Microsoft, BigCommerce team up to launch new marketplace Ads and Listings

Microsoft and BigCommerce just announced a new partnership called “Microsoft Ads and Listings in the BigCommerce Marketplace.” The new collaboration enables BigCommerce merchants in the US, UK and ANZ to directly integrate their stores and reach Microsoft Advertising’s audience of more than a billion people.

What BigCommerce says.

Seamless partner app integrations like Microsoft Ads and Listings uplevel the value and opportunities that we can deliver to our merchants all over the world to reach millions of potential new customers searching across the Microsoft Advertising Network,” said Sharon Gee, vice president of revenue growth and general manager of omnichannel at BigCommerce. “By adding another strategic omnichannel partner integration to our roster, our merchants can seamlessly advance their omnichannel operations while unlocking new channel growth. BigCommerce prides itself on our best-of-breed, partner-first approach and our commitment to the noble purpose of open commerce. With this, merchants are able to easily leverage leading, pre-integrated solutions to drive their long term success.

Sharon Gee, vice president of revenue growth and general manager of omnichannel at BigCommerce

How it works. BigCommerce merchants can synchronize product catalogs directly to Microsoft Merchant Center. They can then create shopping campaigns to promote product catalogs and track campaign performance, without leaving the BigCommerce Control Panel.

The partnership offers advantages to BigCommerce merchants by:

  • Broadening audience reach through new channels. The Microsoft Advertising Network sees billions of searches each month, giving merchants the opportunity to showcase products to millions of potential customers on Microsoft Bing, MSN, Microsoft Edge and via syndicated partners such as Yahoo! and AOL, to name a few.
  • Driving more traffic with enhanced shopping experiences. Through the new Microsoft Shopping Tab, merchants can filter product feeds with specific attributes that deliver richer ad content, and narrow search results that can increase click-through and conversion rates by simply making it easier for shoppers to find what they are looking for.
  • Monitoring and optimizing ad performance in real time. Without leaving the BigCommerce Control Panel, merchants can see campaign performance with a snapshot view or run detailed reporting on a wide or granular scope, with specific key elements or side-by-side comparisons across various ad campaigns. Changes can be made in real time to status, budgets and bids while having access to a personalized tips dashboard and customer support to get better results.

Why we care. Jason McKay, senior director, global partner sales, Microsoft Advertising says:

The Microsoft Advertising Network connects BigCommerce merchants with people who have greater purchasing power, engage more with ads and are more likely to make a purchase online. With Microsoft Ads and Listings, BigCommerce merchants can connect with customers in new ways, achieving a strong return on spend to drive long-term growth.

Jason McKay, senior director, global partner sales, Microsoft Advertising

This new partnership could be part of Microsoft’s effort to double the size of its ad revenue to $20 billion. Either way, it’s a step in the right direction for advertisers and merchants looking to expand their reach beyond Google and Facebook.


Related stories

New on Search Engine Land

@media screen and (min-width: 800px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:770px; min-height:260px; } } @media screen and (min-width: 1279px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:800px!important; min-height:440px!important; } }

About the author

Nicole Farley

Nicole Farley is an editor for Search Engine Land covering all things PPC. In addition to being a Marine Corps veteran, she has an extensive background in digital marketing, an MBA and a penchant for true crime, podcasts, travel, and snacks.

https://searchengineland.com/microsoft-bigcommerce-team-up-to-launch-new-marketplace-ads-and-listings-391040




Arbitrage in Google’s Local Services Ads: What you need to know

Many great articles have exposed the seedy underbelly of Local Services Ads spam and fake reviews. There’s one on Search Engine Roundtable regarding fake reviews and another on Search Engine Land where Len Raleigh talked about location spam, reviews, names and ads. 

I recently learned from a client that the dark hole goes a little deeper than just being misleading on locations and reviews. 

This discovery will make those in the local SEO space recall what was seen in the personal injury and the garage door spaces. 

In the last two years, we have seen location spam and review spam proliferate. 

There were also large lead gen networks involved that would trash an area with fake profiles, bolster them with reviews and then turn around and sell those leads to merchants – usually the same merchants they had buried. 

Several people in the local SEO space banded together and helped reduce that volume of spam. And eventually, Google took some action.

While that spam is still around in some form to this day, it appears that they have moved into another area that Google is not good at – or does not want to police actively. 

As fellow digital marketer and SEO expert Dennis Yu told me: 

  • “Spam in the garage door space is just as bad as it is in the personal injury law space, it is unfair to businesses and consumers. As marketing agencies embrace LSA more, this has to be taken into consideration as any move you make can be disrupted by bad actors at any time, and it feels as though it is hard to get rid of.”

Spam and fake reviews on Google’s Local Service Ads

Local Service Ads (LSAs) allow consumers to find companies that Google feels they trust because they have passed multiple checks on personnel backgrounds, licenses and insurance, among others. 

The big problem here is “trust,” which seems to be easily manufactured and cheated. 

We need to know how LSA works to understand where the issues come in.

  • Entities are background-checked and “Google Guaranteed” or “Google Screened.” Here is Google’s guide on how to qualify.
  • Google presents providers from those which have been verified. The result is three providers that are returned at the top of a query response (in a row of three).
  • The customer calls the provider to schedule an appointment, with calls routed through Google. Options exist for messages and booking as well.
  • The company called is charged for the lead (usually $25 in the garage door space).
  • A review request is made, or a link is sent. Google does not verify the reviews. However, they state that when they can tie the review to a job booked from LSAs, they verify the review.

LSA was supposed to be a great way of combating spam, but now appears poised for the dark side.

Illustrating the issue

lsas - garage door pros in pasadena

The two companies highlighted in the screenshot both serve Pasadena – and they appear to be owned by the same person (based on the following table).

The issue? It would be a violation of LSA policies.

My source delved deeper and saw that the same people owned many companies in the area. 

affiliated companies on gls

The table above shows that the same actors in local service ads own multiple entities. To uncover this, a third party looked at licensing owners for California garage door companies. These companies were in LSA at the time of the data collection. 

Below is the same list of companies with their related LSAs. (At the time of writing, three were removed from LSA.)


  • AAA Garage Door Services (removed)
  • Socal  Garage Door Services (removed)
  • Jordan’s Garage Door Service (removed)



*An affiliated entity is one with overlapping ownership identified through the California Contractors State License Board (CSLB).

Based on research from a third party, the above companies own multiple entities – some of which are also in LSA.

There is a  pattern of creating entities for the sole purpose of getting into LSA. We have successfully removed spam LSA entries by looking at the fake entitles behind them. (More on why that is important later.)

So now we have multiple entities. What to do next? How about getting fake reviews? 

As astutely noted in Raleigh’s article, it is super easy and cheap to get “verified” LSA reviews.

Sidenote: A “verified” LSA review is not really verified per se. A unique link is generated after a job is completed, which you can send to an LSA customer, but you can also just hand out the generic LSA review link and get reviews – from anyone. Even those who left a Google Business Profile (GBP) review. It’s not super trustworthy and can be easily gamed.

So how are these entities getting non-bought, fake reviews? It’s quite simple.

  • Call the “company” to schedule a fake appointment on a Google Local Service number.
  • After the scheduled time, leave a review via the review link.
  • The cost of this review is the cost of a call to Google Local Service. If the call is to a listed local provider when it is not in the 3-box, this is around $25 for the “lead.” One company was quoted $4,000 for 1,500 reviews. 

Get the daily newsletter search marketers rely on.


How the Local Services Ads arbitrage works

How the Local Services Ads arbitrage works.

The LSA arbitrage goes something like this:

  • Create licensed entities and register with the Secretary of State, without having any employees. Only required documents are needed to pass LSA checks.
  • Buy or otherwise seed the profile with fake reviews from a fake GBP and/or with “verified” reviews on LSA.
  • When a lead comes in, they subcontract that job to an unlicensed individual or company. 
  • The lead buyer shows up for the job stating the company canceled and they can complete the order. This leaves the consumer dealing with an unknown individual or company that they will never be able to track down. The consumer is usually overcharged and sold parts/services they do not need. (Sound familiar?)
  • Create more entities.
  • When bad reviews start happening, turn off ads and turn on new entities.

Google has no knowledge or quality control over subcontracting between the entities it licenses and outside entities that ultimately run the jobs. (To be fair, this could be hard to detect right now, but some mechanisms could be put in place to discover it.) 

That said, Google says they investigate allegations of subcontracting on LSA and enforce as appropriate, so report it if you see it.

Ultimately, it is with a combination of strategies that bad actor companies can:

  • Dominate access to customers, burying good merchants.
  • Have no constraints on poor service or negative consumer experiences.
  • Conduct core activities, such as posting fake reviews (against U.S. Federal Trade Commission guidelines) and subcontracting to unlicensed entities, which are illegal. Yet they seem to be able to get away with no consequence for now.
  • Engage in GBP fraud. 

What has Google said?

When I asked our contact at LSA about this, I received the following statement from a Google spokesperson:

“We have strict policies in place for Local Services Ads to protect people and advertisers from industry-wide abuse and fraud. We are committed to fighting fake content and reviews in local ads and listings and are investing significantly in new enforcement systems that help protect both users and providers from abuse.” 

In another meeting, I was informed this is going up to the highest levels in LSA and also to Google Legal, so there may be some change here in policies. 

For context, Google has previously reported that to help people find reliable local information in 2021, they: 

  • Blocked or removed more than 95 million policy-violating reviews, over 60,000 of which were taken down due to COVID-related instances.
  • Took down more than 1 million reviews that were reported directly to them.
  • And as a result of continued advancements in their machine learning, their technologies and teams blocked or removed more than 190 million photos and 5 million videos that were blurry, low quality, or violated Google’s content policies.

Why is this LSA arbitrage a warning sign? 

There was a specific cycle when the personal injury and garage door spam started. Spam would pop up in major states/metros, like California, New York, Florida, and Texas.

They would stay in those metros for about six months and then start to spread across the U.S. Based on reports, these are the metros they are in now.

Actions we can take

Getting Google to take this seriously seems like moving a mountain and they do have many legal hoops to jump through. They could also be disincentivized to act simply because the “proof” is hard to find scalably. And, let’s be honest with ourselves, this is a money-making platform. 

Regarding making money though, if the bad actors are cleared out then good merchants will spend as much as they can to get leads. I have some customers with $100,000+ of weekly budget!

Here are some ways search marketers can take action.

  • Prevent repeat abusers from simply creating a new entity to work from. Document and report your proof to Google.
  • Report fake GBPs and LSAs to the FTC. (Note that Google would like the opportunity to look into any alleged fraud before escalating to the FTC.)
  • Raise pressure on Google to address the issue.
  • Raise consumers’ awareness of these issues through industry outlets.

What can Google do?

  • Part of the value of LSAs to a consumer is in knowing that a contractor is real and is going to be there should there be a problem. Google performs background checks on employees. However, it cannot perform background checks on a changing pool of outsourced subcontractors. Google can make it clear that subcontracting leads to another company or individual is a policy violation (and in some states, like California, a violation of state law). Google can also suspend reported LSA profiles while investigating.
  • Enhance the ranking algorithm to assess the reliability of the number and rate of reviews received based on the employees in the company. For instance, if a company has one employee, how could they get 1,500 reviews in less than a month? If there are hundreds of reviews arriving between midnight and 6 a.m., there might be a problem. 
  • Hold abusive licensing groups accountable for the violations of their other companies.
  • Do not allow multiple companies with shared ownership to compete for the same geographic region within LSA.

We should have seen this coming

The Local Services Ads platform is still relatively young.

Marketers should have seen this coming. Google should have, too, given all their experience with spam and arbitrage on Google Ads.

Google can do better. Hopefully, they can take this as a call to action to step up and do the right thing, no matter how difficult it is. 

It will cost money in infrastructure and loss of ad revenue, but the upside is that real merchants will spend money for real leads. Consumers will ultimately have more confidence in the platform. That is a win-win in my book!

Thanks to those in our industry championing the effort to raise awareness of these issues.


Opinions expressed in this article are those of the guest author and not necessarily Search Engine Land. Staff authors are listed here.


Related stories

New on Search Engine Land

@media screen and (min-width: 800px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:770px; min-height:260px; } } @media screen and (min-width: 1279px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:800px!important; min-height:440px!important; } }

About the author

Ben Fisher

Ben Fisher is a Google Business Profile Diamond Product Expert, and an experienced veteran in SEO since 1994. He is also a contributor to the Local Search Ranking Factors Survey, faculty member at LocalU, and owner of the Local Marketing Institute. He’s the co-founder of Steady Demand, which works with agencies and businesses to maximize outsourced Local SEO can tackle the hardest of GBP issues. He can be reached on Twitter at @TheSocialDude.

https://searchengineland.com/google-local-services-ads-arbitrage-387645




This day in search marketing history: January 9

AdWords Managed Accounts get shared negative lists across accounts

In 2017, Google added the ability to create and share negative keyword lists across accounts for Managed Accounts.

This was welcome news for advertisers who had been adding the same lists of negative keyword accounts manually or using a script to automate cross-account negative lists. 

For accounts in a managed account, you could set up a single list of negative keyword in the top-level Shared Library that could then be associated at the account level.

Read all about it in: AdWords Managed Accounts can finally share negative keyword lists across accounts


Also on this day 


DuckDuckGo, Info.com crowd out Bing in Google’s Android search options

2020: Bing would appear as an option in the United Kingdom only, while DuckDuckGo and Info.com will appear alongside Google in all 31 EU territories


Conductor launches SEO services marketplace for Searchlight users

2020: Agency and corporate customers could request managed services directly within the platform interface.


2019: Google started rolling out a new feature in search named “your related activity” that let signed in Google users pick up on previous searches related to the query they just added.


Google working to disable knowledge graph hack that shows misleading search results

2019: The trick made it possible to show any site for any query in the knowledge panel area.


Har Gobind Khorana Google doodle celebrates first chemist to construct a synthetic gene

2018: Google marked what would have been Har Gobind Khorana’s 96th birthday with a Doodle to celebrate the Nobel Prize winner’s accomplishments in the field of biochemistry.


Google is launching automated call extensions in mobile ads on February 6

2017: The call extensions would automatically pull phone numbers featured on landing pages.


2017: Mobile played a significant role, accounting for nearly half of all Valentine’s Day-related searches on Bing.


What Is The Mountain Of Butterflies? Google Doodle Marks 41st Anniversary Of The Natural Phenomenon

2016: For its first Doodle of the year, Google celebrated the 41st anniversary of the discovery of “The Mountain of Butterflies,” when a research team located millions of Monarch butterflies that had migrated to Mexico’s easternmost Sierra Madre Mountains.


Google Results For “Car Insurance” Could Look Different Very Soon

2015: Google finally seemed ready to launch its long-anticipated comparison site for car insurance.


Report: Yahoo Search Losing Firefox Users Who “Switchback” To Google

2015: An analysis showed a gradual but continual losses back to Google, and Yahoo’s share of Firefox 34 clicks dropped from 43% (Dec. 10) to about 36 percent


Search In Pics: SCU Basketball At Google, Android Professor & Framed Panda

2015: The latest images culled from the web, showing what people eat at the search engine companies, how they play, who they meet, where they speak, what toys they have, and more.


Google Preps “Hotel View” Interior 360 Imagery

2014: Google was photographing hotel interiors as part of an effort to enhance its travel content.


Simone De Beauvoir Google Logo Has Come To Stay In A Number Of Countries, Just Not The US

2014: A number of Google international homepages celebrated feminist writer Simone de Beauvoir’s 106th birthday with a Beauvoir-inspired Google logo, but there’s no sign of her on Google’s U.S. homepage.


Phone Support For Verification Issues With Google Local For Business

2013: Google offered phone support for businesses having issues with verifying their Google Maps listing.


Survey Shows Americans Confused By How Google, Facebook Make Money

2013: A striking 36% of respondents thought that search engines “sell users’ personal data to marketers.” Another 29% thought that “companies pay annual dues for use.” 


Bit.ly Releases Search API To Discover Hot Stories & Discussions

2013: The new APIs let you search for top stories in real time over the Bit.ly URL network. 


Class Action Lawsuit Against Google For Ads On Parked Domains Turned Down

2012: A lawsuit brought against Google in 2008 over the quality of ads showing on parked or error message web pages was thrown out by the court.


Koreans Accuse Google Of “Obstructing” Antitrust Investigation

2012: A Korean official asserted that Google has obstructed his agency’s investigation “by deleting key files from PCs and asking its employees to telecommute from home.” Google denied obstructing the inquiry and pledged cooperation with Korean government officials.


BBC Report: Google Admits Accepting Illegal AdWords In The UK

2012: Ads for illegal Olympic ticket resellers, ads for cannabis, and ads for fake identification cards and UK passports. All illegal, but all could be found on Google.co.uk


Google Has Well Over A Million Advertisers

2009: Google’s advertiser growth started at 89,000 in 2003, to 201,000 in 2004, 360,000 in 2005 and 600,000 in 2006. In 2009, one estimate said Google had between 1.3 million and 1.5 million advertisers.


Want To Rank Tops In Google? Do YouTube Videos, Stupid!

2009: A small but interesting study on how you can improve your chances, by 50 times, of showing up at the top of the Google search results: Utilize Google’s Universal Search by creating videos.


Ballmer: Do Yahoo Deal Sooner, Not Later

2009: Microsoft CEO Steve Ballmer said that a deal should happen within the next few months, due to Microsoft and Yahoo having new “leaders” in place.


Google Changes, Colorizes Favicon

2009: The new icon was inspired by user submissions as part of a contest.


Google Goes To The Inauguration

2009: Google/YouTube threw its first party for a U.S. president’s inauguration


Search Biz: Yahoo CEO Duel, MSFT Reconsiders Search Brand, MSN ‘Lewd’ In China & Google Won’t Buy Newspapers

2009: Roundup of personnel moves or speculation about who might get the top spot at Yahoo; the ongoing MicroHoo saga; and MSN being branded a “lewd” site in China for user-generated content.


Search In Pictures: Snow Reaches Yahoo, YouTube’s Phone Booth & The Google Bear

2009: The latest images culled from the web, showing what people eat at the search engine companies, how they play, who they meet, where they speak, what toys they have and more.


Google Changes Referral Policy For AdSense Referrals

2008: The two changes made to this referrals pricing structure only impact referrals to the AdSense product.


Real Time US Presidential Primary Results In Google Maps

2008: Google mapped the results of the New Hampshire U.S. presidential primary by candidate and county for both parties.


Microsoft Launches adCenter Add-in Beta for Excel 2007

2008: New features included Keyword Expansion, Keyword Search Volume Historical and Forecast, Keyword Buzz and more.


Google Hiring Investigator / Threat Analyst For Safety & Security

2008: The responsibilities included “investigating deviations from company policies or acts against Google as well as collection and analysis of information helping define and assess threats to Google’s operations and assets.”


Microsoft Provides Local Search Content To Garmin Personal Navigation Devices

2008: Users could get maps, news, weather, local events, and other content.


Google Updates Sky Images & Features In Google Earth

2008: Sky in Google Earth was updated with new content, features, and API integrations.


Jim Safka To Replace Jim Lanzone As CEO Of Ask.com

2008: Safka was previously the CEO of Match.com, IAC’s online dating company, from 2004 to 2007. 


Yahoo Acquires MyBlogLog

2007: After several weeks of rumors, Yahoo has officially announced it has agreed to purchase the MyBlogLog service.


Google Named Fortune’s Best Place To Work, But Rich Early Employees Checking Out

2007: A third of Google’s first 300 employees had left the company, and the culture was getting more conservative


Google A “Frenemy” of Traditional Media?

2007: Google had no intention of competing with traditional media by creating content, but many media companies remained wary of Google.


Google Moon, Google Mars, Now Google Universe? Google Partnership With Space Telescope Project May Make UniTube Possible

2007: the company was getting involved with the Large Synoptic Survey Telescope. To be built in Chile, the LSST was planned to scan the sky on a continuous basis, allowing for “movie-like” looks at the universe.


Yahoo China Morphing Into A Business Portal

2007: Due in part to deal with crushing competition from Baidu.com and portal Sina.com.


Fraudwall, New Anti-ClickFraud Company Funded

2007: The company raised millions in venture capital to help online advertisers identify click fraud using statistics, user modeling, machine learning, and IP forensics”


Past contributions from Search Engine Land’s Subject Matter Experts (SMEs)

These columns are a snapshot in time and have not been updated since publishing, unless noted. Opinions expressed in these articles are those of the author and not necessarily Search Engine Land.


< January 8 | Search Marketing History | January 10 >


Related stories

New on Search Engine Land

@media screen and (min-width: 800px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:770px; min-height:260px; } } @media screen and (min-width: 1279px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:800px!important; min-height:440px!important; } }

About the author

Danny Goodwin

Danny Goodwin is Managing Editor of Search Engine Land & SMX. In addition to writing daily about SEO, PPC, and more for Search Engine Land, Goodwin also manages Search Engine Land’s roster of subject-matter experts. He also helps program our conference series, SMX – Search Marketing Expo. Prior to joining Search Engine Land, Goodwin was Executive Editor at Search Engine Journal, where he led editorial initiatives for the brand. He also was an editor at Search Engine Watch. He has spoken at many major search conferences and virtual events, and has been sourced for his expertise by a wide range of publications and podcasts.

https://searchengineland.com/search-marketing-history-january-9-391127




This day in search marketing history: January 8

Intent research vs. keyword research

In 2020, Frédéric Dubut of Bing told us: “Keyword research are probably going to become slowly obsolete and you’ll need to switch to intent research as a practice.”

Barry Schwartz asked Google’s John Mueller about Dubut’s statement. Here’s what Mueller said:

  • “There’s probably always gonna be a little bit of room for keyword research because you’re kind of providing those words to users. And even if search engines are trying to understand more than just those words, showing specific words to users can make it a little bit easier for them to understand what your pages are about and can sometimes drive a little bit of that conversion process.”

So, is keyword research obsolete yet? In 2023, there definitely has been a significant shift in the way SEOs think about user intent, or the search intent behind a query. But keyword research is still far from obsolete.

Read all about it in Google’s John Mueller on intent research vs keyword research for 2020.


Also on this day 


Halting campaigns shouldn’t be your only brand safety precaution

2021: How advertisers responded to the storming of the Capitol and the cases for and against pausing ads in times of disruption.


Google’s John Mueller on intent research vs keyword research for 2020

2020: Search engines continue to get better at understanding intent and rely less on keywords. But Mueller wouldn’t go as far as to say keyword research practices will or should go away anytime soon.


Google handles reconsideration requests in batches

2020: John Mueller said that the Google team goes through reconsideration requests in batches, so sometimes it can feel like there is a backlog.


2020: Page owners could use Bing Pages to aggregate social media links, publish contact details, customize Outlook profiles with images and content and promote social media posts.


2020: In this installment of Barry Schwartz’s vlog series, he chatted with Dean about making good quality videos, the nofollow link attribute change and more.


Need to expedite page removal in Google’s search index? Try a temporary sitemap file

2019: if you have hundreds or thousands of pages, removing URLs one by one can be time-consuming. What tocan you do? Use temporary sitemaps, according to John Mueller. 


Google Assistant updates: Airline check-ins, hotel bookings, language translation and Maps

2019: Google was working hard to make the Assistant (and by extension, Home) a transactional platform.


Machine vs. man: What really matters for SEO success

2019: Lily Ray on changes to how sites are evaluated, dealing with traffic drops due to algorithm changes, Google’s search quality rater guidelines and more.


Google to roll out new Search Console features in coming weeks

2018: Verified users in Google Search Console were about to get access the new Search Performance, Index Coverage, AMP status and Job posting reports.


Google removes addiction treatment ads from UK search results

2018: An investigation revealed an ongoing issue with middlemen bidding on the terms and receiving large kickbacks from the private centers where the searchers were ultimately referred to – a practice called “patient brokering.”


Google accidentally removes news publishers from Google News

2018: Google called it an “unintentional technical issue.”


It’s Google Home vs. Amazon Alexa at CES in the battle for the voice ecosystem

2018: Google and Amazon both announced new device partnerships; the Google Assistant would be on new “smart display” devices, more TVs, speakers and in cars. 


Google announces solution to longstanding AMP cache URL display problem

2018: Google said it was making a change to stop displaying Google URLs, instead of the publisher URLs, in search results served from the AMP cache.


Search In Pics: GoogleBot & BB-8, Google Onesie & Tesla Model X

2016: The latest images culled from the web, showing what people eat at the search engine companies, how they play, who they meet, where they speak, what toys they have and more.


Google Now Bugs Remove Cards From Users While Google Now Tests Custom Background Themes

2015: Some users were missing their Google Now cards, which they rely on to see if there will be traffic on the way to work, how cold it may be or other useful information for their day.


AdWords Reach Reporting Moves To The Campaigns Tab

2015: Google moved the Reach and Frequency report out of the Dimensions tab to the Campaigns tab.


2015: Microsoft’s search engine started displaying a carousel of New York Times best-selling books when searching for specific book genres.


Google France Homepage Goes “Je Suis Charlie” In Memory Of Charlie Hebdo Victims

2015: Google France added the “Je Suis Charlie” (“I am Charlie”) badge on its homepage, honoring the lives lost during the Charlie Hebdo massacre in Paris, France.


Yahoo’s News Digest App Is “Summly 2.0”

2014: CEO Marissa Mayer introduced the new news app at CES. Summly was acquired by Yahoo in March 2013 for an estimated $30 million.


Utah Has Highest Google Usage, West Virginia The Lowest

2014: Ad network Chitika released a new tool that provided a user percentage or traffic market-share breakdown of PC operating system and search usage on a state-by-state basis.


Google’s Matt Cutts On Publishers With Duplicate Content: Use The Canonical Tag

2014: In How should I address a small duplicate content issue?, Cutts said to use the rel=canonical tag to help consolidate the PageRank of the stories and avoid any issues with Google.


Report: US Search Ad Spend Rises 12 Percent YoY In Q4 2013; Smartphone CPCs Drop

2014: IgnitionOne released its fourth quarter Digital Marketing Report, showing that the paid search market in the US continued to grow.


2013: The URL shown under the definition previously wasn’t clickable. Instead, the only way to click through to the source of the definition was to use the smaller Source link at the bottom of the box.


Google Is Hiring Someone To Find Ways To Make You Want To Search While Signed-In

2013: “As Product Marketing Manager within the search growth team, you will be responsible to developing plans, creatives, campaigns and programs to increase the number of user’s signed in.”


Google, Mobile Search And The Paradox Of Competition

2013: How much does Google figure into the “future of search,” whose advances will largely be determined by mobile and non-traditional devices? That was a hard question to answer.


2011: The Year Google & Bing Took Away From SEOs & Publishers

2012: Danny Sullivan called 2011 “alarming.” Why? Because after years of moving forward, the search engines took a big step back, withholding both linking and keyword data.


2011: A huge collection of trends, predictions and resolutions on paid search, SEO, local/mobile and more.


Google Mulling Several Ways To Integrate Ads On Maps

2010: Several articles speculated about or discussed ads on Google Maps (PC and mobile). 


Yahoo To Keep BOSS In Microsoft Deal, May Charge In Future

2010: Some of the results would be powered by Yahoo, while the search results in BOSS (Build your Own Search Service – a Yahoo Developer Network initiative to provide an open search web services platform) would be powered from Microsoft Bing.


A Year Later, Yahoo’s CEO Gives Herself A B-Minus

2010: Said Yahoo CEO Carol Bartz: “It was a little tougher internally than I think I had anticipated, I did move fast, but this is a big job.”


Where’s AP In Google News? Apparently In Limbo, As Contract Running Out

2010: Associated Press stories – hosted by Google itself — were no longer appearing in Google News. Google had not added any new AP content since Dec. 24.


Google Fast Flip Now On Google News Home Page

2010: The company’s experimental news reading tool became part of the Google News home page, while also still remaining a Google Labs project. 


Submit Your Google Spam Suggestions For 2009

2009: An annual tradition, Matt Cutts of Google’s Search Quality team asked for feedback on things Google should work on in relation to search spam.


Are PPC Budgets Increasing Or Decreasing In These Recessionary Times?

2009: 25% of Rimm-Kaufman’s clients increased their PPC spend 2008 Q4 vs. 2007, while 75% pulled back PPC spend.


Google Testing New AdWords Budgeting Option: Timeframe

2009: Timeframe gave advertisers a new budgeting method that automatically adjusted the daily budget based on traffic to reach a set dollar budget as per the calendar month.


Google SMS Search Is Down … For The Count?

2009: “Sorry, ‘[search term]’ did not return any results”.


Google StreetView, GPS Save Kidnapped Girl

2009: Police tracked the girl’s cell phone with GPS and then confirmed her whereabouts in Virginia, using StreetView.


Microsoft To Buy Fast Search For $1.23 Billion

2008:  Microsoft got a market-leading enterprise search company and a world-class web crawler (not to mention some of the smartest engineering talent in search).


Google & YouTube TVs Powered By Panasonic

2008: Matsushita Electric Industrial, the company behind Panasonic, said the TVs would enable users to browse and watch YouTube videos from their TVs.


Yahoo’s Yang Outlines Vision For An Integrated, Open Yahoo 2.0

2008: Search appeared to be a piece of the overall approach but not the core here; community and trusted content sources are emphasized.


Sony In Video Deal With Google & Viacom Deals With Five Competing Online Video Providers

2008: Sony announced a deal to provide Google’s YouTube five-minute clips of some of their most popular TV shows, including “Married With Children” and “Newsradio.”


Open Letter To Wikipedia Editors: Yes, Matt Cutts Is Notable

2007: That time when Matt Cutts’s Wikipedia’s page almost got deleted.


Court OKs Narrow Use of Competitor Trademarks in Search Ads & Meta Tags

2007: A U.S. District Court ruled that the use of keyword-triggered ads and keyword metatags using trademarked terms cannot confuse consumers if the resulting ads/search results don’t display a competitor’s trademarks.


An Open Letter to Paid Search Networks

2007: Search marketer Jeffrey Rohrs published an open letter to paid search providers asking critical questions about billing practices, transparency, click fraud and other issues


Yahoo Introduces Yahoo Go 2.0, Mobile Search & Other Apps

2007: While second to Google in Web search, the company was hoping it could lead the market for mobile search and associated advertising with a new offering tailored for use on handsets.


Search Engine ChaCha Announces $6 Million Round

2007: ChaCha employed a network of live guides to help answer user queries in real time in addition to providing traditional algorithmic search.


Advertisers Cutting Google AdWords Spending With Surge of Keyword Prices

2007: Why were advertisers cutting their PPC ad spend significantly in 2007? Because many of the keyword prices have resulted in advertisers being priced out of profitability.


From Search Marketing Expo (SMX)


Past contributions from Search Engine Land’s Subject Matter Experts (SMEs)

These columns are a snapshot in time and have not been updated since publishing, unless noted. Opinions expressed in these articles are those of the author and not necessarily Search Engine Land.


< January 7 | Search Marketing History | January 9 >


Related stories

New on Search Engine Land

@media screen and (min-width: 800px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:770px; min-height:260px; } } @media screen and (min-width: 1279px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:800px!important; min-height:440px!important; } }

About the author

Danny Goodwin

Danny Goodwin is Managing Editor of Search Engine Land & SMX. In addition to writing daily about SEO, PPC, and more for Search Engine Land, Goodwin also manages Search Engine Land’s roster of subject-matter experts. He also helps program our conference series, SMX – Search Marketing Expo. Prior to joining Search Engine Land, Goodwin was Executive Editor at Search Engine Journal, where he led editorial initiatives for the brand. He also was an editor at Search Engine Watch. He has spoken at many major search conferences and virtual events, and has been sourced for his expertise by a wide range of publications and podcasts.

https://searchengineland.com/search-marketing-history-january-8-391108




This day in search marketing history: January 7

The Spam Clock

in 2011, startup search engine Blekko launched a spam clock that estimated 155 million spam pages had been created since Jan. 1 of that year. Blekko said 1 million spam pages were being created every hour.

How bad was Google’s spam problem then? Big. But as Danny Sullivan pointed out at the time, it was hard to judge whether Google’s relevancy had actually decreased, because:

  • We expect more from Google than we do in the past, searching for things we might not have in previous years
  • We don’t remember all the successful searches, focusing on when things go bad.
  • We probably don’t do a comparison check on Bing or Blekko to see if they performed better, nor do we use those services on a regular basis to understand if they’re also “failing” to the degree we might feel Google does.
  • Our expectations of Google are higher.

Read all about it in Blekko Launches Spam Clock To Keep Pressure On Google.

In about a month, Google would start making moves to correct its perceived, growing relevancy problems with the Panda Update.

I don’t even want to think about how much spam has been created since the start of this year – especially with the explosion that is ChatGPT.


Also on this day 


Google Ads to allow ads for sport betting in New York

2022: Google Ads updated its gambling policy to allow ads for sports betting from certified and state-licensed entities in New York State.


2022: After eight months on pause, AdSense publishers could once again create Related search style experiments.


Google My Business launches new performance reporting

2021: The new reports provided 6 months of data on how people interacted with you (calls and messages) and how people discovered you (the search term used to find your Google business listing in Google Search and Google Maps).


Google working on fixing data in URL parameter tool

2020: Google was working on fixing a data issue with the URL parameter tool, a legacy tool within Google Search Console that let SEOs communicate to Google insignificant page variations and direct Google to consolidate those URLs.


Google tests user comments for live TV shows

2020: The user comments appeared in the search results for queries related to live TV shows. It was similar to Google’s live sporting events feature.


Direct site navigation via voice arrives on iOS Bing Search app

2020: The updated Microsoft Bing Search App also had a new look featuring a carousel of common search categories.


Google’s Rich Results testing tool now supports code editing

2019: You could now edit the code in the rich results test and see what those edits did in real time.


Google Manufacturer Center adds rich content, deeper analytics, expands availability

2019: A new “From the manufacturer” section in Google Shopping product pages could feature brand-supplied rich content.


Bing Ads’ AI-powered Performance Insights now available globally

2019: The tool provided an on-the-spot way to take action on performance changes in your accounts.


StrategiQ launches Spark, an SEO deployment platform

2019: The digital marketing agency’s new tool helped SEOs test and deploy SEO-related changes on their own without developer overhead.


Leading local SEO predictions: Reserve with Google will grow, real-time local inventory gets real

2019: GMB messaging, voice search optimization, local inventory data, Q&A and the decline of SMB websites are all explored.


2015: Torrent Freak study reveals the number of Google’s takedown notices were up 75% from 2013.


Report: Yahoo Search Share Up After Firefox Deal

2015: Yahoo saw a nearly 2 point search market share gain in the U.S. in the past month (10.4% vs. 8.6% year vs. year.)


Google Webmaster Tools Search Queries Adds Mobile Stats & No Longer Rounds Data

2014: Google’s John Mueller said, “data in the search queries feature will no longer be rounded / bucketed,” and you will start to notice these changes in Webmaster Tools in the next few days.


WordStream Updates Its Free Google AdWords Performance Grader: Now With Mobile And Automatic 30-Day Reporting

2014: The tool was refined to give advertisers performance benchmarks within their own industries


Zora Neale Hurston Google Logo Marks The 123rd Birthday Of The Harlem Renaissance Writer

2014: The Doodle paid tribute to one of the 20th century’s most celebrated African American female writers.


Twitter Co-Founder Biz Stone Launches New Social Search App Jelly

2014: Calling itself a “new way to search,” ultimately, Jelly would follow the path of social Q&A platform pioneers failures like Ask.com, Quora, Yahoo Answers and Google Answers.


Stats On Mobile Content & Impact On Google Rankings

2013: Having mobile-optimized and rendered content was highly correlated with getting organic traffic from Google.


Library Of Congress Struggling To Make A Searchable Twitter Archive

2013: The Library of Congress was working on plans to create a searchable archive of nearly every public tweet ever sent, but the challenges inherent in that task were making it a slow process.


Google Logo Honors Addams Family Creator, Charles Addams

2012: The black-and-white Doodle featured seven characters from “The Addams Family.”


Bing Adds FanSnap Ticket Inventory Into Search Results

2011: Just in time for the opening round of the NFL playoffs.


Quora Co-Founder Outlines Plans To Deal With Growing Pains

2011: Co-founder Charlie Cheever admitted it had been “a big challenge” to maintain Quora’s character while the site has been flooded with new users.


Bad Directions: Google Maps Sends Local Listing Reports To Wrong Business Owners

2010: Google sent out its Google Local Business Center updates – but the emails didn’t go to the actual business owners.


Armstrong: Google Gets “First Dibs” At AOL Search Deal

2010: AOL’s CEO, Tim Armstrong and former Google executive, said Google (not Microsoft Bing) would get “first dibs” at a search deal.


Yahoo & American Airlines Settle Search Ad Suit

2010: The two companies reached a settlement prior to judgment, although the terms of the settlement were not disclosed.


CES: Microsoft Expands Scope Of HP Search Relationship To 42 Countries

2010: Microsoft CEO Steve Ballmer announced that Bing would become the default search engine and MSN the default homepage on HP computers.


Earthquake: Real-Time Results On Google Make Up For Lack Of Other Content

2010: Google’s Earthquake OneBox didn’t catch it, but Google was saved by its integration of Twitter results.


French Wants To Tax Google & Others

2010: President Nicolas Sarkozy was exploring ways to tax Google and other online advertising companies based outside of France.


Bing Admits MSNbot Is Slow

2010: That was according to Brett Yount, a program manager for Bing, who said “it is well known in the industry that MSNbot is fairly slow.”


Google’s Near Me Now: A Yelp Killer?

2010: Spoiler alert: No, it was not.


Baidu Sued As Search Monopoly In China

2009: Leading Chinese search engine Baidu was sued by Chinese medical B2B marketplace Qmyy.com to prevent its site from being blocked or dropped by the engine.


Bruce Clay Releases Two New Tools

2009: One tool was named the Search Engine Optimization/KSP tool and the other was a toolbar called SEMToolBar.


Report: Sitemaps Decrease Crawler Response Time

2009: Test showed that submitting a sitemap to Google and Yahoo decreased the time it took Google and Yahoo to crawl the page.


Google Maps For Mobile Simplifies Directions

2009: Previously if users entered a business name on the Maps client as a directions end point, Google might not recognize it.


Bush: Fix Your “Miserable Failure” Googlebomb Legacy Before Obama Takes Office

2009: Bush should have stopped redirecting requests for his old biography to the current presidential home page. It left that page with a legacy of ranking for failure.


Microsoft Wins Verizon Mobile Search Derby

2009: Google and Microsoft were in tight competition for the mobile search partnership.


Search Biz: Yahoo-MSFT Update; Google’s 20% Time Changing & Google Router Coming Soon?

2009: The latest twist in the Yahoo-Microsoft saga: a new group was trying to takeover Yahoo with Microsoft’s money. 


Deal Puts Microsoft Live Search On Dell Computers, Verizon Phones — Will It Help?

2009: Microsoft CEO Steve Ballmer announced several high-profile distribution deals for Live Search at CES.


Google Confirms Layoffs Of Contract Employees

2009: Google released “a substantial number” of its contract and temporary employees, but the exact number wasn’t known.


Search Wikia: Not Even A Remote Threat To Google

2008: “Widely hyped … it’s really just yet another crappy search service that may, potentially, if all goes well, eventually turn into something useful.” See also: Wikia Search Launches Alpha Version


Googler’s Bet Goobles On Predictive Markets During Their Free Lunch

2008: Why did Google encourage this activity from their employees? Google believed it generated creative ideas from their employees.


David Hirsch Leaving Google & Omid Kordestani Sells 6,000 Shares Of Stock

2008: David Hirsch, the Director, B2B Vertical Markets Group at Google, was leaving at the end of the month to help invest and advise startups.


Yahoo Makes Bid To Become A Mobile Development Platform

2008: There were essentially three pieces to what Yahoo announced: Yahoo Go 3.0, an open mobile widget development platform for third parties, and a redesigned mobile WAP homepage that emphasized personalization and customization.


Google, AOL, Yahoo, & Digg Sued For Playing Online Solitaire

2008: Google, Yahoo, AOL, and Digg were all sued by Sheldon F. Goldberg for patent infringement.


From Search Marketing Expo (SMX)


Past contributions from Search Engine Land’s Subject Matter Experts (SMEs)

These columns are a snapshot in time and have not been updated since publishing, unless noted. Opinions expressed in these articles are those of the author and not necessarily Search Engine Land.


< January 5 | Search Marketing History | January 7 >


Related stories

New on Search Engine Land

@media screen and (min-width: 800px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:770px; min-height:260px; } } @media screen and (min-width: 1279px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:800px!important; min-height:440px!important; } }

About the author

Danny Goodwin

Danny Goodwin is Managing Editor of Search Engine Land & SMX. In addition to writing daily about SEO, PPC, and more for Search Engine Land, Goodwin also manages Search Engine Land’s roster of subject-matter experts. He also helps program our conference series, SMX – Search Marketing Expo. Prior to joining Search Engine Land, Goodwin was Executive Editor at Search Engine Journal, where he led editorial initiatives for the brand. He also was an editor at Search Engine Watch. He has spoken at many major search conferences and virtual events, and has been sourced for his expertise by a wide range of publications and podcasts.

https://searchengineland.com/search-marketing-history-january-7-391035




Google and Meta are losing their edge as TikTok, Amazon, Instacart ads grow

2022 marked the first year since 2014 that Google and Meta’s advertising market share dropped below 50%, standing at 48.4%. By the end of 2023, that number is expected to drop to 44.9%.

What’s going on. Amazon, ByteDance’s TikTok and streaming services like Netflix are continuing to increase their foothold. People are spending less time online on sites like Google and Meta, so it’s no surprise that they’re facing hurdles, despite still growing (albeit slower than other digital ad platforms).

Meta and other platforms also suffered from Apple’s iOS14 update in 2021, which required apps on its devices to ask users if they wanted to be tracked. The majority of iPhone users opted not to be. Google was not affected by this update, as it relies on customer intent, revealed by a user’s search terms.

The TikTok effect. Marketers want more options, and TikTok is it. TikTok’s hold on the digital ad market more than doubled in 2022, while Amazon gained market share due to its ad business being able to target users by their purchases and browsing history. 

The Washington Post reported that “Supergut Chief Executive Marc Washington said the maker of gut-health products used to spend about 80% of its ad budget on Meta’s Facebook and Instagram platforms, with the rest going to Google. In early 2022, he noticed that the cost of bringing in new customers through advertising on Meta’s platforms was twice as high as it was before Apple’s privacy changes. Supergut shifted about half of what it spent on Meta to TikTok, a short-form video platform popular with younger audiences.”

Insider Intelligence said that TikTok’s command of the digital ad market more than doubled in 2022 and has nearly 100 million U.S. monthly active users. However, its overall share remained small, at just 2% of U.S. digital ad spending.

Amazon continues to grow. Amazon accounted for 11.7% of U.S. digital-ad spending last year and is poised to grow to 12.4% in 2023, Insider said.

“Our advertising is at the point where consumers are ready to spend,” Amazon Chief Financial Officer Brian Olsavsky said on the company’s October conference call.

Other retailers have followed in Amazon’s footsteps by building digital-ad businesses based on their consumer data, known as retail media networks. Combined, Walmart Inc., eBay Inc., Etsy Inc. and Instacart took in about 1.4% of digital-ad dollars spent in the U.S. last year, according to Insider.

Microsoft & Netflix. We can’t talk about Netflix without talking about Microsoft. Last year they announced a partnership to bring an ad-supported subscription plan to Netflix. Vincent Létang, executive vice president of global market research at Magna, a media- investment firm that is part of Interpublic Group of Cos.‘ Mediabrands, called Netflix and Disney’s entry into the market “a game-changing moment” for ad-supported streaming. “They bring a potentially huge number of viewers,” he said, and a wealth of premium video content.

Why we care. Advertisers should be aware of emerging platforms, just as they should be aware of those experiencing a decline. Though most tend to predict these types of trends long before the numbers get published. But reports like this help solidify what many advertisers already know; diversification is key.


Related stories

New on Search Engine Land

@media screen and (min-width: 800px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:770px; min-height:260px; } } @media screen and (min-width: 1279px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:800px!important; min-height:440px!important; } }

About the author

Nicole Farley

Nicole Farley is an editor for Search Engine Land covering all things PPC. In addition to being a Marine Corps veteran, she has an extensive background in digital marketing, an MBA and a penchant for true crime, podcasts, travel, and snacks.

https://searchengineland.com/google-and-meta-are-losing-their-edge-as-tiktok-amazon-instacart-ads-grow-391062




This day in search marketing history: January 6

In 2011, Google Webmaster Tools started sending out two new types of warnings – for “unnatural links” and “cloaking.”

The messages were sent out when Google detected pages on websites that were using techniques that were outside of its quality guidelines.

At the time, Google had been talking about wanting to increase its outreach to webmasters. See this video (published Dec. 18, 2010), in which Google’s Matt Cutts (featuring Danny Sullivan) mentioned that Google wanted to make communication a priority in 2011.

[embedded content]

Read all about it in Google Adding New Spam Warnings In Webmaster Tools.

Dig deeper: Google penalties, manual actions and notifications: A complete guide


Also on this day 


Google launches ‘Shops’ section in mobile search results

2022: The Shops section showed three to 10 retailers based on their organic search rankings.


Google Ads error tells advertisers exact match keywords are saving as broad match

2022: Search marketers entering exact match keywords may have seen an alert toward the bottom of their Google Ads interface stating, “Broad match keywords are on. Keywords will be saved as broad match.”


Search Engine Land, SMX name Carolyn Lyden content lead

2021: Lyden acted both as editor-in-chief of Search Engine Land and content lead for our SMX events series. She departed Third Door Media in November 2021.


Standard text ads will live on a bit longer, Microsoft Advertising says

2020: Microsoft Advertising, which originally said standard text ads would no longer serve after 2019, announced it would allow existing standard text ads to continue to serve until March 31.


Video: A.J. Ghergich on not chasing the Google algorithm and focusing on human intentions

2020: In this installment of Barry Schwartz’s vlog series, he chatted with Ghergich about how to scale your SEO agency, understanding human intent and more.


Google to start showing local-specific phone numbers when location extensions appear in ads

2017: Google said, starting Jan. 19, it “may” show the local retail phone number when that store’s location extension showed in an ad – even if a call extension in the campaign used a different phone number – in order to increase the relevance of ads that featured specific business locations.


“Illegitimate” SEO Sentenced To 37 Months In Federal Prison For Extortion

2016: William Stanley extorted individuals and companies by threatening to engage in illegitimate SEO work: posting “fraudulent comments and creating negative reviews online, if the victim did not pay him a certain sum of money.”


Google Revamps The Android App-Indexing Crawl Errors Report In The Search Console

2016: Google announced they had finally upgraded the App Indexing Crawl Errors report, which had not been working for months, in the Google Search Console.


2016: Claiming to be enforcing Germany’s “Ancillary Copyright” Law, the publishers were suing to get Google to pay them for showing their content in search results.


Bing Ads, Too, Says Goodbye To Phone Numbers In PPC Ad Copy

2015: Bing Ads told advertisers they soon would no longer be able to put a phone number in the headline, body copy, URL or extensions like Sitelinks. As with AdWords, advertisers would need to use location or call extensions for phone numbers.


Pinterest Beefs Up Its Search Chops With VisualGraph Acquisition

2014: Pinterest said the acquisition would “help us build technology to better understand what people are Pinning. By doing so, we hope to make it easier for people to find the things they love.”


Bing Launches Awards Site In Time For Golden Globes, Grammy’s & The Oscars

2014: The site served as an online resource for “all things awards” with background information on nominees, tips for award-themed parties, and winner predictions based on Bing search statistics.


Bing Makes Driving Directions Twice As Fast

2012: Bing Maps pushed out a major update to their driving directions “routing engine.” The new routing engine was twice as fast as the old one and added more features, such as adding up to three routes in one request.


Search In Pics: Google Bumper Sticker, Knitted Android Sleeve & Yahoo’s CEOs

2012: The latest images culled from the web, showing what people eat at the search engine companies, how they play, who they meet, where they speak, what toys they have, and more.


Google Mobile Strategy Playing Out Almost Flawlessly: Ads Growing, Android Beating iPhone

2011: Google’s AdMob unit reported that it saw more than 2 billion ad requests on a daily basis. Meanwhile, comScore reported that Android passed the iPhone as the number two smartphone platform in the U.S.


South Korea May Arrest Google Execs Over WiFi Data Collection

2011: The country’s national police agency had determined that Google acted illegally when it gathered personal data as part of its Street View mapping service.


Covario: Consumer Electronics Marketers Take Q4 Paid Search Boom Overseas

2011: Among its tech and consumer electronics clients in the Americas, paid search spending only rose 1% in the fourth quarter of 2010, as compared to the third quarter, but that’s because growth from the second to the third quarter was 30%.


Twitter’s New Year Tweet Record Shown In Stunning Video

2011: Twitter started 2011 with a new record: 6,939 tweets were sent at four seconds after midnight in Japan. 


Foursquare Puts The Kibosh On Friend-Tip Spamming

2011: Foursquare started limiting the number of friends and friend requests that a user can have.


Google AdWords Testing Lead Capture Forms: Contact Form Extensions

2010: Contact form extensions provided a contact form directly in the search ad, which a searcher can fill out and the advertiser can then use in the future to contact that lead.


Google Loses French Lawsuit Over Google Suggest

2010: Google was ordered to remove the word arnaque, which translates roughly as “scam,” from appearing as a Google Suggest term on searches for the Centre National Privé de Formation a Distance (CNFDI). 


Surprise: Google’s Home Page Promoting Nexus One

2010: The promotion was found under the search box and read: “Experience Nexus One, the new Android phone from Google.”


Nexus One: What Exactly Happened Yesterday In Mountain View?

2010: Less than 24 hours after the formal unveiling of the Nexus One by Google, we had a collection of differing perceptions and accounts of what was significant (or not).


Google Claims That Google Checkout Increases Conversion By 40% & Clicks By 10%

2009: Google added claims to its Google Checkout Merchant homepage that having Google Checkout as part of your AdWords ads would lead to higher conversions and a better click-through rate.


Google Testing ‘Blended’ Mobile Ads

2009: As it turned out, Google wasn’t doing anything new. On the Google WAP search experience the company had always placed ads at the end of organic text results but before other types of content.


Yahoo To Advertisers: We Can Create Ads & Edit Keywords Without Asking First

2009: Yahoo emailed their search advertisers about new terms and conditions, including a controversial provision that they are allowed to create ads, remove or add keywords to campaigns and “optimize” accounts.


Google Finally Brings Picasa To The Mac

2009: Picasa was a management system for photo sharing and editing.


Google Wins “Gu Ge” Lawsuit In China

2009: The Beijing Haidian District Court ruled that Beijing Guge Science and Technology had to pay Google China 100,000 yuan ($14,624). In addition, Beijing Guge is required to stop using the name.


2009: It was suggested that the art represented an airplane crashing into New York’s former World Trade Center towers on 9/11.


The Big List of 2009 Marketing Predictions

2009: Articles and blog posts filled with forecasts, predictions, and/or resolutions for the new year. 


Mahalo Adds More Social Features

2008: The Mahalo Follow toolbar let you post links to Delicious, Ma.gnolia, Mahalo Social, and Twitter with the click of one button. The sidebar displayed quick tips when you were on sites like Twitter and Gmail.


From Search Marketing Expo (SMX)


Past contributions from Search Engine Land’s Subject Matter Experts (SMEs)

These columns are a snapshot in time and have not been updated since publishing, unless noted. Opinions expressed in these articles are those of the author and not necessarily Search Engine Land. 


< January 5 | Search Marketing History | January 7 >


Related stories

New on Search Engine Land

@media screen and (min-width: 800px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:770px; min-height:260px; } } @media screen and (min-width: 1279px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:800px!important; min-height:440px!important; } }

About the author

Danny Goodwin

Danny Goodwin is Managing Editor of Search Engine Land & SMX. In addition to writing daily about SEO, PPC, and more for Search Engine Land, Goodwin also manages Search Engine Land’s roster of subject-matter experts. He also helps program our conference series, SMX – Search Marketing Expo. Prior to joining Search Engine Land, Goodwin was Executive Editor at Search Engine Journal, where he led editorial initiatives for the brand. He also was an editor at Search Engine Watch. He has spoken at many major search conferences and virtual events, and has been sourced for his expertise by a wide range of publications and podcasts.

https://searchengineland.com/search-marketing-history-january-6-389992




Google agrees to pay up in 12 year class-action lawsuit

Consumers in a 12-year-long class action lawsuit against Google say that Google shared their queries with third parties without their permission.

What happened. The lawsuit alleged that Google violated both the Stored Communications Act, a federal law that governs access to records held by internet service providers, and state laws in California.

The settlement. Details of the settlement can be found here. In addition to the $23 million payout, which still needs court approval, it also requires Google to provide added disclosures to consumers about the sharing of search terms.

Dig deeper. Read the full announcement from Bloomberg.

Why we care. We’re not sure how or if this will affect advertisers in the future. But privacy issues are still a hot topic as we move into 2023.


Related stories

New on Search Engine Land

@media screen and (min-width: 800px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:770px; min-height:260px; } } @media screen and (min-width: 1279px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:800px!important; min-height:440px!important; } }

About the author

Nicole Farley

Nicole Farley is an editor for Search Engine Land covering all things PPC. In addition to being a Marine Corps veteran, she has an extensive background in digital marketing, an MBA and a penchant for true crime, podcasts, travel, and snacks.

https://searchengineland.com/google-agrees-to-pay-up-in-12-year-class-action-lawsuit-391038




Why advertisers should reassess Google Ads recommendations

I have a new recommendation for Google Ads advertisers in 2023:

Turn off and pause the use of all Google Ads recommendations.

Why?

On Jan. 4, Google Ads fundamentally changed the definition of a recommendation that users previously implemented. And Google is only giving advertisers two weeks before the change hits.

Before we begin here, the moral of this article is neither that the content in recommendations is bad, nor that you should blindly dismiss all recommendations. The goal here is to make less work for you while increasing account performance. 

Google Ads recommendations: what changed?

Nicole Farley covered an astounding change to what was a fairly tame Google Ads recommendation: “Remove Redundant Keywords.”

Advertisers had opted into the recommendation, allowing Google to remove keywords with the same match type that show for the same queries in an ad group in an effort to combat redundancy. There are reasons for and against this recommendation, but some advertisers would implement it due to the overall benefit of having one keyword in a match type show for the majority of terms. 

The new change being rolled out to advertisers that have applied this will change the recommendation definition to cross match types – removing phrase/exact match types in favor of a broad match keyword in an ad group.

If you applied the previous recommendation, these new rules will be pushed through to your account by Jan. 19 unless you opt-out.

Google said this recommendation change “doesn’t negatively impact your performance” but provided no facts or data to back up that statement.

Think about this for a moment.

Google Ads made this recommendation to help advertiser clean up redundant terms across a single match type, only to fundamentally change the recommendation and the rules completely.

If users had to go back and opt-in, as Shawn Elley mentions, this wouldn’t be a problem. If this cross match type cleanup was a new recommendation completely, no issue.

This, unfortunately, is not the case. 

Why is this a problem?

If Google Ads can change match type rules for this recommendation type, what’s next?

How can advertisers trust a single recommendation from Google if what you agree to today can be something completely different tomorrow? 

This is dangerous territory for advertisers and, frankly, the entire Google Ads platform.  

No recommendation can now be taken at face value.

That said, some recommendations can be helpful.

I will now be advising everyone to take any meaningful advice from recommendations and implement on your own volition – just not applying via a Google Ads recommendation.

The definition of Google Ads recommendations may now be fluid, but your work, attention to detail and commitment isn’t.

Don’t let Google take your efforts and dollars into its own hands.

Wait, aren’t Google Ads Recommendations helpful?

As an agency owner, I like to operate as if I were a fiduciary operating on behalf of my clients. The best interest of the client is always #1, #1a and #1b. Frankly, the recommendations system and Optimization Score has a notorious history and operates differently in my opinion.

When Google launched recommendations, some advertisers were flabbergasted that you could see the full list of possible recommendations where “raise your budgets” was an option, but “lower your budgets” wasn’t.

Similar expansion-esque recommendations like “Expand your reach with Google search partners” or “Use optimized targeting” also exist without a ying to said yang. It’s hard to welcome these spend-first, inflationary recommendations under a fiduciary lens.

While the majority of the recommendation intentions are obvious, most advertisers saw the system as more aggravating than helpful. 

Then it got worse. 

Google tried to force the hand of partners to adhere to a strict Optimization Score percentage if they wanted partners to keep their badge. The annoyance of recommendation dismissal turned into a threat against agency ethics and client outcomes. 

Thankfully, this ill-advised idea was put to bed and we’ve been back to dismissing most recommendations and only applying those that are bulletproof. 

Until now.

I no longer trust applying recommendations – and this isn’t a one-off occurrence, there is history behind it.

So what should you do with recommendations?

It’s a new year and should be a “new you” on the approach to Google Ads Recommendations.

Take a few minutes to check your settings and opt-out of any questionable recommendations.

You can see all by going to the Manage tab in the web interface.

Also, you need to be diligent in your efforts to make sure any existing recommendations are doing exactly what you thought they would do.

An important note is that you still need to implement any work that was executed by recommendations! Turning them off may save you headaches down the road.

You may want to reassess any auto-applied recommendations as well (make sure to manually do the work if you were relying on said recommendation though.)

Bottom line: If recommendations that have previously been applied can now be changed, advertisers should take extreme caution in applying any recommendation from Google Ads as it may change in the future.


Opinions expressed in this article are those of the guest author and not necessarily Search Engine Land. Staff authors are listed here.


Related stories

New on Search Engine Land

@media screen and (min-width: 800px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:770px; min-height:260px; } } @media screen and (min-width: 1279px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:800px!important; min-height:440px!important; } }

About the author

Greg Finn

Greg Finn is the Director of Marketing for Cypress North, a company that provides digital marketing and web development. He is a co-host of Marketing O’Clock and has been in the digital marketing industry for nearly 20 years. You can also find Greg on Twitter (@gregfinn) or LinkedIn.

https://searchengineland.com/reassess-google-ads-recommendations-391025




New Microsoft Store Ads promote desktop apps on Windows devices

Microsoft has just announced Store Ads to promote desktop apps on Windows 10 and 11 devices on desktops. When you create the ad on the Microsoft Advertising Platform, you can see it in the Microsoft Store, allowing your customers to click, download, and then start using your app.

The Microsoft Store in action. The Microsoft Store, for those Apple users, is where PC users go to learn about games, apps, and new software from Microsoft. The new Microsoft Store Ads s all desktop traffic, with mission-driven users that have a high intent to download a desktop app.

Instead of limiting your target audience and incentivizing app downloads on mobile alone, with Microsoft Store Ads, you’re now expanding your thinking and casting a wider net.

As one of the first to implement this strategy, Microsoft Advertising’s vision is for Microsoft Store Ads to empower advertisers to do more, boosting app acquisition and engagement strategy across screens beyond just mobile apps.

Getting started with Microsoft Store Ads. Microsoft Store Ads are for promoting apps built for Windows. To get started creating Store Ads, Microsoft offers the following guidance.

Dig deeper. For more information on the new Microsoft Store Ads, check out the announcement.

Why we care. If you’re a Windows developer or are running campaigns for one, you should check out the new Store Ad options to expand your reach and leverage the Microsoft audience. They’re easy to launch, don’t require a large budget, and will improve discoverability.


Related stories

New on Search Engine Land

@media screen and (min-width: 800px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:770px; min-height:260px; } } @media screen and (min-width: 1279px) { #div-gpt-ad-3191538-7 { display: flex !important; justify-content: center !important; align-items: center !important; min-width:800px!important; min-height:440px!important; } }

About the author

Nicole Farley

Nicole Farley is an editor for Search Engine Land covering all things PPC. In addition to being a Marine Corps veteran, she has an extensive background in digital marketing, an MBA and a penchant for true crime, podcasts, travel, and snacks.

https://searchengineland.com/new-microsoft-store-ads-promote-desktop-apps-on-windows-devices-391021