various search engines were trying to get users to make them their default choice.


SEO Blogs Under Hack Attack

2007: Graywolf’s blog was hacked, then Stuntdubl went down.


Hacking Google To Help It Improve Security

2007: “It’s your worst nightmare – someone reads parts of your Google emails, views your docs, modifies your spreadsheets, checks out your reading habits on the Google personalized homepage or Google Reader, and goes through your search history.”


Googlers Give Overwhelmingly To Democrats; Google’s PAC Gave More To Republicans

2007: While 98% of Google employee money went to Democrats in the last election, the company-controlled Google NetPAC gave 61% of its contributions to conservative candidates. 


From Search Marketing Expo (SMX)


Past contributions from Search Engine Land’s Subject Matter Experts (SMEs)

These columns are a snapshot in time and have not been updated since publishing, unless noted. Opinions expressed in these articles are those of the author and not necessarily Search Engine Land.


< January 14 | Search Marketing History | January 16 >


Related stories

New on Search Engine Land

@media screen and (min-width: 800px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:770px; min-height:260px; } } @media screen and (min-width: 1279px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:800px!important; min-height:440px!important; } }

About the author

Danny Goodwin

Danny Goodwin is Managing Editor of Search Engine Land & SMX. In addition to writing daily about SEO, PPC, and more for Search Engine Land, Goodwin also manages Search Engine Land’s roster of subject-matter experts. He also helps program our conference series, SMX – Search Marketing Expo. Prior to joining Search Engine Land, Goodwin was Executive Editor at Search Engine Journal, where he led editorial initiatives for the brand. He also was an editor at Search Engine Watch. He has spoken at many major search conferences and virtual events, and has been sourced for his expertise by a wide range of publications and podcasts.

https://searchengineland.com/search-marketing-history-january-15-391804




This day in search marketing history: January 14

R.I.P. AMP

In 2022, we revealed what happened when Search Engine Land shut off AMP.

TL;DR: “We have seen very little disruption to our traffic and have reaped the benefit of having a clearer picture of our audience analytics.”

We didn’t see any year-over-year declines in traffic that we could tie to AMP aside from the loss of pageviews to a handful of pieces that routinely spike for organic traffic.

Why did Search Engine Land shut off AMP? As we explained in We’re turning off AMP pages at Search Engine Land, it was due to competition in Top Stories (after AMP was no longer required for inclusion in Top Stories) and waning support by social media platforms.

Read all about it in What happened when we turned off AMP.


Also on this day


Shopify chat bug leads to titles with (1) in Google’s search results

2022: It was a widespread issue, not a Google bug, related to a chat feature in Shopify that had this unintended consequence in search.


Google Ads enables bid simulator for Target ROAS, budget simulator for Maximize clicks, conversions

2020: You could see the projected impact of making bid or budget changes in your campaigns that used these smart bidding strategies.


Google buys Pointy to bring SMB store inventory online

2020: Pointy had solved a problem that vexed startups for more than a decade: how to bring small, independent retailer inventory online.


Nofollow couldn’t save the Google webmaster blog from comment spam

2019: Google removed the ability to leave comments on Google Webmaster blog because “most of the time they were off-topic or even outright spammy.”


How Google’s Search Chief Has Been Living The “Mobile First” Life For Over A Year

2016: Amit Singhal, Google’s senior vice president of search, did almost all of his searches for more than a year on mobile devices.


Bing Ads Updates Keyword Planner With Impression Share Comparisons And More

2016: The new features: more competitive insights and benchmarking, customizable ad group and keyword bids, a new source for keyword suggestions and time range customization up to 24 months for keyword search volume.


Bing Updates Its Logo With Uppercase “B” & New Teal Blue Color

2016: “It felt like the right time to freshen things up,” said Microsoft spokesperson.


Google Street View Goes “Miniatur” To Capture Hamburg Model Train Exhibit

2016: Google documented the attraction with tiny Street View cars as though it were a real place.


Google News Now Will Crawl & Index Images Hosted Off Your Domain Name

2015: In the past, if your images were hosted off your website’s domain, it was very unlikely Google would crawl them for Google News.


Q4 Paid Search Ad Revenue Up 24 Percent YoY In The Americas [Kenshoo]

2015: Return on investment rose as revenue outpaced the rise in spending.


Google History Added A Section For Your Google Now Cards

2015: You could track, over time, what Google Now Cards Google showed you each day.


Google Translate App Gets Improved Picture & Conversational Translation

2015: The update brought both camera and conversation mode translation to the iOS app for the first time, as well as vast improvements to those features on the Android version of the app.


Google Opens A Visitor Center

2015: Historically, Google had never allowed for random people to come and visit or tour the offices.


Thousands Of Hotel Listings Were Hijacked In Google+ Local

2014: Thousands of hotels listed within Google+ Local appeared to have had links leading to their official sites “hijacked” and replaced with ones leading to third-party booking services.


Google Image Search Adds Usage Rights To Search Tools

2014: The feature wasn’t new. You just no longer had to dig into the “advanced image search” features to get them.


Two Videos Of What It Would Be Like If Google Was A Real Living Person

2014: Two video parodies make fun of what a Google would be if it was a real guy.


Yelp Turns Up The Heat: 285 Consumer Alerts Issued Over Fake Reviews

2014: A pop-up alert appeared on a Yelp business profile page and warned consumers that a Yelp sting operation had caught the company trying to acquire reviews by buying them, offering gifts or discounts, or some other way that Yelp doesn’t allow.


Wayback Machine Now Has 240 Billion URLs

2013: Prior to this update, The Wayback Machine provided access to about 150 billion URLs.


Welcome AJ Kohn & Ginny Marvin To Search Engine Land, Marketing Land

2013: Kohn joined us as our Special Projects Correspondent. Marvin joined as a Contributing Writer, focusing primarily on paid advertising topics (she would go on to become Editor-in-Chief from October 2018 to December 2020).


DuckDuckGo Relaunches With New Visual Design

2012: Founder Gabriel Weinberg has been taking feedback and tweaking the design for at least three-plus weeks in the site’s community forum, where he announced the new look and layout.


Google’s John Hanke Speaks About New Mobile Incubator

2011: After six years at the helm of Google Maps, Hanke said he was “restless” and was a bit tired of running a large organization.


Google, Bing Up While AOL Hits All-Time Low: comScore December Search Data

2011: Google hit 66.6% – a record high for Google in comScore’s numbers – while AOL hit a historic low of 1.9%.


More See Horizontal Look For Top Three Google Ads

2011: In the new format, the headline was combined with the first description line, or the two description lines were combined.


South Korean Police File Criminal Charges Over Google’s WiFi Data Gathering

2011: Police examined the data that Google collected between October 2009 and May 2010 and determined that it broke two South Korean laws.


Bing Set To Advertise During Golden Globe Awards

2011: Both ads played on the Bing “decision engine” idea by having aspiring actors explain why they decided to get into acting, followed by a message that “pre-congratulates the Golden Globe winners of tomorrow.”


Yahoo’s Irving: “Hell Yes” Yahoo Is Committed To Flickr

2011: “Q. Is Yahoo! committed to Flickr? A. Hell yes we are! We love this product and team; on strategy and profitable.”


Google Search Suggestions For Mobile Get Locally Relevant

2010: Query suggestions varied based on user location.


Experian Hitwise: Google Passes 72% U.S. Market Share

2010: Yahoo, Bing, and Ask.com all saw their search share drop from November to December.


100 Day Reminder: AdWords API v13 Sunsetting

2010: Another warning.


Google Integrates “Real-Time” Messages Into Place Pages, Makes BlackBerry Mobile App More Useful

2010: Businesses could use their Place Pages to promote time-sensitive (real-time) events – as long as they could find the feature.


Shashi Seth Now At Yahoo From AOL, Cooliris & Google

2010: As the new Senior Vice President of the Yahoo Search Products team, Seth would manage Yahoo’s Search team and all things related to Yahoo Search.


Chinese Gov’t Offers Bland Statement On Google, Google.cn Employees Given Indefinite Holiday

2010: China’s government suggested it likely wasn’t going to allow Google to operate unfiltered or negotiate with the search engine.


Yahoo Adds Network Distribution & Improved Importing To Search Ads

2010: Network Distribution allowed advertisers to select if they wanted to advertise on Yahoo’s entire network or just on either the Yahoo Search network or Yahoo Search Partner network.


Where Have All The Old Tweets Gone?

2010: The massive number of new tweets coming in was to blame. The search index behind Twitter Search couldn’t hold it all.


After The Hack, Should I Still Trust Google & The Cloud With My Data?

2010: Would the entire GoogleHack episode develop into a major reversal for the growth of cloud computing? (Spoiler alert: No.)


Google Pledges $1 Million To Haiti Relief Efforts, Bing & Yahoo Add Donation Info

2010: The major search engines responded by linking information about disaster relief efforts from their homepages.


Google Local Business Ads Score New Features

2009: New links appeared at the bottom of the ad’s info window: Get Directions, Street View, and/or Save to My Maps.


Google Creates Smart Sitemap Generator Tool

2009: It used web traffic, log files and other methods to find new or modified URLs. 


Google Ends Google Video Uploads, Shutters Notebook, Catalog Search, Dodgeball & Jaiku

2009: Google ceased developing a variety of products as part of a continuing move to keep efforts focused on products with greater usage


Google Apps Authorized Reseller Program

2009: The program was aimed at developers, hosting companies and others to take on the responsibility of billing, support and training, in exchange for a 20% discount on the services.


Adobe & Yahoo Discontinue PDF Contextual Ad Program

2009: Blame the failure on the economic conditions.


Consumer Groups Trying To Preempt Behavioral Targeting For Mobile Ads

2009: A complaint sought to preempt the development of behavioral targeting and profiling in mobile advertising.


Harvard Prof: Deceptive Ads ‘Widespread’ On Yahoo’s Right Media

2009: The ads were either are false or failed to make legally required disclosures.


Yahoo Shuts Down Content Match In UK

2009: Yahoo matched the advertiser’s ads by the contextual relevancy of the page’s content to the keywords the advertisers purchased.


Google Cuts 100 Recruiters; May Replace Up To 70 Engineers Due To Office Closures

2009: Google implied the cuts would be due to the engineers not being willing or able to relocate to Google’s Mountain View headquarters.


An Apology To Wired & The Search Marketing Community

2008: The article generated some serious spam issues for Wired, generated discord within the search marketing community, and injured the search marketing industry in general.


Google Loves The iPhone, But Google’s Eric Schmidt Won’t “Talk” About It

2008: Google CEO Eric Schmidt was a member of the Apple board and was on stage for the iPhone’s introduction.


Liberty Media Corporation Bought 14 Million Shares In IAC

2008: The 14 million shares came out to about $339.5 million, but gave Liberty Media Corporation about a 30 percent stake in the parent company of Ask.com.


IncrediMail Gets Crushed Financially By Google AdSense Ban

2008: The ban seemed to have caused their stock price to drop 45% in one day.


Professor Bans Google & Wikipedia In Class Room

2008: University of Brighton professor said using Google and Wikipedia doesn’t encourage students to use their “own brains” enough


From Search Marketing Expo (SMX)


Past contributions from Search Engine Land’s Subject Matter Experts (SMEs)

These columns are a snapshot in time and have not been updated since publishing, unless noted. Opinions expressed in these articles are those of the author and not necessarily Search Engine Land.


< January 13 | Search Marketing History | January 15 >


Related stories

New on Search Engine Land

@media screen and (min-width: 800px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:770px; min-height:260px; } } @media screen and (min-width: 1279px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:800px!important; min-height:440px!important; } }

About the author

Danny Goodwin

Danny Goodwin is Managing Editor of Search Engine Land & SMX. In addition to writing daily about SEO, PPC, and more for Search Engine Land, Goodwin also manages Search Engine Land’s roster of subject-matter experts. He also helps program our conference series, SMX – Search Marketing Expo. Prior to joining Search Engine Land, Goodwin was Executive Editor at Search Engine Journal, where he led editorial initiatives for the brand. He also was an editor at Search Engine Watch. He has spoken at many major search conferences and virtual events, and has been sourced for his expertise by a wide range of publications and podcasts.

https://searchengineland.com/search-marketing-history-january-14-391800




3 core skills that will help advance your SEM career

There are three essential skills you need to develop to progress your SEM career. These critical skills apply to almost any industry, but we will make a specific case for roles within SEM: 

  • Clear communication
  • Effective collaboration
  • Focused productivity

Clear communication 

Do not underestimate clear, concise communication. Communication is at the core of any role within a company or agency. 

Every day you are sharing information across teams, clients, and vendors. Individuals who are thoughtful and purposeful with their communication style will benefit from a unique voice and confidence. 

As a result, these individuals will have a more significant impact on their organization. 

Communicate effectively in every medium

Conveying ideas comes in many forms – email, virtual and in-person meetings, presentations, instant messaging, and countless others. Conversations in instant messaging apps move quickly, which can cause errors and misunderstandings.

Often, instant messaging via Slack or Teams is informal and conversational. Still, it’s important to be professional when collaborating with team members, managing projects and delegating tasks on such platforms. Take the time to be thoughtful even during micro-discussions like chats. 

Specific channels, like email or deck presentations, allow more time to be purposeful with your communication. In many instances, email is a method of transferring ownership of a given topic.

For example, someone could be asking a question (you own the answer), requesting data or reporting (you own the data), or sending a task (you own the task completion).

Always confirm receipt and establish a timeline for a response and follow these quick tips:

  • Make sure your message is clear and concise.
  • Adapt your message for different media.
  • Use proper language for the medium.
  • Use active listening techniques.
  • Proofread your messages.

Run and attend successful meetings

Meetings are the bane of many professional existences. Poorly run meetings waste time, drain energy and provide little value.

Moreover, meetings occupy more time for many unfortunate souls than completing actual work. Break this cycle of meeting fatigue as much as possible.

Meeting agendas are your secret weapon. A great agenda will set the stage for a highly successful meeting. They set the tone and expectations. Meeting agendas allow attendees time to prepare for specific topics. Also, you should request an agenda that you are attending. 

Agendas set the stage for a successful meeting, and clear meeting notes ensure the meeting has the desired impact. Meetings that do not result in delegated tasks or new collaboration could have been an email.

You need to be the person who sets excellent agendas and provides thorough notes and task ownership afterward. For successful meetings, be sure to follow these steps: 

  • Set a great agenda.
  • Invite the right people.
  • Start on time.
  • Be organized.
  • Encourage participation.
  • Take thorough notes.
  • End on time.
  • Follow up.

Set agendas for 1:1 manager meetings 

Be aware of one of your most important regularly scheduled meetings. You should have weekly meetings with your manager.

These weekly sessions are your chance to discuss challenges, opportunities, and long-term goals. Remember, you should not rely on your manager to set the meeting agenda. 

Individuals in more junior positions may feel they can not dictate topics to their manager. That is not true. Be proactive about your development. 

Be sure to follow these tips for great 1:1 manager meetings: 

  • Set clear expectations.
  • Ask the right questions.
  • Listen carefully.
  • Follow up on any takeaways.
  • Encourage open communication.

Get the daily newsletter search marketers rely on.


Effective collaboration 

Success is not achieved alone. No matter where you work, you are a member of a team. You need to make sure that you are a supportive, collaborative team member. 

Build a support network with your company. This support network should be an outlet to brainstorm ideas, provide feedback, and help with tasks. 

Master the art of delegation and task management

One of the core tenants of collaboration is delegation. Delegation goes both ways. It would be best if you mastered the art of assigning tasks to people on your team. Also, it would be best if you mastered the ability to have tasks assigned to you.  

Identify the skills and tasks you are best at and those that are a struggle. Understanding your strengths and weaknesses will help you decide which SEM tasks to delegate and which to handle yourself.

Create a list of all the tasks that need to be completed and assign them to the appropriate people. Make sure to include deadlines and any other necessary details.

Next, prioritize tasks based on their importance and urgency. This prioritization will help you identify which tasks should be delegated and which you should handle.

Make sure to provide clear instructions and provide the necessary support to ensure that tasks are completed on time. Monitor progress on tasks to ensure that they are being conducted on time. Use regular check-ins or progress reports to stay up-to-date on the status of tasks.

Here is a quick checklist for task delegation:  

  • Understand your strengths and weaknesses.
  • Create a prioritized task list.
  • Set clear deadlines.
  • Provide clear instructions.
  • Monitor progress closely.

Build a support network within your company

You can build a support network in companies large and small. But first, take the time to personally get to know your team members.

Ask them about their interests and hobbies. Create an open environment where everyone feels comfortable sharing their perspectives.

This strategy is powerful when you get to know team members in other departments. 

Show every team member that you appreciate their work. Send thank-you notes when folks go above and beyond to help solve a problem. Also, be open to solving problems for other team members. From an SEM perspective, you should build strong bonds with your analytics, creative, and operational teams. 

Here is a quick checklist to build a support network: 

  • Get to know your team.
  • Show appreciation.
  • Provide resources and tools.
  • Celebrate achievements.

Always look for new ways to help your team

Make yourself available to team members when they have questions or need guidance. You can do this by:

  • Being active in team meetings.
  • Responding to emails promptly.
  • Being willing to provide advice or assistance.

Even if you are a junior or senior on your team, you can make yourself available to help solve problems within your skillset. There are always dozens of small tasks that need to be completed within SEM teams so dive into those small tasks.

Being a helpful resource for your team is a winning strategy, but you must protect your bandwidth to avoid burnout. Here is a quick checklist to be a resource for your team: 

  • Encourage team collaboration.
  • Offer help and support to folks inside and outside your team.
  • Share your knowledge and experience when possible.

Focused productivity 

Managing SEM campaigns is complex, and there is never a shortage of tasks.

Focused productivity means being purposeful with your time and energy. You will learn early in your career that no one will manage your time. 

To progress your SEM career, manage your daily workload while building toward your long-term goals. 

Be relentless about prioritization and project management 

There are tasks when managing SEM accounts that will take priority over others. Determine the objectives and scope of each project and task. Set realistic expectations for success. Establishing clear goals will help you determine priorities and allocate resources. 

Monitor the progress of your projects and adjust resources as needed. Regular updates and feedback will help ensure the project is progressing.

In addition, regularly communicate with stakeholders, team members, and other stakeholders to ensure everyone is on the same page.

A theme throughout this article is ownership. Take ownership to advance your SEM career. Own your project and task management. Stay on top of your task list, so your manager doesn’t have to follow up. 

Here is a short list of how to prioritize tasks and projects: 

  • Establish clear goals.
  • Create a project plan.
  • Assign responsibilities.
  • Track progress.
  • Communicate regularly.

Build a system to achieve your quarterly goals 

More than likely, your manager will set quarterly goals for you. However, you can contribute to this process and provide your unique insights.

Take ownership of your development and career trajectory. Your manager will appreciate your proactive approach to setting goals and thinking about long-term growth.  

There is no shortage of content to help build actionable long-term goals. If you do a few quick searches, you will discover a litany of resources to help with this process.

One high-level to take away right now is setting “SMARTER” goals. 

  • S: Specific 
  • M: Measurable 
  • A: Actionable 
  • R: Risky 
  • T: Time-keyed 
  • E: Exciting 
  • R: Relevant 

Approach your manager with structured SMARTER goals, and you’ll be ahead of the game. Your manager will likely have other ideas for your goals and milestones, but this process shows that you are thinking about long-term development. 

Here is a quick list of ways to set great long-term goals: 

  • Set up a goal-tracking system.
  • Establish specific timelines for your goals.
  • Create progress milestones for each goal.
  • Celebrate success as you make progress.
  • Stay focused and review your goals at least monthly. 

Focus on energy flow and take breaks

This strategy should be discussed more when discussing career progression. To progress in your SEM career, you must be mindful of your working patterns.

There are times of the day when you are more focused on detailed work like analyzing reports or building SEM campaigns. Take time to review your daily schedule and make sure it aligns with your best working patterns. 

Meetings are a reality of working life. You can not get around. There will be meetings with clients, internal stakeholders, team syncs, and countless others who can control your schedule.

Do your best to create meeting blocks. For example, if you have three meetings in a day, schedule them back-to-back. 

Meeting blocks allows you to create a workflow. You need a certain amount of time each day for focus time. Focus time is crucial for SEM campaign managers.

Take ownership of your daily calendar to allow for focus time, workflow management, and meeting blocks, and you will be astonished at how much this improves your day. 

How to facilitate positive workflow habits: 

  • Allot daily focus time on your calendar 
  • Schedule meetings in blocks as much as possible 
  • Add breaks onto your calendar to protect your restorative time 
  • Create a daily plan every morning to lay out your day 

This closes out our SEM career playbook series, which aims to advance your career in search engine marketing. Here are links to our previous installments:


Opinions expressed in this article are those of the guest author and not necessarily Search Engine Land. Staff authors are listed here.


Related stories

New on Search Engine Land

@media screen and (min-width: 800px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:770px; min-height:260px; } } @media screen and (min-width: 1279px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:800px!important; min-height:440px!important; } }

About the author

Joseph Kerschbaum

Joseph Kerschbaum is Senior Vice President of Search & Growth Labs for 3Q/DEPT. During his 20 years of experience in digital marketing, Joseph has worked with businesses of every size from SMBs to enterprise-scale. Joseph has been a regular speaker at digital marketing conferences for over a decade. Joseph is a regular contributor to Search Engine Land. He is co-author of the Wiley/Sybex book, “Pay-Per-Click SEM: One Hour a Day,” which was published long enough ago to be outdated but that is a good thing because SEM is such a dynamic industry.

https://searchengineland.com/core-skills-advance-sem-career-391198




This day in search marketing history: January 13

Matt Cutts educates Washington, DC about Google

In 2011, Matt Cutts, the head of Google’s search spam team, was in Washington DC, doing an “educational tour” to explain to US Federal Trade Commission members and congressional staffers that Google’s search results didn’t require government regulation.

Part of his visit included a 89-page slide presentation, called “Search Integrity,” at Google’s Washington, D.C. offices.

Cutts said the same thing that Google had been telling the search marketing community for years – that Google’s results are determined by an algorithm and not tweaked to get particular sites ranking well.

“The only reasons I know of to go in and change [search rankings] manually is for security, a court order or spam. It is impossible to pay for a better ranking.”

Matt Cutts, as quoted in The Washington Post

Read all about it in Mr. Cutts Goes To Washington, Testifies Google Has Integrity.


Also on this day 


IndexNow now officially co-sharing URLs between Microsoft Bing and Yandex

2022: If you used IndexNow to submit URLs to Microsoft Bing, Microsoft would immediately share those URLs with Yandex.


DuckDuckGo passes 100 billion searches

2022: The privacy focused search engine announced it had surpassed 100 billion all time searches.


Google pauses all political ads through inauguration

2021: Ads mentioning politics, impeachment, the inauguration, and the insurrection at the US Capitol were all being halted.


Google January 2020 Core Update rolling out later today

2020: Google announced it was releasing a broad core algorithm update called the January 2020 Core Update.


Google Rich Results testing tool now reports on unloadable embedded resources

2020: The tool could now report unloadable embedded resources, such as external elements included by a page.


Google’s ‘My Business Provider’ program replaces ‘Trusted Verifier’ for GMB outreach

2020: Agencies, SEOs, and resellers were not eligible for this program. And the proposed MBP “must not have access to the business listings they are verifying.”


Google rolling out desktop search redesign with black “Ad” label, favicons for organic results

2020: After several months of being live in the Google mobile results, Google launched the new design on desktop.


Responsive search ads available globally in all Microsoft Advertising interfaces

2020: Microsoft recommended running up to five ads per ad group, including at least one RSA.


Video: William Álvarez on the importance of structured data and Google search

2020: In this installment of Barry Schwartz’s vlog series, he chats with Álvarez about why structured data will be important in the future and his passion for mentoring SEOs.


Zhou Youguang Google doodle honors Chinese linguist known as the ‘Father of Pinyin’

2018: The animated doodle highlighted Youguang’s work by flipping the Os within Google’s name from Pinyin (Gǔgē) to Chinese characters (谷歌) and led to a search for “Zhou Youguang.”


Search in Pics: Google Bollywood car, orange tree & indoor bike parking

2017: The latest images culled from the web, showing what people eat at the search engine companies, how they play, who they meet, where they speak, what toys they have and more.


SEOs Confused, Puzzled After Google’s Mystery Update

2016: A summary of some of the questions, answers and additional confusion around the most recent Google core algorithm update and Panda becoming part of Google’s core ranking signals.


Bing Adds An Internet Speed Test Tool To The Search Results

2016: Some users were seeing the new feature on Bing when searching for [speed test] or [internet speed test]. 


Google Maps For Android Gets “Driver Mode” Feature To Anticipate Your Next Stop

2016: The new feature would anticipate where a user wanted to go and advise how best to get there.


Bing Predicts Launches AreWeIn.net For NCAA March Madness Basketball Fans

2018: The site offered daily analysis of NCAA basketball teams, predicting whether they would make the tournament and how they would finish. 


LinkedIn Gives Search A Promotion By Adding Better Post Results & Richer, Personalized Listings

2015: LinkedIn’s new customized search functionality was designed to help you find people, jobs or posts faster.


Ryanair CEO Claims Airline Is Working With Google On A Flight Search & Comparison Tool

2014: Ryanair CEO Michael O’Leary said his airline has entered a partnership with Google, and was providing the search engine with flight pricing to help build a travel search and comparison tool.


Bing Begins Supporting Separately SSL Search Site; No Referrers Pass

2014: If you conducted a search on Bing, while on the HTTPS URL, it would remain HTTPS and keep your searches secure.


Google: Ability To Block Sites From Search Results Will Return, But When?

2012: The ability to block web sites from search results disappeared when Google’s Search Plus personalized results format launched.


Q4 Reports: Search Advertising Growing In Efficiency

2012: Four reports all pointed to an overwhelmingly successful fourth quarter in 2011 for major search advertisers in a number of verticals.


Search Alliance Begins First AdCenter Testing In Europe

2012: The first testing for the roll-out was to commence mid-January and involve up to 10% of Yahoo’s traffic in France, Ireland and the United Kingdom.


Report: FTC Expanding Anti-Trust Investigation Of Google To Include Google+

2012: So said “people familiar with the situation.”


Bing Tests New Bottom Home Page Bar

2012: The new bar added a Popular Now, Weather, Image and Video boxes.


Google’s SPYW, Kenya Imbroglios An “Ink Blot” Test For Google As Good Or Evil

2012: A local search/directory startup said Google crawled its site for local business sales leads and then falsely claimed in cold calls to those businesses it had a partnership with the publisher to sign them up.


Search In Pics: Google Cockroach, Cutts With Horse Mask & Google Beer Pong

2012: The latest images culled from the web, showing what people eat at the search engine companies, how they play, who they meet, where they speak, what toys they have and more.


Google Now #1 Search Engine In Czech Republic; 5 Countries To Go For Global Domination

2011: The Czech Republic was one of six countries (along with Russia, Japan, China, Taiwan and South Korea) where Google wasn’t the dominant search engine.


Bing Now Powering Yahoo Search In 3 More Countries

2011: Bing was now powering the Yahoo back-end for organic search in Australia, Brazil and Mexico.


Bing Enhances Auto Instant Answers with Car Listings

2011: Bing added new and used car listings in a self-contained autos-shopping page that kept users within the Bing experience.


Experian Hitwise: Bing Searches Up 5% In December 2010

2011: From November to December 2010, Bing.com saw a 5% increase in search activity, while Bing-powered searches also rose 2%


Google’s New China Plan: Target Display Advertisers, Report Says

2011: Under the new game plan, Google was targeting Chinese firms to advertise on its dominant overseas search market, a business which already constitutes about half of its China revenues.


Europeans Go “Fishing” For Bad Google Behavior In Anti-Trust Inquiry

2011: A 120 question document sought “to ascertain whether Google manipulated search results and used its popular platform to keep business and disadvantage rivals in online advertising and Internet search.”


Topsy Launches Brand-Friendly Twitter Widgets

2011: Topsy’s Social Modules were embeddable widgets that brought Twitter content to any website.


AdWords Display URL Policy Change For Hosted Domains

2010: For sites hosted on a blogspot.com, wordpress.com or similar type of domain, Google wanted advertisers to show the subdomain portion of the domain, in addition to the main domain.


Google Ranks Real-Time Tweets Based On Followers?

2010: It wasn’t just about the number of Twitter followers, but also who the “reputed followers” were, according to Amit Singhal, a Google Fellow.


Google’s China Gambit: Day Two Reaction

2010: A sampling of a wide variety of reactions and responses to the news that Google could potentially pull out of China if it cannot operate without censorship.


Nielsen: Yahoo, Bing Down, Google Up in December

2010: Gains by Google, a minor gain by AOL, and declines for Yahoo and Bing. 


Harvard Professor Details New, ‘Insidious’ Form Of Google Click Fraud

2010: One of Google’s more vocal critics says the company should cut its ties with InfoSpace over what he called “a particularly insidious kind of click fraud” that involves a fairly complex combination of paid ads, affiliate traffic brokering, and spyware. 


Baidu: The Official Google Blog You Seek Does Not Exist (& Don’t Even Try Looking For It)

2010: Anyone searching for the official Google blog post about Google deciding to leave China over censorship was unable to find it on China’s leading search engine, Baidu.


Think Like A Blackhat By Matt Cutts

2009: A 20-minute video where Cutts went over what he considered to be virtual “blight” (link spam, open landing pages and hacking). Cutts also showed how to think like a spammer.


Autodesk’s Carol Bartz Named New Yahoo CEO; Sue Decker To Leave As President

2009: Bartz was praised for her management and deal brokering skills but had never run an internet company, and had no advertising background.


Help Google Find ‘Empty Review Sites’

2009: Cutts said these pages might run afoul of Google’s webmaster guidelines, and gave specific instructions for reporting this kind of page to Google’s spam team.


Obama Stimulus, Predictions And Search

2009: In retrospect, it appeared that relative search query volumes (Obama vs. McCain) did presage the outcome of the November election. And it appeared they predicted the recession.


Ask.com Partners With NASCAR, Says “Super Verticals” Will Put It Back In Search Race

2009: Coming soon: A NASCAR search engine? Ask also becomes the official search engine of NASCAR.


Google Maps Adds Public Transit Data In 50 Cities

2009: Once selected, the Transit Layer would display public transportation lines/routes for the area you were viewing.


Spice Up Your ASCII AdWords Campaign With Animated ASCII URLs

2009: How one agency created animated racing ASCII cars in the browser address bar using JavaScript.


From Search Marketing Expo (SMX)


Past contributions from Search Engine Land’s Subject Matter Experts (SMEs)

These columns are a snapshot in time and have not been updated since publishing, unless noted. Opinions expressed in these articles are those of the author and not necessarily Search Engine Land.


< January 12 | Search Marketing History | January 14 >


Related stories

New on Search Engine Land

@media screen and (min-width: 800px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:770px; min-height:260px; } } @media screen and (min-width: 1279px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:800px!important; min-height:440px!important; } }

About the author

Danny Goodwin

Danny Goodwin is Managing Editor of Search Engine Land & SMX. In addition to writing daily about SEO, PPC, and more for Search Engine Land, Goodwin also manages Search Engine Land’s roster of subject-matter experts. He also helps program our conference series, SMX – Search Marketing Expo. Prior to joining Search Engine Land, Goodwin was Executive Editor at Search Engine Journal, where he led editorial initiatives for the brand. He also was an editor at Search Engine Watch. He has spoken at many major search conferences and virtual events, and has been sourced for his expertise by a wide range of publications and podcasts.

https://searchengineland.com/search-marketing-history-january-13-391743